Interesting idea! I don’t think I will do that, though, at this point. But I like the way you think.
It’s not bad, but I’m not sure its better than what was there.
This one looks good, so the 1080p and DVD versions are up on Google Drive. The others will likely be tomorrow, and I’ll get torrents ready whenever I can, too.
Yeah, no problem!
Let us know how it all goes.
FWIW, Here’s a quick stab at a crawl. Do with it whatever you like:
The spark of rebellion has engulfed the First Order. Supreme Leader Kylo Ren, protective of his newfound reign, searches relentlessly for the source of his former master’s power.
Rey continues her Jedi training under the ailing General Leia Organa, hoping to commune with her spiritual predecessors.
As Resistance operatives pursue intel from a possible spy within First Order ranks, Kylo Ren travels to Mustafar to reclaim his grandfather’s SITH WAYFINDER…
Hi, thanks for the interest. Sounds like you’ll be in for a treat.
As far as viewing order, my edits don’t modify this aspect of the prequels, so whatever personal calculus you would do would apply to these as well. Personally, I recommend release order for a true first-timer, as that’s the most organic presentation of the drama. However, chronological order also works.
If you’re going release order for a first timer, I would just run through the ‘saga’ films first. (You could lead with Rogue One, but ANH is the perfect introduction.)
If you’re doing chronological, I’d put Rogue One before 3 and 4 but skip Solo. (Maybe include the Clone Wars Microseries between 2 and 3 if you like that; part one right after 2 and part two right before 3.)
I’ve done machete order before but I honestly would prefer not to break up the trilogy structure or skip 1. However, whatever viewing order you like should work as well with my edits as with the official versions.
My primary source for these are the commercial BluRays and HDTV captures beaten into shape by schorman13. So. X264 is where they come from and the best output abandoned-in-2011 software can deliver. At this point my project files for the prequels are a smoldering heap that used to be a house; any valuables left inside are beyond my reach now. I’d have to recreate the visual sequence and align all clips from scratch, and there’s no reason for me to do anything like that. The PT is complete and I’m satisfied with that.
I don’t really know much about how x265 differs, but my output should be about as good as the input and that’ll have to do for posterity. Considering several scenes in the PT are sourced from deleted scenes from the DVD releases, I’d say that’s even a good thing to prevent the disparity from being overwhelming.
All films (except Solo and TROS) have finished edits that are watchable. ROTJ is available as a perfectly serviceable workprint, to be filled in with its primary video source sometime soon once I get the new discs. And of course TROS will be a project.
I envy your home theater; I’d like to view these with some friends and family at some point after they’re utterly complete in a nice environment. I hope you enjoy these, and will report back with your thoughts. Even if they aren’t open to new changes at this point, I enjoy tossing things around and interacting with them as complete works.
EDIT: Oh, and if I were going to watch Solo I would pick up DigMod’s edit “The Coaxium Heist.” (My quick edit of Rogue One is merely a partial version of his.)
I’ll be merciful. It’s text against an empty background. (It’s an end credit, once it starts scrolling.)
I agree technically, but it doesn’t register to me as any more of an issue than any other pieces that add up to the very rushed pacing throughout.
No one has found it. Only hint is that it is text replacement.
As Rey arrives at the Lars homestead, add two human skulls poking through the sand.
Ooh, now that’s a spicy butterfly!
Lol, nice. Nobody has found my Easter egg in Ep3, either.
Congrats on finishing (maybe?) a wonderful edit. And for lending a great deal to me in the process.
Thanks, just in case I forget to add!
Maybe a Snoke or Palpatine laugh right after Snoke is cut in half could’ve worked. My only concern about that is it feels out of place in that film, and in the scenes that follow.
Has anyone played with overlaying Boba’s two vocal performances in ESB, time shifting to sync, to see how it sounds? Like his real voice is muffled but just audible over his modulated one?
Hmmm… should I really remove the song Ben Solo was conceived to?
I think that might be just a little bit confusing. i’m thinking of people’s moms.
Actually, my mom has been a hypothetical audience member that I have kept in mind as I’ve done my edits.
Thank you for refreshing my memory.
TROS doesn’t have any alien subtitles, does it? Can’t think of any.
Still waiting to get my hands on the BluRay…
Were there any ideas to tie into TROS that you had considered but decided not to go with?
If SMJ gets to say as much…
Sticking a purple blade into Palpy’s face is what does him in after all.
Thanks for the picture. Glad that exists.
If the crawl suggests Kylo continues to eradicate remnants of the Jedi and the Sith, finding the Wayfinder would seem to just be an accident. That could work, I suppose. Maybe. I still don’t have a problem with the scene in the first place. Nothing wrong with showing him finding it real quick; the movies don’t usually rely on the crawl too much anyway.
When Kylo holds up the Wayfinder during the opening scene on Mustafar, adding one of our patented “Find me”s would help bridge the gap between not having Palpatine in the opening crawl and his unphased determination when arriving on Exogol.