logo Sign In

Burbin

User Group
Members
Join date
17-May-2020
Last activity
8-Mar-2024
Posts
493

Post History

Post
#1436241
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

TestingOutTheTest said:

You really think that just because something is mentioned in the movie and has no evidence refuting it, doesn’t mean it’s automatically true? A fact is a fact. There’s nothing contradicting Kylo’s intentions to kill Palps.

And Palps wants to be killed, so Kylo saying he wants to kill Palpatine doesn’t tell us he’s doing anything against Palpatine’s plans at all, saying he wants to stop him would clear up any confusion on whether he’s on Palpy’s side or not.

RogueLeader said:

Yeah, to me, the throne = power. Kylo doesn’t want to be a Sith, but he wants that power.

The issue I have with that is that Kylo just spent the last movie working to take a throne that represents power, introducing another throne that represents power that Kylo wants to take just feels like a regression. And like Jar Jar said this is called the Sith throne, so more than power it represents a legacy that TLJ Kylo wouldn’t have any interest in, it makes more sense that he’s looking to make his own throne stronger so to speak, rather than trying to take a new one.

As for the crawl, I agree with changing “attacking” to “silencing”, other than that I don’t think it should be changed. I think it’s better to keep whether or not Kylo’s really on Palpy’s side ambiguous until he reveals his true plans to Rey (rather than saying “he sees him as a threat!” from the beggining), and instead focus on the “threat to his rule” being the flames of rebellion ignited by Luke… “see you around kid”.

Post
#1436085
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

sherlockpotter said:

Again, I like what you’re going for; I just don’t think the film shows it in any meaningful capacity. Especially “He’s willing to gamble with the devil” - that would have been so cool! But as the film never really does much with the idea of Kylo double crossing Palpatine aside from one or two throwaway lines. There’s no scene where Rey wonders about Kylo’s loyalties, or where Kylo openly goes against orders…It’s all played very straight. He says he’ll help Palpatine, and then he tells Rey he won’t. How compelling. But the key is, none of it changes how Rey sees Kylo at all, or how the audience sees Kylo at all. So any potential nuance or intrigue is nullified.

Oh yeah, in the theatrical version Palpatine just feels like a Snoke replacement so that Kylo regresses into “overturning his Master to take his place” mode like TLJ never happened and becoming the Supreme Leader meant nothing, him telling Rey he has “other plans” rings hollow.

But with these changes to the crawl, and removing his interest in “taking the thone”, the point of focus would now be on the conference scene where they talk about the how the fleet will turn the FO into a true Empire and increase their resources ten thousand fold. Since from the crawl we now know the FO is struggling with the growing uprising and Kylo’s looking to increase it’s power, we can now see this as Kylo’s main interest. He even says on that scene “prepare to crush any worlds that defy us”, so it’s not like this is something we’re completely making up, just giving it the focus it deserved.

And by removing Kylo’s interest in the throne, you remove his apparent allegiance to the Sith. I prefer the implication that he is just flat out against Palpatine’s plans and is just trying to use him (taking a gamble by confronting him and pretending to do his bidding). It feels more in line with the Kylo from TLJ, after all Palpatine is basically a symbol for resurrecting the past, the opposite of Kylo. That’s also why I really liked your change to Kylo’s line to Rey “we can stop Palpatine”, which aids in feeling like Kylo really has “other plans” of his own.

Post
#1436075
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

sherlockpotter said:

Fair point, Burbin; I think I may be conflating the theatrical crawl and the Ascendant crawl in my head. I’ve been pondering over this film so long, everything is becoming a blur haha.

I guess as-is is fine, then. Personally, I think I’d still rather have the change though. If he’s going after the hidden power because it would “allow him to destroy any threats,” that implies to me that he’s choosing a certain side; and I’d rather keep his motivations more ambiguous. But like I said, I guess it’s fine to leave it.

I think telling the audience Kylo is in need of more power to shut down the threat of rebellion is great to telegraph his shifted motivation being solely focused on the Sith fleet. His rule is under threat and he needs more resources, it makes Palpatine’s offer more enticing without telling us what side Kylo’s really on. And the fact he’s willing to gamble with the devil for it makes the growing uprising seem like a real threat.

