I think I'll stick with the "Reinventing the Wheel" set instead of the new DVDs. They look pretty good even for laserdisc, compareable to the new DVDs, are anamorphic, and are not $90. Even if the picture isn't quite as good, it's darn near close, and anamorphic already!
I'm very dissapointed in Lucasfilm for this poor release, so I'm not shelling out $60-100 for them when I have something just as good or better.
I'm downloading them right now, and took a little peek at the video quality from short burts of video it's already downloaded.
And I must say, it's the best transfer I've seen so far. I don't think I'll spend $90 on the official OOT DVDs when I can live with this, which is about on par with it.
Thanks, trickbaxter. Glad to see the PIF system finally starting to take off on it's own. Post in this thread if you recieve a copy and can PIF to 1-3 more people who inquire. Thanks, and enjoy.
I remember, and downloaded, some short clips from ROTJ from tf.n where someone had added flashes and damage to the victims of Luke's saber on the skiff. Was this your work?
^In the Death Star thing, they changed a miniscule part of the frame from English to Aurebesh, Editous. I can't really see it, so I had no idea. I thought the only written English in the movie was on the tractor beam.
Originally posted by: ADigitalMan Does frame 32 indicate this is a blasted interlaced release?
Nope. Here's the caption under that slide:
The original 1977 version of this shot suffered poor image quality from repeated optical compositing to obscure the wheels of the landspeeder with a hand-animated haze.
Ooooh, the library robots deleted scene sounds interesting. So what, are they just going to identify the dart after all so Obi-Wan doesn't have to go to the Diner, just straight to the library?
And if the SE send-back campaign gets organized so I know I won't waste them without cause, I'll happily send them back to LFL. For one thing, I already have a copy.
I have an idea of something you can add to make ANH seem more like part of the saga. Why not add the tombstones in the Lar's yard into ANH in the same place? (Unless they're absent from ROTS. Do we see the same part?)
Quite simply, can anyone tell me how to convert/crop an mpeg video file (namely, the upcoming DVDs) into anamorphic standard size? (While retaining as much quality as possible) Thanks a lot, as this helps with my editing.
I love the idea of extra features with ideas for edits that are better left out of the film itself, to the editor's disgression.
Maybe when you're done with the DVD, you could post a few quick full-resolution mpeg clips for editors like myself to incorporate into our own edits? Although judging from what I've seen so far, there may be nothing to actually improve on your edit!
Hey, at least the colors look right, the saturation and brightness levels are normal, and it actually looks like a normal film before it's candy-coated.
This isn't the right forum, but it's an appropriate question: Does anyone know a good way to convert MPEG from letterbox to anamorphic via cropping, without loosing quality? Give me that info and I'll have a De-SE DVD fan edit ready by September 13th!
Oh well, these look good enough for me. Not as bad as I'd been hearing about.
I'll buy them I think, and begin work on my own somewhat De-SE DVD fan edit, assuming I can find a decent way to convert the DVDs to anamorphic without loosing too much quality.
Well I guess it makes sense, although it was the unfortunate by-product of the technology available. (Notice how all the CGI speeders and ships with antigravity lifts in the other flims don't do that. That's my evidence.)
I am definatley not buying them until I see some kind of video clip from it, or am able to preview them in some way.
I'm undecided. If it looks like something I could live with, but still mumble and grumble a little, then fine. But I will not buy them if they truley do suck.