logo Sign In

greencapt

User Group
Members
Join date
12-Mar-2005
Last activity
8-Jul-2015
Posts
1,941

Post History

Post
#166685
Topic
Questions about AOTC
Time
Originally posted by: 20th Century Mark
I thought about that as well. In one of the first drafts of the screen play I think that was accually true. But as the story evolved, and I use that word loosely, it was dropped. When Sifo Dyas is mentioned, he was a known Jedi Council member, so I don't thing it could be Palpatine.


I don't know- in PT logic 'magic force monkeys' could have easily flown out of Yoda's butt too so I'd tend to not dismiss anything.
Post
#166680
Topic
EU books: A funny Lucas contradiction
Time
Originally posted by: End Credits
I agree. When I was in the theater, I was like, "um, shouldn't they cover him up?" I mean, I know it was probably for effect or something, but come on. You'd think the people of this hi-tech civilization (or at least George) would know better.


LOL. They should have had one guy off to the side saying "Er, Sir... Mr. Palpatine? Geez sir that looks pretty nasty- I think it might get infected..." Then have the new Emperor, while looking crossly at the person who spoke up, unscrew the lid of a salt shaker and pour it onto Anakin's body... then walk on.
Post
#166636
Topic
EU books: A funny Lucas contradiction
Time
Maybe it was really mega-mega-mega Death Star (sans weapons)! Maybe it started as a small artificial satellite that someone built a house on and it kept growing and growing and being built on, etc, etc.... Maybe the core is hollow and contains HUGE water holding/recycling tanks (I mean I assume they pee and stuff so it has to go somewhere) and then occasionally giant artifical geysers errupt 'rain' over areas of the planetoid to clean it up.
Post
#166635
Topic
Questions about AOTC
Time
Obviously we don't know *exactly* how their government worked but my guess is that *whichever* official representative makes a motion its on behalf of the planet they represent- and a motion is basically just to officially open something up for discussion meaning that even if 15% or whatever of other systems voted 'no' the systems either independently wanting military action and/or already under Palp's sway would have been enough to make the motion pass. Palps just needed someone stupid enough to have the balls to actually bring it up.

As for Siphodious (sp?) I feel it was just another case of too many names for too many superfluous characters and GL just lost track of it or it was meant to be someone else (like Dooku under a psuedonym as discussed elsewhere).
Post
#166623
Topic
Goosebump lines
Time
The 'binary sunset' sequence is a crowning moment of cinema and is a perfect synergy of performance, cinematography, direction and scoring. The ENTIRE message, IMHO, of the OT is told in that one short sequence- with, I'll add, only approximately ONE 'special effect'.

That scene was added on, thematically, in ESB with the 'I am your father' exchange (in which we learn that hope can sometimes turn to despair which in turn can create a direction in our lives) and then in ROTJ with the 'I am a Jedi' sequence and the Emperor scenes which follow (bringing us full circle and showing that mature decisions and the right direction can lead us down the correct path even at the very end).

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v72/greencapt/sunset.jpg




*sigh* Escapist fun yes. Lessons to be learned for a young impressionable mind? Absolutely. I'll refrain from any comments on the PT in this thread.
Post
#166238
Topic
Classic Edition: Return of the Jedi by Ocpmovie (Released)
Time
Originally posted by: Coov
Originally posted by: greencapt
Probably an old question, but hey Coov where I get your fabulous covers????


They are pretty scattered. Most, if not all, are found throughout the covers thread. OCP set some aside HERE...


Thanks! Got them all except the Classic ROTJ you have pictured above. Any chance I could get it emailed to me?

greencapt (at) yahoo (dot) com