DuracellEnergizer said:
Makes you wonder why he didn't give any of the PT villains redeemable qualities if he's so uncomfortable with stark black-and-white morality tales.
To be fair, he didn't give any of the PT heroes any redeemable qualities either...
Does anyone know how Chewtobacca is converting this to DVD5? It might be faster for me to convert it myself than to download it. I just tried AVS2DVD and HCENC kept crashing.
Let's ask Harmy about these things before that sort of step gets taken...
Rox64 said:
Nice to hear that, there were some visible crushed blacks in the first release. Can you please tell me one example of completely crushed blacks that Harmy was unable to fix it?
I believe Snicker posted a Blu-ray shot of the DS landing bay, where you couldn't see as far down the hole the stormtroopers fell down because the shadows got completely black higher up than on other transfers. But the thing is, while technically crushed, it didn't look unnatural--at some point the hole was going to get pitch black, the point just moved a bit. I'd agree with Harmy, there may be some crushing here or there, but not enough to make it especially worse than any other transfer of another film IMO.
AFAIK, blacks that were truly crushed out of existence (the data is gone) could not be recovered except via Snicker's method which were not used here. However, there are a LOT of cases where blacks were crushed to the point of imperceptibility (there was data to work with, just not visible), and Harmy was able to recover those.
It's a possibility in the future. Right now we have no Japanese source files to work with. I'm just happy we have the dub...
Or maybe a more general question: at this point, are there any known bad sites for this?
delusions_of_grandeur said:
EDIT: I should mention that the torrent I downloaded from 1337x.org contained a badly damaged MKV, and though I had it recheck my download against the torrent, I was still left with a damaged MKV. Fortunately, I was able to download it from another (non-torrent) site.
Crap, that's where I'm downloading from. Anyone get a successful download from there?
Yes, unless Harmy decides to alter something and re-render, which I think it's safe to say he's going to avoid at all costs now...
Happy Birthday Harmy, and thanks for the extra birthday present in my PM's!
Nearsighted Scrappile said:
Does anyone have access to the Project Threepio folder for this?
PM sent, but please let Harmy reply first before doing anything with my link. He may have modified things.
EDIT: This was resolved using the official files.
The wookiees had a role in the rebellion?!? Which one? Itchy?
That's part of why I'd like Harmy to do ESB next instead of ROTJ. With Puggo and -1 projects still outstanding, there's always a chance we'll get some good new source material for Jedi at a later date. At the very least, we'll get frame-accurate subtitles if nothing else. But improved Lapti Nek footage would be awesome as well.
Bingowings said:
[INSERT REVISION HERE] for no definable reason.
Any estimates on the availability of the alternate encodings (448/lossless)? Speaking for myself, I'm fine with DTS-MA or a bunch of FLAC/WAV files for lossless, but I could see why others would prefer FLAC/WAV.
I'm only partway through the new version and have to say I can't hear too much difference compared against V1. Either it's my ears or a testament to how right you got it the first time.
I don't know... to me, that's a lot like saying "I don't mind Hayden Christensen in ROTJ because he always intended Anakin to be in that scene." Hayden hadn't been invented yet either ;)
pittrek said:
Hell YEAH !
This will be a day long remembered ...
It has seen the end of CGI Jabba... and will soon see the end of Joh Yowza.
Thanks for all of your hard work on this! I am very excited to hear this, and although I'm probably NOT one of those with a nice enough system to hear the benefit of lossless, I'm also still excited about the lossless release, because... well, why not... I might have a nice system someday before I go deaf...
I know you get a lot of this, but your work is always stunning. I may not frequently write about how impressed I am, but it's all been said before. You are truly an artist.
EDIT: Also, I have tried my hand at audio editing somewhat recently, which just makes me all the more impressed with your work...
Ah OK. Carry on.
B-but that only leaves us with... Stinky Dinkins! I would never have guessed that dream team!
Me too, but I've found it next to impossible to use of late, so I'll be trolling some of the more usual suspects looking for it.
Yeah I'd have to say Han's head jerk in the Falcon was my only major gripe with 1.0, and only because it reminded me so much of the Han's Special Edition head maneuver. Everything else is just gravy... delicious, delicious gravy...
It's already uploading...
Also, Harmy, when you have the time (months away, I know) I'm interested in what you did for merging the commentary track with the 93 audio, but for the other two films.
Royal Albert Hall ;)
timdiggerm said:
Aaaaaaaaaand there goes one of the classic OT.com gripes.
Not really. For example, was it always Lucas' vision to have Luke scream when falling into the chasm in ESB or not? Whichever answer you pick, George has unquestionably changed his vision over time on at least SOME matters.
That said, I agree with the principle that actually George hasn't changed his original vision very much. I believe he always intended to do things that would have resulted in the OT sucking, but either due to youthful humility or necessity, he originally took the advice of others to make them much, much better films. But there are also plenty of things he could never have reasonably intended.