ben_danger said:
i really liked it, especially the fact that you uploaded it in a far-from-complete form, which was quite nice to see. the only two things i wasnt too sure about was bens speech on tatooine, im not sure how much it will break up the pacing, but it seems to make alot of sence:
leia goes to rescue han, they BOTH get captured (like in ESB)
luke goes to rescue them, but this time succeeds.
the other thing though is the arrival of the emperor, could you leave this until they go to the rebel fleet? its a good way of establishing a shift in storyline to fighting empire as oppose to fighting jabba.
i liked the alternative fate of the droids, ie being taken straight to the dungeon, and the executor appearance, though vaders little intro may not be necessary. id rather not see him until the second half of the film with the emperor.
Thanks, ben_danger! I appreciate the feedback!
Yeah, I haven't been sure about Ben out Tatoonie...but for me-...well, you can read my reasons in the original post...
It also seems to add a little more to Lukes' side of the story: he's been training all this time with Yoda, learns about Vader, returns home, finds out about his trapped frineds...this is all piling up on him..."I can't do it R2. I can't go on alone..."
Good point about the emperor scene...
I've looked at the vader's and emperor/vader scenes several times...wondering if there's something I could do with them. They're very similar visually...and they don't do much with pushing the plot forward...
I've looked at even combining them (vader lands...then emperor lands...then they have their talk)...but I don't know...
Thanks again!