mrbenja0618

I do NOT want to know what Robo is doing!!!! =O

I'm for... But in the meantime, I wouldn't mind seeing your edit. =)  That was my way of getting back on topic.

Is there any way to remove Anakin from the movie? He's not THAT important is he?

Would be great...  But good luck! =)

Here is how I cut it.... There is the shot of them landing, and then the very next shot you see Anakin and Padme leaving the ship.... I never once found it jarring. Just something to look at.

A little late but I did really like the new SW logo. Great work, but I think I prefer it without the glow.... What 3D program are you using?

I would just cut 3po talking in that scene all together.... I don't think you have to show him.... I know you could argue that you need to see R2 following Anakin and Padme, but I cut it where you see R2 show up in nick of time... I like it that way because it's surprise... and it also gives me an excuse to cut his stupid flying.

fishmanlee said:

fishmanlee said:

i proposed in the radical prequels thread to have the crawl text replaced with something like this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HyE1V6Ac49Q&feature=related though obviously withought the moving background and perhaps the voice over intro could be something from Ep III (perhaps Obi-Wan/Yoda/Qui-Gon saying something that wouldnt spoil the Darth Vader/Lukes Father angle) and maybe having instead of the destruction of Krypton it could be something else (Jedi Temple or Anakin burning up, or something)


though i admit this would be very plagiarist and perhaps too un-starwars and hard to do

 here is a rough mockup that worked on for the past three days (the music is temp)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KIJekL2tPDc

Gotta give you credit for that one. Not too shabby. I really don't care to see it in a Star Wars film, but for the sake of just doing it, it's cool.

I always liked how star wars left their credits at the end of the film. I wish more movies would adopt this idea actually. The credits too often pull me out of the movie.

TMBTM used that in his Grindhouse edit I believe.

Nah... But at least he acknowledged all the internets and not just one!

vbangle said: Remember when I was being a douche... I was just picking! I love you all. Rainbows and kittens to all my internets friends! =)

See, it's all good. He's trying to make nice now.

TV's Frink said:

fishmanlee said:

though i admit this would be very plagiarist and perhaps too un-starwars and hard to do

But other than that...

;-)

Hehe.

Bingowings said:

That reminds me of that other spooky old git the lovely Julian Beck (I wish the had got him to play the Emperor back in in 1980 he could have done it without makeup).

P

Thank you. Now I have to go watch 800 Disney movies.

TV's Frink said:

Anakin said:

From my point of view, the Jedi are motherfuckers!!!

:p

I actually laughed out loud when reading this. =)

Thanks everyone. Just noticed there were replies. I'll try that Fan.. And thanks ChainsawAsh... No rush, just whenever you can try. =)

But...Pony rides.... =/

adywan said:

There will always be bits that people don't like in any movie. If i tried to do an edit that would suit everyone then there would be thousands of different versions of ANH:R out there.

If someone wants to do it then fair enough but i won't be having anything to do with it or offering any help because i have too much on my plate at the moment and i need to finish ESB:R as soon as i can

This is why I always say if you don't like it, edit it yourself.

JasonN said:

Ghost said:

mabey Lucas would give Ady permission to use his tech and edit the PT for him.

Only when the devil starts giving out free ice cream cones and pony rides to all the children of the world...

The Devil gave me a pony ride..... Or was it Oprah.... =/

I wouldn't want music there either.

I keep hearing it's a giant leap for Anakin to kill kids.... No it isn't.... He did already.... He killed innocent women and children in AOTC... It's not leap.... He's been in the dark side already. He's been freaking saturated in the dark side like a pig sitting in it's own feces. But that sucks too for the plot. We wanted to see a fall, and Anakin is on his face in the first scene. Brilliant.

TV's Frink said:

Haha. You read my mind... Now would you like a Squishy?

http://www.francesfarmersrevenge.com/stuff/simpsons/simpson16.jpg&t=1" width="259" height="195" />

Jaitea said:

mrbenja0618 said:

I know this is probably the wrong thread for this kinda talk.... And while I appreciate the work, J.... It's just sooo busy. It's so busy that I don't focus on what I should be focusing on... Mt attention should be on Obi-Wan but I'm busy watching all the Christmas lights. Does that make sense?

No, this is the right place to discuss. I know what you are talking about, it does look a bit busy........I could try and tone it down...perhaps replacing the column with a glow that pulsates......dunno.....but remember this is a radical ideas thread....just a cooking pot for ideas.....I'll try and realise your ideas.

J 

The tractor beam changes don't bother me so much as it's more of a enhanced version of what is already there.

It's the little abrupt things that pop up here and there that cause your eyes to go to them. If it was a David Blaine show, maybe I could understand. My point is simply, if you're going to enhance; do it in such a way that it doesn't distract from the story.

However, I have been impressed with what you've been able to accomplish. Would love to see you take a stab at a edit.. And maybe that's you're intention?

I am in need of a whoosh sound effect. Kinda like the one on LOST when they went backwards and forwards in time.

I'm having a hard time locating it. Anyone know where I could go?

Excellent.