Excuse me guys, what do you think is the best ROTJ edit available?
There are a few ‘Best Edits’ / ‘Recommend me an Edit’ / ‘What are the highest rated Fan Edits?’ type threads in the…
🔢 • What Are The ‘Best’ Star Wars Fan Edits? (subjective discourse on which Fan Edits are highly rated / liked / suit viewers)
…category of An Index Thread for Star Wars Fan Edits and Other Projects…. 👍
Personally, I like darthrush’s ‘Return of the Jedi - Remastered’, and am looking forward to adywan’s ‘ROTJ Revisited’, and snooker’s ‘Revenge of the Jedi’ - when they are finished, of course.
There are 15 or so Star Wars fan edits / similar projects available in…
• 📍 A few available Original Trilogy Preservations - from a long time ago . . . . 📍 | 350+ OT•com projects listed & accessible.
^ Note: You must be a participating member of this site; someone with 30+ posts - not including any ‘shitposts’ or ‘link request’ posts.
Simply send me a PM asking for the project you’d like - I don’t read this thread very often - so you’ll likely not get a reply from me if you make a ‘link request’ post in here for any of the projects featured below…
| Ⓩ • A small number of legacy Star Wars Fan Edits are available… |
|---|
☑️ The Phantom Editor Episode I: The Phantom Edit | a 4.35gb DVD file. | see An Index for Star Wars Fan Edits for more info.
☑️ The Phantom Editor Episode II: Attack Of The Phantom | a 4.10gb DVD file. | see An Index for Star Wars Fan Edits for more info.
☑️ MagnoliaFan Edits: Ep I “Balance Of The Force”, and Ep II “The Clone War” - BOTF: 4.19gb. TCW: 4.22gb. Both are mkv files.
☑️ Jeremy M West-Esquire ‘Anti Cheese Edits’ - Star Wars Prequel Trilogy Edits. | 16.7gb total; mkv files.
☑️ Q2 / Thunderclap The Fall of the Jedi Trilogy - Star Wars Prequel Trilogy Edits. | 12.2gb total; DVD files.
☑️ ADigitalMan Special Editions Saga - Fan Edits for Episodes 1-6 & Episode 2.5 Clone Wars | Re-encodes | 15gb in total; mkv files.
☑️ ADigitalMan Special Editions Saga - Fan Edits for Episodes 1-6 & JW’s A Musical Journey | Full Size Files | 63.8gb total; mkv files.
☑️ TheThirdGathers Backstroke of the West - Episode III Chinese dub bootleg - with humorously bad subtitles | a 4.6gb mkv file.
☑️ LeviSnuts Backstroke Of The West - DUBBED AC3 Audio and Subtitles Files - remux your own BOTW project. | 262mb file.
☑️ mredthefed Heavy Star Wars Prequel Trilogy - Heavy Metal Style Fan Edit - for all 3 PT films | 1.93gb total; mkv files.
☑️ Darth Lunar The Blackened Mantle - a 3-in-1 Prequel Trilogy Fan Edit | a 2.5gb mkv file.
☑️ njvc Pulp Empire | A highly stylized Empire Strikes Back fan edit. | a 3.9gb mkv file.
☑️ Atom-88 Star Wars Saga Fan Edits | Prequel Trilogy Edits - available. 96.5gb total; mkv files. | Original Trilogy Edits - a WIP.
☑️ Atom-88 - a 1080p HD Upscale of adywan’s OT Revisited Edition: Star Wars. | a 37gb mkv file.
☑️ L8wrtr - Prequel Trilogy Edits: Shadow Of The Sith. The Republic Divided. Dawn Of The Empire. | 22gb total; AVCHD blu ray files.
☑️ ocpmovie OT ‘Classic Editions’ Fan Edits : SW | ESB | ROTJ | CE2 | 🔺 The Banning of OCP Movie 🔺 | ocpmovie Megathread
• Mk_9000’s intriguing The Star Wars Fan Edit Database project is also well worth checking through…
In general…
In general, simply sending a PM is the default way of asking for fan projects on here (unless indicated / instructed otherwise in the project thread)…
Please note that cluttering up the project threads with ‘link request’ posts is not only poor form - but is also against the rules & guidelines here - the reasons for which can be found below…
ATTENTION NEW MEMBERS: “Link begging” posts will be deleted without notice - in Announcements
^ Not being able to send a PM because your account is new… is NOT a reason to make ‘link request’ posts on here.
Along with…
❕ Welcome to the OriginalTrilogy.com | Introduce yourself in here | Useful info within ❕ | About | Help | Announcements
❕ ‘How Do I Do This?’ on the OriginalTrilogy.com; some info & answers + member FAQs ❕ | Site Rules | Fan Project Rules
Hopefully the project threads will soon get back to being discussions about the actual projects themselves - queries, feedback, reviews, exchange of ideas, suggestions for future versions etc - and not be full of endless & unnecessary ‘link request’ posts.
We’ve had a number of fan editors, preservationists, tech wizzes and regular members… leave the community in recent times… as many grow frustrated that the forum has seemingly become more of ‘a link request site’. With conversations on the actual projects being disrupted and curtailed by the needless / lazy / aggressive ‘link request’ posts and unsolicited PMs (“I’m not reading your rules or links - just give me the f****** link” - basically ‘I’m not gonna look up how to get this - someone do it for me’).
Fellow members are more likely to help you out if you are a participating member of the community here; you don’t have to be a fellow fan editor, preservationist, tech wiz, artistic or skilled etc… just a member that has made, or is making, an effort.
NOTE: Many editors & preservationists choose not to make their projects available to ‘hit & runners’ or people with a post history of mainly asking for various projects - which is completely up to them. That some people join up here looking to simply take - instead of give something back; not even leaving a simple ‘thank you’, feedback or review, or join in with the community here - and instead move on to asking for more projects… is not encouraged. Such requests may likely be ignored or deleted.
Good luck with it. 👍