logo Sign In

Hal 9000

User Group
Members
Join date
14-Oct-2003
Last activity
18-Sep-2025
Posts
11,348

Post History

Post
#291378
Topic
What is the most distressing aspect of the PT?
Time
Story-wise, I think ROTS is a real let-down. Count Dooku is supposed to be the 8-ball of the Clone Wars, and he's killed off right at the start. Then they introduce Grevious.

I think ROTS would have been better if they'd stuck with their original story ideas. And had the ending be less like a powerpoint presentation. (And have Padme move to Alderaan at the end! WHY DIDN'T THEY DO THAT?)
Post
#288458
Topic
ROTJ: Fan-O-Matic! 3 new clips!
Time
Good ideas, I think!

I'm a dunce at surround-sound editing, but if you or someone can get that line of Threepio's into the surround mix, I'd use it whenever I get around to ROTJ.

Also, do you think the scene where Leia meets Wicket could be safely removed altogether? That way we don't know what happens to her, and the Ewoks are first revealed when the gang are trapped in the net.
Post
#288289
Topic
Lord of the Rings - FOTR - The Book-Cut (Released)
Time
I just started reading the novel for the first time, and this is my first dip into the world of Lord of the Rings.

I don't want to see the movie versions at all until I'm completely finished, so I can be free to imagine on my own at least once first.

However when I do get down to watching them, this edit sounds great. Does anyone have them, who would want to work out a trade? PM me if so.