logo Sign In

sherlockpotter

User Group
Members
Join date
31-Jan-2021
Last activity
4-Nov-2026
Posts
753

Post History

Post
#1691983
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Exactly! I just think that if both transports take off at the same time, Rey would have seen both, and it would have been obvious (to her and to us) that J.J. did the ol’ switcheroo with the ships. This way we can preserve Rey’s horror, while also having a little “hidden details” moment with the other ship.

But that sort of “I don’t see anything”/“It’s right here.”/“Oh there it is!” response is exactly what I was aiming for, so thank you!

Post
#1691868
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Okay, I made some tweaks to the double ship shot: I’ve shifted it over a bit (now there’s not a straight line directing the viewer’s gaze from Rey pointing, to the first transport, to the second transport), and I’ve also made it disappear into the clouds faster (this also helps to hide potential jankiness in the animation); but, trying to be fair to the audience, I’ve also made the second ship larger.

I’m aiming for something that the viewer shouldn’t even notice unless they’re specifically looking for it. Did I go too far, though? Feedback, as always, is appreciated.

https://streamable.com/8ejvqm

Post
#1691565
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

I was thinking about adding the ship to the Finn shot, but like I said, it’s a tricky balance to find. Since the ships have to take off from the same spot (and are presumably going to the same place), they’d be roughly the same size in-camera. And the ship is so close, and therefore large, in the Finn shot. When Rey says “There must’ve been another transport,” it means that the other ship must have gone completely unnoticed, which is why I think it would have to be a “blink-and-you-miss-it” situation.

Or, we just don’t duplicate the ship at all, of course.

Post
#1691455
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

I don’t know that Chewie’s death was ever “believable”; but then, I never really thought Luke was going to fail to destroy the Death Star either - that doesn’t mean we should remove the Trench Run. I guess it’s important to consider the characters’ perspectives - what’s true to them. And ideally, showing Chewie here might make Rey’s perspective of the event feel more authentic.

Similarly, just because someone knows what’s going to happen doesn’t mean we shouldn’t treat the story seriously - otherwise there’d be no point in rewatching anything ever. As it so happens though, I’ve actually shown Untold to a few people who haven’t seen the original, and they all seemed to like it! My goal here isn’t to improve a bad film; my hope is to make a good film, period.


As for the scene in question, I’ll be honest, I’m having trouble finding the right balance. It needs to be significant enough that it doesn’t look like a mistake, but short and inconspicuous enough that no one will notice it unless they’re looking for it. And of course, I have to consider my own lack of expertise with these sorts of effects.

I’m not sold on my handiwork, but suggestions are welcome!

https://streamable.com/j9hii9

Post
#1690902
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Honestly, I’ve gone back and forth about referencing her parents in this scene. I think ultimately, I lean towards not including them - the problem with making her abandonment/parent trauma so central to her character is that she never gets any sort of closure with it. So at that point, making such a big deal about it here is basically writing half of a character arc. At least, it would be in my edit; I know you’re cooking up something different.

So at that point, what do we think: does showing Chewie add enough to this scene to outweigh the blatant deception to the audience?

Post
#1690832
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Hi everyone, v1.1 is nearly ready! I had one other idea though that I was hoping to get some opinions on. What if we show Chewie “on the transport” before Rey blows it up? It’s obviously incredibly deceptive from an editing perspective; but it might also make the apparent urgency feel more believable and less contrived.

https://streamable.com/cn0aeb

Or, an alternate version: https://streamable.com/3smu8y

Post
#1690304
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

aero177 said:

It was a bit difficult to describe, but I found some photos I took of a bonfire to explain better. the flatter, dimmer looking fire comes from a night scene that is darker than real life, so the camera is exposed for the fire. When the scene is balanced, the fire will still look ‘normal’, just brighter, maybe a touch of highlights in the flame center, but the scene will still have lit detail. An overexposed night scene will look brighter than real life, and that is what causes the fire highlight clipping, but even then the clip is only the inner part of the flames, with an orange clipped highlight, just like in the TLJ frame.

in this case it makes sense for your scene to appear more evenly exposed with small hints of highlights, rather than reducing the exposure even more to pitch black, and then nuking the flame lighting, those are opposite ends of scene exposure. It seems to be early morning right before the sun rises (seeing how the lighting changes at the end of the clip), so it makes sense that scenery is visible, while not blowing out the fire.
I hope this explains what I meant! https://ibb.co/yBFk4hpS

Those references are super helpful, thank you! I do think that those test shots still seem too bright and not like nighttime, but I made some adjustments to try and get closer to that “true to life” shot: brightened the shadows, lowered the white spots, reduced the color spill. I also tried to experiment a little with making Luke slightly brighter that the fire; I dunno, it seemed like a fun idea.