Post
#1435953
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

That’s my thinking too jarbear, adding some anti-FO/Luke grafitti and changing some stormtrooper lines instantly alters the context of the FO troops raiding homes and holding people. Basically hinting that there are people out there that have hope and want to push back against the opression, but they’re not united (yet) and as such they’re caught in a constant struggle. That would still gel with the depressive state of Kijimi while offering another hint at what’s to come.

sherlockpotter said:

Burbin said:

…There is enough of a backbone of elements like these that do seem thought out…

That’s pretty much the one thing I’ll flat-out disagree with you on, mate lol. I don’t think the story was well thought out at all; and one of the things I love about Ascendant is that it actually provides much of the backbone that was missing in the theatrical (like when it sets up the galaxy rising up in the crawl).

Like I said I don’t think the film is a secret masterpiece for this, it was clearly rushed out and mangled in development, with things shifting around in the middle of production, the end product is a garbled mess. I’m not saying it was well thought out, but to say it was not thought out at all would be disingenuous. There are clear throughlines and intentions within the story and characters, some we can disagree on, some are muddled or underdeveloped, but they’re there. It’s the reason Ascendant has been such a great project, because there’s stuff buried in the mud that can be drawn out and polished.

Post
#1435859
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

sherlockpotter said:

It’s not a conflict with his character arc - it’s a conflict with the mechanics of the story.

The main reason I went about altering the dialogue was because it contradicts the new through line that was added in Ascendant, of the galaxy rising up. Right in the new opening crawl - “Flames of rebellion burn across the galaxy”… it creates a conflict if we say that the galaxy is rebelling, and then Poe claims that “Maybe it is over. Everyone is so afraid. They’ve given up.”

So yeah, Poe’s hopelessness works in the theatrical version, where the galaxy has given up (until Lando gives everyone an off screen pep talk); but if we want to establish that the galaxy has been working on this since Crait, Poe claiming that the galaxy is “afraid” and “has given up” comes across as incongruous. The restructured dialogue effectively conveys the same ideas of Poe’s hopelessness as it did originally, just without that contradictory aspect.

I don’t see it as contradictory, the point of Poe’s arc is that he’s wrong, both in the theatrical and in Ascendant, to think the galaxy has given up. That there are other people out there willing to fight. In TLJ he learns to embrace the role of a leader, here we see he feels the burden of taking over such a role. So his focus is on the strenght of the Resistance, we see him scold Rey for staying behind when she’s the best fighter the Resistance has.

The new crawl serves to tell us the state of the galaxy, so that we can accept it could come together in such an incredible fashion by the end. But it doesn’t mean Poe is aware of everything that’s going on, he didn’t see the kids on Canto Bight recounting the tale of Luke, he didn’t notice the puppet show on Passana and he walked right past a Skywalker mural on Kijimi. To him the Resistance forces are dwindling, and it’s all on his shoulders. He comes to the conclusion everyone is too afraid to join the Resistance, but reminiscing with his old friend Zorii helps him think outside his Resistance shaped box, that there are other good people out there and so the Resistance isn’t alone in it’s fight against evil.

The way I edited it - or at least, the way I envisioned it 😉 - it would only serve to enhance everything you’re saying about Poe and his journey. The difference is that rather than “nothing character #156, introduced two minutes earlier” Zorii telling Poe "Ehh…I’m sure there are other people somewhere! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ ", it becomes an actual moment - a scene for Poe to see for himself (and for the audience to see) that the galaxy hasn’t given up on their cause. He helped inspire the galaxy by his actions on Crait, and now the galaxy is able to inspire him in return. It’s tangible, and concrete; it’s much, much more than Keri Russell saying “Cheer up there, bucko!” as her seventh line of dialogue.

Fair enough. Though I remain skeptical it can be done seamlessly, as I feel there would be something more to this scene if it was actually made with this intention, I would like to see it. But I don’t think the dialogue should be trimmed… the role of nothing character #156 is small, but as I’ve said it’s there and it does serve it’s function. I’m not saying this movie is secretly genius or anything, but there is enough of a backbone of elements like these that do seem thought out, if rather rushed and not perfectly executed, so we should strive to work with these elements and improve them where possible, being careful not to make cuts that might end up doing more harm.

Post
#1435850
Topic
The Clone Wars: Refocused [COMPLETE] + Subtitles for season one!
Time

Congrats on finishing season 3! I started watching the first few episodes but I think I’ll wait for the season 1 polish/reordering before I continue and make any comments. I also checked out S03E00 - Tales from the Clone Wars out of curiosity. I’m a huge fan of the Tartakovsky series and I really loved S01E00, however I felt a bit mixed with S03E00. I found the tween animation of Forces of Destiny very jarring when mixed with the beautiful frame-by-frame animation of the Tartakovsky series, there’s also a clash in tone from FoD being more light and kiddy, to CW being more intense and action-heavy. For example, cuting from Mace taking down legions of super battle droids to Padmé and Ahsoka taking a casual piloting lesson has a bit of a tonal whiplash.

