Hal 9000

sade1212 said:

I posted a test of black robe Rey earlier in the thread

I think it looks perfect.

Welcome aboard, Sasquatch! Thanks for the kind words. 😃

Nice work! Did you patch using the soundtrack?

I think Jyn’s dream fits well as she heads to Jedha; she is tapping into old memories she has run from for a while.

One more.

The good thing about that, though, is anyone could revert that to the original and both options would exist in the world.

CaptainFaraday said:

Also, am I too late to send an audio file to be added to the "For Skywalker!"s in the next release?

“Send them in.”

Well put, I endorse that read on it. The line about Dooku just felt incongruent, but there’s nothing that would conflict with any EU material suggesting Dooku instructed him.

I believe he is altering the Death Star laser corridor with the guys in harm’s way shot to match Rogue One. (ANH and presumably its reuse in ROTJ)

I don’t see anything at all wrong with the footage of that establishing shot. Then again, I didn’t notice anything off about the Mustafar game footage either. I think it’s a nice shot to add some breathing room before we are introduced to a new location. I agree I could do without a wipe transition, but I like it.

And as much as I appreciate it, sherlock, I will leave the music unaltered.

I’m sure it could be done, but I don’t think it really amounts to much, yeah.

Can anyone post a clip of the altered shot with the blue milk from TM2YC’s edit?

Quick note: the line en route to Jedha, “We find Saw, we find your father,” is present in some form in all but the LFE channel so I don’t think it’s worth going to lengths to remove.

I thought it was fan-rendered, but it makes sense it’d be from a video game.

I guess video games have come a long way since I regularly played any. So, like 2003.

The Alan Kloss clip. The forest feels foreign… I’m not convinced it’d be a good fit.

What’s the source?

The serious answer is that his fighting style doesn’t speak to this at all and he comes across as a total novice with no actual saber skill beyond mechanical ability.

DigMod is the senior RO guy, so I’m open to whatever!

I agreed with removing character introductions though, so I imagine leaving that as is…

Whoa! That’s pretty nice!

And Burbin, that’s a step up with the castle shot.

About the trees, I read the scene as it stands as the forest being below the castle so there wouldn’t be trees up that high to see during the first shot. The trees don’t match between shots but I bet real forests can be that way too, maybe?

Hmm anyone want to add a pine or two to the main scene? Lol

And yeah we have delved into the opening, but it’s important as it opens the whole film and we’re waiting around for the last few main pieces.

Let’s just drop the subject here and carry on. I don’t think there’ll be much use in keeping it up.

Yeah, messing with their material stands to violate the prime directive and be trashy. Let’s leave them to it.

I kind of like naming Mustafar in the crawl, so I wouldn’t remove it. It still wouldn’t be clear what planet it is to someone only watching through the main film series otherwise. It is only Rogue One that shows us this location.

It’s all vaporware until there’s something finished and put out there.

I’m not concerned about it. I don’t think they’d have much of a leg to stand on if anyone did want to lift their work which is based on copyrighted works, but I don’t think we’ll even need to. We’ll do what we can and it’ll be grand.

“Would you like to discuss this with the Hutts? I’m sure they can settle this.”

I don’t know Rogue One like the back of my hand, but it makes sense to me. One of these days I’ll catch back up and can try addressing these in my NLE.

Sure, but I’m just looking at it from the perspective of someone watching through the main movie series.

I think keeping his orders a secret until Chirrut’s comment about killing would work even better in an edit where we see that Cassian is willing to kill people in cold blood from his first scene.
I could see either approach working well. I’ll have to think about it I guess. Good conversation, you guys.