Ideally it’d be great to include, but it just seems like it may be more trouble than it’s worth. But I don’t really know since I don’t do that kind of thing.
Me, too, that’ll work!
I really like having a brief dip into DOTF during the DSII duel. I think it’d be better to take that and sort of quit while we’re ahead.
Which is clarified by an omniscient narrator who has been there the whole movie.
Or, about halfway through the movie, after apologizing for being late.
How the Yoda figure on my computer desk looks every time someone suggests a good change…
As long as this doesn’t feel to abrupt, I think we got it: https://vimeo.com/432014515
In any of the other movies I’d think better of it, but in TROS it’s probably okay.
Boba Fett constantly making random Fett/clone grunt and half-assed scream sounds.
Could you pass along the footage if you have it?
PM sent
Well the puppetry stuff, mostly. In order to remove the bulk of it from the shot facing Rey from the front while DO rolls back and forth, it must be zoomed to the point of presenting pretty rough. It’d need to be… processed in some way. Upscaled, smoothed, or something I don’t know even.
Would it be better (or even doable, because lol I don’t know how to do this) to not have as much of a smoke trail?
Fair. I think if the idea is to telegraph some time gone by, showing them begin to head in a direction makes sense. It’s not terrible for his flashlight not to make a sound.
Much appreciated. When I looked through earlier it seemed like the dialogue was going to be hopelessly mixed with the blaster sounds. If I can’t get it myself I’ll ask for audio maybe.
Anyone already have any good metal clink sounds? Right now Poe’s flashlight makes no sound as he tosses and catches it since I’m trying to keep the full shot while removing the beginning of the conversation at the end.
I should be able to emulate it, so there’s no need for a high quality! Thanks, though; I like that a great deal. Helps to take a look at work already done when I can usually only make brief guerrilla strikes.
Hey, good thinking! Thank you.
And if you can post your clip, too, MR, whenever you can, I’d appreciate it!
Lol I’m not sure why, it just became a gag.
Has anyone whose removed the Finn secret thing found a good way to remove their talk while about to be executed? It happens right up and through the false shots.
Awesome! Makes me feel like I’m publishing a 70’s grindhouse flick. 😃
Here’s poppasketti’s visual and my audio for Ochi’s ship leaving. Be honest, does this feel legit?
https://vimeo.com/431955828
Poppasketti just send me those two shots with Klaud removed, so check that one off!
And if you don’t have his link already, Movies Remastered, ask and you can get it.
I’d be okay with removing the confession thing as long as it’s reference underneath the sand can be handled in a way that is not jarring. Cutting abruptly to Poe leading the way with the flashlight is.
It’s a digital planet. Like, the planet itself is composed of digits and pixels absorbed from a glitchy nebula.
Having the porg sounds linger into the next shot is a great idea!
Klaud is still in the end celebration scene.
I’d feel better about removing the un-explicitly-resolved Finn secret if it can be removed without making the underworld scene feel weird.
And nice poster! I can include it as a bonus, even if another is the main cover art to match the other two edits.
Following the second workprint, here’s everything still needed at this point from others. If certain of these are received I can get to a point of locking down sync of the edit and be able to get other things ready to go. Again, I hope to expedite this in order to avoid it being stuck in limbo once the Fall hits and I have even less time to put toward it.
The yellow lightning was meant for a ‘Rey Nobody’ version, to distance her from Palpatine, with the added meaning of her saber being incorporating or accepting her shadow. But the majority opinion seems to be that blue is better, even for that alternate version.
Related: For the regular Rey Palpatine version, should Palpatine’s fingers crackle when we first see them? Might just remove it in both versions. Why make it any more obvious than it already is when Rey shoots lightning what the reveal is gonna be?
“Why did the Emperor come for me? Why did he want to kill a child? Tell me.”
“Lol, didn’t you figure it out when you shot lightning? You’re Dooku’s great-granddaughter’s sister.”
Welcome! I’ll send you one.
Hal are you planning on adding Luke and Leia’s theme over their training sequence? I feel like it’s a lot more appropriate.
No, as much as I love that music this scene is focusing on Leia in particular after we are introduced to her saber. It makes sense as is, and plus it would probably be really difficult to do since there’s sound effects flying around everywhere.
I don’t feel the need to make a point of bringing Finn down much.
I’m hesitant to remove the Finn having something to say thing because it’s a good chunk of what implies he’s Force sensitive. I already used poppasketti’s Rey voiceover in TLJ to tie into this even. And I find it awkward to cut out the reference to this in the sandy underworld.
We don’t really see any birds or porgs on Ach-to so it feels sort of weird to add foley for something not even there. Maybe they migrated South to an evil island.
I removed Rey’s line (“…really difficult”) rather than Finn’s (“we just landed”), since Finn doesn’t speak for a while otherwise.
And I added a little more of the DOTF from Solo to bridge more smoothly into the existing score.