logo Sign In

Hal 9000

User Group
Members
Join date
14-Oct-2003
Last activity
4-Jul-2025
Posts
11,339

Post History

Post
#42478
Topic
Star Wars Pan Scan
Time
Quote

Originally posted by: ricarleite
With all this digital hi-res TV talk nowadays, and digital recording and stuff... Couldn't the movie makers, studios and TV statios agree on a standart universal format? A widescreen standart ratio, that would be use in every movie and TV show? And every movie theater and TV would follow that screen ratio. And that would end all those problems.



No, bad idea.

Different directors can choose whatever aspect ratio they want. That's an artistic trait of a film.
Post
#40640
Topic
Star Wars Pan Scan
Time
I'll use Back to the Future as an example.

It was shot in open matte.

The "fullscreen" version is still just as horrible as ever, because you can see some revealing set props now in frame.
When Marty is being hanged, you can see a stage hand keeping the rope from choking him in the fullframe version.
A widescreen version is still the correct choice here.




Although, I think the Terminators were shot in an even stranger way...
Post
#39820
Topic
Changes in 2004 DVDs
Time
How old are you, jimbo?


I'm thirteen, and colorizing ANY b/w movie is WRONG. They did that with a special version of some of the 'Twilight Zone' episodes.

I would never buy a pan-n-scan version of ANYTHING. The only 1.33:1 DVDs I own are either released in that format, are documentaries, or simply have no widescreen counterparts.

The original trilogy IS Star Wars. The SE is a rehash of it. I find it embarrasing to watch.

That's why I bought Laserdiscs.
Post
#39061
Topic
Movies that have never been released in original form on DVD
Time
But the point I need to make is, how the hell can anyone act surpised that Lucas isn't going to put the rough-cut out on DVD? He said nine years ago, NINE YEARS AGO thar the "95 release was the LAST TIME the original versions would ever be released on video. So if you where actually paying any attention you'd known that he wans't going to release the rough-cut of the movies on DVD, or VHS, or lazer disc for the last NINE FREAKIN' YEARS.

If I tell you that I'm gonna break your leg, does that make it any less of a bad think when I actually do?
Post
#39040
Topic
BOYCOTT (the 2004 OT SE DVD release)
Time
Quote

Originally posted by: jimbo
Two things. One when baby Herman walks between the ladys dress his fingers have been modified so he no longer pocks her vagina. The other is Jessica Rabbits dress was modified in one scene so you no longer see her ass.



Blunt answer.


But that's pretty much what happens. They also censored some of the scribblings on the bathroom wall that Valient falls out of in Toontown.
Post
#38147
Topic
Okay, what did we LIKE about the Special Editions?
Time
Quote

Originally posted by: Bossk
Well, we've discussed this in the past. But since we have so many new posters around, let's do it again...

1. ESB
2. ANH
3. ROTJ-AOTC tie
5. TPM

You're holding out a lot of hope for Ep3 sight unseen, aren't you, Hal?


From what I've heard so far, it should be good.

That's why there's a question mark (?) included next to it.
Post
#37930
Topic
Reading of the Names
Time
I thought of something that maybe somebody might want to do if they get really bored.


Remember when they read the names of everybody who died in 9/11 on TV?
Maybe we could do this with the petition! And somehow get somebody at Lucasfilm to see it.

Which would make more of an impact: simply saying that 55K people signed it, or a video with somebody reading all these names?
Post
#37728
Topic
Info: OT Bootleg DVDs
Time
There are many more shots modified in ANH than in ESB and ROTJ.

ANH would be the most difficult to do if that were to happen.
ESB would be easier.
ROTJ would be pretty easy. The great middle chunk of the film until the end has no changes. ROTJ just has major changes; keeping little detail changes to a minimum.

But yeah, ANH would be a mess to do.
Post
#37711
Topic
Info: OT Bootleg DVDs
Time
Here's an idea for somebody to do who has the equipment.
Take the O-OT laserdisc set and the SE DVD set.
Transfer both to computer. Then, edit them together so that it is the SE up until a change is made, in which it will revert back to the laserdisc.

That way, you have the best possible picture and sound, and it's the originals!

I can't even begin to attempt such a feat. But that'd be sweet.