Is this any better? https://drive.google.com/file/d/1f1x0zyWHduF_lLOFHbZ9MnEOjlg464wb/view?usp=sharing

Post
#1690008
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

That’s really good feedback about the technical side of all of this, which admittedly, I hadn’t thought too much about. Of course, the compression isn’t helped at all by the fact that I posted that as a lower quality clip. Something like this would be closer to the final product, compression-wise. It might look a bit better? (You might have to download it to get the full quality.)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1COJJ_C5y-sMJqr-HQflinmJRk2xYstsf/view?usp=sharing

aero177 said:

From a “realistic” camera perspective, if the scene was exposed for such jet black shadows in the new regrade, then the fire would look like the 1.0 grade, because the scene is already very underexposed.

Correct me if I’m wrong - and I well might be - but if the scene was underexposed originally, nothing but the fire would be very visible at all, yes? So if the exposure is brought up enough that we can still make out some things like the rocks behind Rey (which we can still see), wouldn’t that cause the fire to blow out? Like I said, I’m not an expert at all. I just saw TLJ and TROS back to back and it really stood out to me how dim and sad the fire looked.

Post
#1689719
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Hello, all! Here is the new color grade I’ve been working on, for the Ahch-To sequence. Ahch-To was originally recolored to nighttime in Ascendant. However, it bothered me a little that the fire, as a result of being filmed on a bright day, is relatively underexposed to how it should appear now in the darker environment. For example, compare the burning tree in TLJ to the burning TIE in Ascendant/Untold.

I wanted to see if I could make the fire brighter; and that, consequently, led to an entire, shot-by-shot, element-by-element, ground-up regrade of the whole scene. I’m no expert on the science behind it all; but I did try, from an artistic perspective at least, to create accurate exposure, glow, color dispersion, lightcast, etc. from the fire. I also wanted to gradually transition the light during the scene - from night, to twilight, to dawn, and finally to sunrise - which also meant additional adjustments to those same lighting characteristics.

This is a very intense reworking of the color palette, so I’d really appreciate feedback!

VIDEO: https://streamable.com/cf5qg0

Post
#1689043
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Hi everyone! I’ve been away for a bit, but I’m back now, and I wanted to give a quick update.

I’m currently working on a v1.1 update for Untold, taking into account some of the feedback here, as well as some additional tweaks that I want to make. The most significant thing is some new color grades I’m working on, as well as some adjustments to the audio mix.

I know that some of you have messaged me asking for a download link; however, I’d like to get v1.1 out before I fill any more requests. I’m hoping to post some of the update work on here very soon to see what you think.

Thank you for sticking with me!

Post
#1686096
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Octorox said:

sherlockpotter said:

EddieDean said:

WOW! Just watched this, and it’s an extremely impressive edit. Technically flawless (well, could you turn up the initial Sith voices a bit?), but absolutely every narrative change landed for me
…
I was always a Rey Palpatine purist, because I figured Disney won’t let us ignore that canon forever, but until the Mouse forces my hand, this is my new primary version. Excellent work.

Not gonna lie, I was worried when the new Rey movie was announced that it would invalidate what I was working on - at least that problem has been averted for now! I’m hoping TROS having such a negative reaction will encourage Disney to not mention the Palpatine stuff again, even if we do see Rey again in the future.

Thank you for the feedback as well! If anyone else notices anything that needs to be tweaked (such as turning up the Sith voices), please let me know!

I hope that my comment did not come across as overly negative. I want to emphasize that you really did a great job with this!

Oh gosh, no, not at all! You were very kind, and your critiques are legitimate! (Some of the more structural ones may not be straightforward to address, but it’s definitely worth thinking about for potential future updates!)