I wonder if these issues could be mitigated by sticking the FoD segments together to create a single “Tale from the Clone Wars” that is closer in lenght to the Dantooine and Illum segments. It would begin with Ahsoka training with Anakin, then imply later that day she meets Padmé for security duties. Then the following day all three depart on a mission together, ending with that nice Ahsoka/Padmé interaction. I think these three stories have a nice natural progression and would flow together well.

Also I think Kit Fisto on Mon Cala makes for a better opening, it’s a quick and simple battle that sets the stage for shorter stories, and it begins with a bit of narration that the other segments lack. With these changes the episode could be ordered like this:

  • Jedi Master Kit Fisto leads the battle on Mon Cala
  • Ahsoka recieves training form her Master and Yoda, and meets/bonds with Padmé
  • Jedi Master Mace Windu leads the battle on Dantooine
  • Barris recieves training from her Master, and Yoda and Padmé appear again.

Then finally you bring things back to Ahsoka and end with the ceremony. The only thing that would be left out is the segment where Ahsoka and Padmé are flying around in space, which honestly I think is pretty weak and random, and I think the other FoD segments are stronger if they’re the ones where we see them bonding for the first time. Ahsoka telling Anakin “I like her” in “Unexpected Company” lands better if they’re not previously shown taking space strolls together.

Post
#1435841
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

I just don’t understand why the dialogue needs to be gutted though, in my opinion it’s much better the way it is originally. I don’t think it works to splice the Crait line before “maybe it is”, it breaks the flow of the conversation, and I don’t get why you’d remove “Everyone’s so afraid. They’ve given up”. This doesn’t contradict Poe’s development from TLJ, and is integral to his arc: Poe still believes the Resistance is the spark, but he laments so many people haven’t joined the Resistance because they’re afraid/given up. When Zorii says “there’s more of us” she’s telling him there are more good people in the galaxy, good people who’d be willing to fight. This is something he still believes (which is why she tells him “I don’t believe you believe that”), he just has moments of doubt, such as this, the scene on Leia’s death bed, and the ‘lowest point’ of the battle on Exegol.

Poe’s arc in this movie goes hand in hand with it’s main theme: he goes from believing the Resistance has to fight alone, to putting his faith in the people, The people who come together and (in this version) Rise in the name of Skywalker. He basically goes from only focusing on the spark, to actually letting it light the fire that brings the First Order down. Poe’s conversation with Zorii is a key moment for the story and his character arc, and is one of the few legit callbacks to TLJ. I don’t think it’s a disposable, meaningless moment… and I don’t think it should be tampered with.

We can add signs of rebellion on Kijimi without interfering with this, in fact it could heighten the fact Poe is so focused on the struggles of the Resistance he’s (partially) blind to signs of the external growing uprising. Maybe the moment he listens to rebellious calls could work, if it can be done seamlessly, as the moment he regains his hope/faith in the people, but I think the previous dialogue with Zorii shouldn’t be altered.

Post
#1435742
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

I think adding a Luke graffiti in the background and some stormtrooper lines that imply they’re looking for dissidents should be enough to imply there’s more of a push against the Fist Order on Kijimi, which naturally changes the context of the First Order patrols, and does build up on the Skywalker spark/flames of rebellion without interfering with the film.

Post
#1435413
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

Hate to be the sourpuss over so many of these proposed changes, I just think the original scene/dialogue is fine as is.

Changing Zorii’s line to “I don’t believe that (the war is over)” suggests she has a stake/opinion on the ongoing war. Along with the rest of the dialogue changes it makes it seem like she’s basically admiting to Poe that she’s part of the Kijimi rebellion, right after saying she’s planning to abandon it all and flee, alining with Poe’s sentiments that everyone’s giving up. It’s just an odd contrast. I feel the Kijimi rebellion stuff should be kept as subtle background since we’re so limited on what can actually be shown, bringing it to the forefront just exposes the limitations of being a fanedit.

Post
#1434307
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

The image of Luke Sywalker holding a lightsaber plus the Rebel symbol should be enough to convey to the message. Perhaps the graffiti could be placed on top of First Order propaganda? Plus whatever axlanian can do audio wise.

I think the idea is that the First Order is being spread thin by the growing uprising (which would make Palpatine’s fleet so alluring to Kylo Ren). I believe that’s what the new crawl aims to convey, plus the idea that Leia has been trying to unite these segregated acts of rebelion, which does a lot to make the giant civil fleet at the end more believable. The puppet show on Passana and the graffiti work to make Luke the ‘symbol’ of this uprising, which culminates in the “For Skywalker!” chanting on Exegol. This ties things directly to the ending of TLJ, and it adds a new layer to the title of the film.

