Very interesting. I like the idea of “A day of revenge, a day we all can share” or whatever, then Poe saying “He’s been planning his revenge,” then “The Final Order begins” and Poe saying “He calls it the Final Order… in 16 minutes attacks on all three worlds begins.”
YES.
(Si, Threepio!)
Excellent work! I think a blind poll like you laid out makes it totally fair for your voice to come out on top. As you say, as long as there are options so each knight can have a unique voice.
I did want to ask, because I honestly cannot tell, was my voice in the sampler? Just find it funny that I can’t even tell if my own voice is there after the effects. Lol (And if so, I’m frankly glad it didn’t make it to the finalists!)
Here’s how it would be with just the TIEs shot.
Cool, man, thanks for the detailed breakdown. I could see something like that working as a replacement for that one line.
In thinking about Mustafar… It’s true that the original idea didn’t really pan out, of making it visually clearer that it was that planet using lava. As it stands we just extended it with more of the same environment. I keep getting, including from people IRL, a 50/50 split on finding the added video game footage believable vs weird. The only relatively noncontroversial shot is poppasketti’s TIEs, but I don’t think it really improves the scene to only add that shot alone. In light of all this, I think it would be better to leave it with the theatrical. 😕
Oh, of course, because you removed Poe’s line and the surrounding reactions.
That plays pretty well. However, it borrows shots from later in the scene and it may not work to lose them.
Yeah, I like NOT having anything capitalized in TROS:A. And, for that matter, nothing in the crawl that would even feel like would need to be capitalized.
“I will earn your family’s saber, one day.”
“You are family.”
If only we had a good source for that. That would’ve been nice.
ALLOL
YES that kid has been terrible lately at night.
I’m just kidding. It was like 3AM for me.
tried a little take on the palpatine message, might be a little too subtle
https://vimeo.com/433918483
pw: fanedit
That’s not a bad idea. If there were enough footage to be able to let it play out before they comment on it I think it’d work. As it is, it makes me wonder why they aren’t listening to it intently until it’s finished.
I haven’t had chance to read this thread as yet, but my personal feelings are anything outside the OT are taboo now.
These two logs may be the other two trilogies.
Who put a hyphen there??
I can, hopefully in the coming day. Should be easy to tell if it’ll work or not.
Chase and I interacting can mean only one thing: sleeplessness.
Good idea!
Oh, well, at least it’s a scene I was already planning to remove.
I won’t say I saved Kijimi, just created an alternate universe in which it survives.
There’s audio? Man I really don’t have this movie committed to memory yet.
w00t
Did they really indicate he translated the spy intel from Sith?
I hope that once jonh finished with the hair, it won’t be too hard to apply the work done to de-blue Luke to that footage.
Yeah, those lines are gone, Muffy. It sounds good as it is, and I don’t think it’s needed to add reverb. Yoda sure didn’t have any in TLJ and the center channel is not totally free of music and ambience anyway.
I originally thought a deleted scene of the broadcast could be interspersed with the reveal of the fleet, but I don’t think the right resources are there to make it work. And it’s pretty much ONLY the added lines from idir that make it worthwhile anyway.
Yeah, Poe is just there to be like “okay guys, here’s the deal, they brought back Palpatine for this one.”
Is there a clip I can reference for that?
I don’t want to re-purpose a bunch of footage from the old movies, as I feel that would be pretty fan edit-y.