logo Sign In

pittrek

User Group
Members
Join date
16-Nov-2005
Last activity
8-Sep-2025
Posts
2,740

Post History

Post
#723572
Topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Time

Harmy said:

OK guys, how's this:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B0dtCY1O9WXzN2hXRmxGRjU3cFU/edit?usp=sharing

(It's just the new Oscar intro)

 Another tip - sorry :-) I like the "collage" of the Oscar clips, but it would be great to know for what they were received. So something like "And the winner is .... Star Wars" followed by e.g. the on screen text "Film score".

Post
#723411
Topic
How did you first see the Star Wars films?
Time

Star Wars - in the late 80's at my friend's house. He knew I love robots and sci-fi and that kind of stuff, so he invited me to watch " a good robot movie ". It was a high generation pirate VHS, 4:3 P&S, dubbed in an unknown language "overlayed" with a voiceover in another unknown language (I think it was a german dub with a polish voiceover but I'm not sure about that anymore). I didn't understand a word, but I couldn't get my eyes of the TV screen, I immediately fell in love with the characters and the straight forward action packed story.

Empire & Jedi - in the early 90's we got satellite and I've seen these movies on one of the German channels, not sure which one it was. So for many many years the droids have been for me "Tze Drei Pe Oh" and "Er zwo de zwo":)

During the 90's the movies were shown many times on different czech, slovak & german channels, and I FINALLY saw the movies on the big screen for the very first time ever in 1997. Unfortunately they were the SE, but I didn't care then.

Post
#723409
Topic
All Things Star Trek
Time

You know what? During the 20 minutes I actually got emotionally involved, I cared about the characters and what to know what will happen to them in the main movie. I didn't care about anybody or anyone in the JJ movies. So yes, for me it's much better than the JJ movies. Still it's FAR from a great Trek movie (I love movies 1,2,4,6,8), but it's much better than the last official movies. Of course just in my opinion.

Post
#723025
Topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Time

A few more thoughts - shouldn't you mention the PDEs too? If you read these threads, many people are confused about how many different versions are there. Any chance you could mention with just a few sentences what are the differences and why should people skip the previous versions?

You (or the narrator) mention(s) 2 kinds of preservations - laserdisc transfers and DE. Isn't it worth mentioning film preservation too? You know, 8mm, 16mm and maybe with 1-2 sentences mention that a couple of fans are doing a 35mm transfer (possibly without mentioning Puggo or -1 if they won't like it). It would make sense to me to mention these projects here, probably between laserdisc transfers and the DE, because later (I assume) you will be mentioning you used material from these projects?

If you talk at the beginning about the cultural impact of Star Wars, wouldn't be it useful to use a minute or two from either the TV intro or the "Making Of" documentary?

Post
#723016
Topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Time

Good documentary, when will we get the other 3 parts ? :-)

A few points

1) why do you use only Williams' Oscar? I think a better way would be to start with a montage of all Star Wars oscars - I checked and all of them (or most) appear to be on youtube in pretty good quality

2) Obi-wan's scream - please use all versions, not just the first and the last

3) just a tip/question - do you plan to do a more detailed comparison of all (or the most obvious) changes done to Star Wars over the years?