I can’t improve if I don’t know what to fix, you know? That’s all. :)

Post
#1685914
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

EddieDean said:

WOW! Just watched this, and it’s an extremely impressive edit. Technically flawless (well, could you turn up the initial Sith voices a bit?), but absolutely every narrative change landed for me
…
I was always a Rey Palpatine purist, because I figured Disney won’t let us ignore that canon forever, but until the Mouse forces my hand, this is my new primary version. Excellent work.

Not gonna lie, I was worried when the new Rey movie was announced that it would invalidate what I was working on - at least that problem has been averted for now! I’m hoping TROS having such a negative reaction will encourage Disney to not mention the Palpatine stuff again, even if we do see Rey again in the future.

Thank you for the feedback as well! If anyone else notices anything that needs to be tweaked (such as turning up the Sith voices), please let me know!

Post
#1685911
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Hi everyone, I just wanted to say thank you to everyone who’s watched and commented on Untold! I’ve really enjoyed reading all of the positive feedback to the project, and I’m so glad this version seems to be resonating with so many others!


oojason said:

This was truly a memorable and project - proving just what can be achieved by the amazing talents on here.

Kudos and credit to everyone involved on this - and to sherlockpotter especially for pulling this all off - my cap is doffed.

I’ll be watching this again come the weekend. And likely again soon after that as well.
 

Thank you, oojason! To echo this point, this was absolutely a collaborative project, and I couldn’t have done it without the community sharing their time, talents, and ideas. Not to mention everyone who contributed to Ascendant before this. I’m standing on the shoulders of giants, and I’m incredibly grateful to all of you!

Post
#1684936
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

KumoNin said:

Vader ruins his entire life and body and destroys the whole Jedi order, and, after decades of tyranny, rectifies this by sacrificing himself for his son and the galaxy. But Kylo’s story is different. Bringing home the lost boy is the goal for Ben since TFA. I know he’s like 30, but his arc is painted more like a tantrum-prone teenager who goes down a dark path and eventually realizes the error of his ways, because a girl (his peer) and his parents (!) still relentlessly believe in his goodness. His life is not over once he turns back to the light, it’s just beginning. He’s not Vader, he’s more like Zuko. Buut nope, he dies because that would be too difficult to write (although not in the minds of Driver, Kennedy, Filoni, et al, since they greenlit the Hunt for Ben Solo, but I digress)

…

I love your ending where she at least flies off into the sunset with her friends, onwards to new adventures. This is so far the best version of TROS that can be engineered with the material given. Thank you for your excellent work! This was well worth the wait.

I know there was a fair bit of discussion back in the day about making Rey the one who dies while Ben survives on Tatooine. Ultimately, I didn’t go that route because A) I couldn’t think how to do that convincingly, given the amount of new FX work that would seem to require; and B) I wanted to end the movie in more or less the same place as the theatrical version, in case Rey comes back in the future. But it is possible that some editor is pursing that direction still.

And full props to Hal and Ascendant for letting Rey be with her family at the end! Even just moving the chess scene to the end is such a clever, subtle change that adds so much.

Post
#1684933
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Octorox said:

Just took a look at this last night. Really impressive effort overall. In particular, I think the work done to delay the Palpatine reveal into later in the movie was really effective. My only criticism, and I don’t know if this is colored by my familiarity with the original movie, is that sometimes the sheer amount of ADR and repurposed shots can give the impression that entire scenes were cobbled together in the edit. I particularly felt that way with some of the Hux stuff. However, short of filming new scenes, I don’t think anything can really be done about it.

I saw in the special features you had a segment about sentence mixing techniques, which was impressive since I assumed many of those scenes were AI. About how much of the new dialogue replacement would you say was sentence mixing vs. AI vs. new voice acting?

Interesting question! I went back through the script changes, and here’s the rough breakdown:

  • Approximately 37.23% is original recordings/submitted voice clips
  • 39.31% is completely dialogue spliced out of official audio and dialogue clips
  • 4.95% is mostly dialogue spliced, with some specific AI additions
  • Around 18.51% is completely AI generated

All of those techniques are selected on a line by line basis and interwoven together. Hopefully each feels homogeneous with the other changes (and of course, with the original script). A lot of work was done mixing and balancing everything - volume, EQ, reverb, pitch, etc.

And yes, several scenes were cobbled together in the edit lol! With the Hux stuff specifically, he was originally killed halfway into the film for treason. Since he’s no longer a traitor in Untold, it felt awkward to have him disappear for most of the film - hence the repurposed shots.