Post
#1433758
Topic
Star Wars: <strong>The Rise Of Skywalker</strong> Redux Ideas thread
Time

Jar Jar Bricks said:

Eh, whatever. The only reason I brought it up is because I enjoy having Kylo being independent from Palpy with his own goals and motivations. And since he’s the Supreme Leader of the First Order, I prefer to have them be two distinctly different organizations. One much more concerned with militarism, and the other wanting to instate a Sith Empire.

I agree, if anything they should be separated more, not blurred together.

Post
#1433329
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

sherlockpotter said:

Are you talking about the video cutting from the lightsaber to Rey’s face? I only did that because someone mentioned her lips reading as “all the Jedi,” so I cut the video to avoid that. I agree with you, myself - I like the pacing better without cutting the video, but that’s not a huge issue either way. (I was going to send Hal the audio, and let him decide whether to cut the video around it or not.) Just in terms of the line audio though, do you have any strong opinions of anything that stands out?

I believe sade actually stitched the shot of Rey to alter her mouth movements, so that it reads as “I’m a Jedi”, that’s what I meant works seamless/flows naturally.

As far as audio goes I don’t really have a sharp ear for issues so both sound good to me, only difference I hear is your version goes a bit faster that sade’s I think, and also there’s an audio pop on your version though that might just be the streamable compression.

Post
#1433320
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

DominicCobb said:

Who was it that did the little purple/blue flash in the saber? Is that available to grab?

oops, I’m sorry I didn’t understand you were referring to the shot I edited since the ongoing combo was about the Exegol fight, glad Hal’s already got it to you.

Burbin said:

I’m not sure what the differences are but I think sade’s extended “I’m a Jedi” lands more naturally:

I was referring more to the timing and the way he stitched the shot to avoid cutting to Rey in the middle of the line, I think it works pretty seamless and flows nicely.

Post
#1433205
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

I’m not sure what the differences are but I think sade’s extended “I’m a Jedi” lands more naturally:

sade1212 said:

sherlockpotter said:

Hal 9000 said:

Also, sherlockpotter, did you stitch the very end of the “I am all the Sith” shot onto the end of “no match for the power in me”? If so, bravo, because I can’t tell unless I’m reverse engineering it. lol

All credit where it’s due: sade1212 is the one who did the incredible work restructuring Palp’s dialogue; I just stapled my line onto the end.

Yeah, I stitched the two Palpatine shots together. All the lossless footage for that, and all the necessary audio for switching Palpatine’s lines (plus my version of “I’m a Jedi”) are up on my Mega account here (My post about this is somehow now ten pages back because of how active this thread is!). I tried to not use too many files so all the (single-channel) audio clips are in the one mp3 and the Ascendant/Theatrical flavours of the stitched together Palpatine shot are both in the same mp4.

Post
#1433102
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

sherlockpotter said:

Yeah, Burbin, I suppose I see the use in including it earlier rather than later. But I don’t think any of that is strictly “necessary,” you know? Like, Palpatine not trusting Kylo is made apparent at the end (and, I think, works better if it’s not spoiled beforehand), and Rey not being a Jedi is spelled out elsewhere.

I don’t undermine the idea or it’s excecution, I just think when weighing either option keeping the Palpatine/Kylo interaction is more significant to the plot and characters than explaining how Kylo got to Endor, specially since as it’s been pointed out Kylo had access to the dagger and was in cahoots with Palpatine so it’s not really a hole that needs to be filled.

As for Palpatine’s relation to Kylo, I prefer it to be as separate as possible from the Master/apprentice dynamic Kylo just got away from in the last movie, it’s much more interesting to have it so that neither really trust each other (and for good reason) but they need one another. Palpatine needs Kylo’s help to end the Jedi and restore the Sith, Kylo needs Palpatine’s fleet to turn the First Order into “a true empire” and extinguish the flames of rebelion. He has to pretend to go along with Palpatine’s plans to avoid having him and his fleet turn against him, he basically has a gun to his head, so he goes to hunt Rey down as instructed while secretly planning to recruit her to take down Palpatine.

I think that’s a way better motivation for Kylo than the one in the original film, and the changes done so far have really helped push things in that angle, those include Palpatine threatening Kylo early in the film (first with the spirit transfer, and later with his fleet) so we see they’re not really on the best of terms.