Post
#1684035
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Hello everyone, happy Star Wars Day. You’ve waited long enough… and you’ll have to wait just a teensy bit longer, because I’m working on compiling everything together. (There is a lot of stuff to upload.) However, I think Untold is finally ready to release!

I genuinely can’t believe that this day is here - when I started the project over six years ago, I had no idea how much work this would be and how much of my life it would consume (it almost feels strange to share something that’s been so personal for so long); but nor did I know how many wonderful people I would meet in this community, and what we would be able to accomplish.

I set out to make a film that could sit cohesively with Episodes VII and VIII - a film that would elevate the entire Sequel Trilogy, rather than undercut it at every turn. And I think this might be it. I think it’s a significant improvement over the theatrical cut, and I hope you will too.

As I’m getting everything ready, I know that a fair number of you cheeky buggers have already requested the edit, despite it not being released yet. I’m going to try to get to everyone who messaged me; feel free to send a reply to help me find you again.

And while I’m working through the queue, I thought you all might be interested in seeing the new trailer I cut for the film!

To everyone who contributed material, or offered feedback, or even just expressed interest and encouragement, thank you! I hope that Untold was worth the wait!

THE SAGA HAS COME TO AN END

Post
#1678496
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Hello, all! Welcome to what, by all accounts should be our last 2/22 update! (That actually makes me a little sad.)

The most exciting news is that I finally sat down and watched the entire edit start to finish - which, yes, was my first time doing so since the project began. And I have to say… I think it’s better than I ever would have predicted when I started all those years ago, let alone when I first saw the film in theatres. I think it really came together well!

However, true to form, I did make a list of some spots where I noticed things were a tad off - adjusting a color tint here, tweaking some EQ there, etc. I know I said last time that it would be around a month, but we’ve come this far; I want it to be as close to perfect as possible!

In addition, I’m building out those special features I promised. There’s so much I wanted to include in the commentary track, it’s been a bit of a bear editing it all down to time…

All that being said, I can’t keep delaying forever. It’s not fair to you, and it’s certainly not psychologically healthy for me. And so, I am going to announce a hard deadline of: May the Fourth. This is the first time I’m committing to an actual release date. Might even be earlier than that; but short of computer failure, I promise it won’t be later. Just a few more weeks!

Thank you as always for your patience and support. I can’t wait to share it with all of you!

Post
#1676382
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Honestly, I haven’t seen any other TROS fan edits other than Ascendant. A lot of my changes are fairly intricate, and I didn’t want to get different versions of the film confused in my head. It will be nice to check out other people’s work when I’m done!

And as much as Duel of the Fates handles Finn better than TROS does, I do think that its handling of Poe and especially of Kylo is significantly worse. So hopefully I’ve come up with something better here!

Post
#1675794
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Streamable only keeps videos for a limited time, so most of those old clips will be expired by now, unfortunately.

Bingowings said:

One change that I personally feel should be in any edit of this film is if the line”I am all the Sith” is kept Rey should respond “I am a Jedi”. It’s so obvious I was shocked it wasn’t used. Palpatine is vaingloriously declaring himself the accumulation of millennia of evil force wizards and Rey is exalts the power of a single person. That’s Star Wars in two lines of dialogue.

Don’t worry, I was the one pushing to change the line to “I am a Jedi” back on TROS: Ascendant, and I definitely used it here too!

Post
#1675400
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Untold (Released)
Time

Rors said:

sherlockpotter said:

Hello, everyone! Apologies for going dark for so long. However, I think this update will be worth it.

I’ve been hard at work pulling everything together, making final tweaks, updating notes, checking and rechecking every detail; and after almost six years of work, I am excited to announce that Untold is finally going to release! The edit will be a 264 encode, with a 5.1 DTS English audio track, and will also include English CC subtitles, English SDH subtitles, and chapter markers.

Additionally, I’m preparing a few special features to go along with the film. These include a full fan editor commentary track, a brand new trailer, and more. I’m very proud of how the edit has turned out, and I wanted to give it the best possible release. These extras should provide more insight into the thoughts and process behind the hundreds of changes that have gone into the film.

I’m aiming to get it out within the next month or so. We’re nearly there - I think it will be worth the wait!

Runtime??😁😁

130 minutes!