Post
#1433060
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

sherlockpotter said:

Then, for that Kylo scene, get rid of the entire ADR conversation with Palps. It’s all useless, repetitive dialogue that really doesn’t progress the story at all, so who cares about that.

I think the moment the scene is placed in V1 it helps keep Palpatine as a looming threat (where in the original he just kinda vanishes for the first half of the film), and it sets up a bunch of things: Palpatine immediately starts suspecting Kylo wants to betray him, and Kylo deflects the question, which helps with the new direction we’re taking Kylo where he doesn’t want to “take the throne” and inherit the Sith legacy. Palpatine also immediatley threatens Kylo with turning the Sith fleet against him which helps explain why he’s “working for him” despite the conflicting interests.

And his answer “I know where she’s going, she’ll never be a Jedi” also builds on (and helps spell out) Rey’s struggle in the film, and it sets up their confrontation on the DSII. With the original placement of the scene the setup and payoff were pretty much immediate (or reversed in the case of the “betray Palpatine” reveal), now it’s set up early and paid off across the latter part of the film. So I think it’s a pretty useful scene.

Post
#1432584
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

Personally not a fan of the “voices”. The film offers a simple explanation: the spirits of the Sith live inside Palpatine, that’s it. It’s fine that this concept is only introduced in this film because it just builds on Palpatine’s character of pure evil, I wouldn’t want to overcomplicate things, it would be retroactively odd to never see or hear anything like that from Palpatine anywhere else before. Maybe it could work to replicate the raspy voice from ep. III as a callback(though I don’t think it’s necessary), but not anything as excessive as a legion of voices.

I don’t like the parallel to the Jedi voices, it basically puts them on equal ground, where I feel it works better to imply the Sith are essentially trapped inside Palpatine as a hive mind whereas the Jedi are free individuals who each have their own free will and literally stand on their own.

And there’s also the issue of muddling things even more, firstly with the opening scene where Palpatine speaks in the voices of Vader and Snoke, despite neither of them being part of the Sith conglomerate, and secondly with the whispering dagger, which I think should stand as it’s own separate dark side thing, and not imply Palpatine is literally guiding Rey around, specially since Hal has removed the “I never wanted you dead” angle and the film is already stuffed with “Palpatine was behind it all” elements. Just my two cents on the matter…

Post
#1431872
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

Burbin said:

The close-up shot of the children looking over is a bit awkward since they look to the right, but the following action of the puppets is on the left (the walker winding up the fire), I looked at the original scene and noticed you reversed that shot, but I think now it makes more sense to leave it with the children looking left at the walker that’s about to shoot.

Here’s a quick mockup with the shot unreversed, so you guys can judge: https://vimeo.com/554532367

I think it flows nicer, it feels like the children go from looking at the alien guy over to the puppet action, and also it matches the following shot of them laughing.

Post
#1431863
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

The close-up shot of the children looking over is a bit awkward since they look to the right, but the following action of the puppets is on the left (the walker winding up the fire), I looked at the original scene and noticed you reversed that shot, but I think now it makes more sense to leave it with the children looking left at the walker that’s about to shoot.

Post
#1431600
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

RogueLeader said:

https://streamable.com/h1f3ot

The puppet show turned out amazing! I love the tusks and claws on the walker, and I love how the childen looking back and forth makes the interaction of the puppets feel seamless. I’m curious to see how it could be extended but I think it works perfectly fine as is.

It’s a subtle (and wonderful) nod to TLJ but we should be careful not to put too much emphasis on it, since it could end up taking emphasis away from the children, which are an important part of the scene. Also I think the laughs of the children should be a bit louder to match the volume of the alien speech, that would help blend the two elements together.

Post
#1430709
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

Also I really like changing Kylo’s line to “we can stop Palpatine” -

sherlockpotter said:

So I made a quick mockup. Is it worth trying to iron out the new line? https://streamable.com/4tms6i

It actually makes it sound like Kylo is against him, against the Sith (which is what we want). We’re told killing Palpatine results in Sith spirit transfer, and we learn later Palpatine wants to be killed, so saying “we’ll kill him” doesn’t explicitly mean he’s working against him. Changing this line would avoid any confusion, it makes it very clear Kylo doesn’t want to play into Palpatine’s hands, he wants to stop whatever he’s planning (and take over his fleet).

It’s also a more seductive way to present it to Rey, who set out on her mission “to stop what we both know is coming…”. It makes it sound almost reasonable to join forces with the Supreme Leader to stop the return of the Sith, instead of the original’s “let’s become super evil together, you know what you need to do”.