doubleofive

Sluggo said:

doubleofive said:

Sluggo said:

doubleofive said:

It's not bad editing.  It's seeing the same event twice from different viewpoints.  There are some movies completely built around that premise.  How else can you follow both the probe droid and Luke at the same time?  Split-screen?

 I gotta disagree with this.  It seems to be two different probes represented by filming one landing at different angles.  This was just a cost-cutting measure by LFL.

Sure, but Ady flipped the reverse shot, so now its even more obvious that they are the same explosion.

 So are you saying that Ady making the two shots into one singular event as far as the story goes?

Yes, they are the same event viewed at two different times, just as I've always assumed (and apparently Ady had as well).

Sluggo said:

doubleofive said:

It's not bad editing.  It's seeing the same event twice from different viewpoints.  There are some movies completely built around that premise.  How else can you follow both the probe droid and Luke at the same time?  Split-screen?

 I gotta disagree with this.  It seems to be two different probes represented by filming one landing at different angles.  This was just a cost-cutting measure by LFL.

Sure, but Ady flipped the reverse shot, so now its even more obvious that they are the same explosion.

I knew someone would try it. ;-P

Sevb32 said:

Sluggo said:

Sevb32 said:

What I find hilarious is that anything bad about ESB is Lucas' fault, but anything good is Kershner's.

Now you are catching on! It is too bad Kersh was powerless to stop Lucas from meddling with his movie!! :P

I believe Ady was touching up the scenes to remove the footprints from around where the explosion happened.

You are kiddin, right?

No, Ady really has removed the footpri--- oh, that's not what you're talking about.  Pretty sure the ":P" means he's kidding. ;-)

Sevb32 said:

What I find hilarious is that anything bad about ESB is Lucas' fault, but anything good is Kershner's.

Well, he did blame it on Lucasfilm.  And don't act surprised, we do the same thing to the Indiana Jones movies. ;-)

It's not bad editing.  It's seeing the same event twice from different viewpoints.  There are some movies completely built around that premise.  How else can you follow both the probe droid and Luke at the same time?  Split-screen?

We have discussed this, and I believe it was decided that its the same crash seen at two times.  They are identical in every way, so everyone just has to deal with this being the only time in Star Wars where we see the same thing two different times.

Alexrd said:

doubleofive said:

The first page is completely updated with every change Ady is doing.  It should be the first place anyone goes.  Even those who have been here the whole time.

Although I only registered now, I've been reading this forum for a year.

I read the first page but I didn't notice that change, that's why I posted. Sorry once again. Mistakes happens.

It was more advice for everyone, not just you.  Don't worry about it.  :-)

I worked hard on the first page list, want to make sure its used properly.

The first page is completely updated with every change Ady is doing.  It should be the first place anyone goes.  Even those who have been here the whole time.

CompMovieGuy said:

Now that looks a list of someone who actually watched the movies and not someone who just follows the sheep and says "all the even movies and then all the odds" with TFF being the worst, cause it fucking wasnt even close
....and you summed up 4 perfectly, IT WASNT GREAT so people need to get off the notion that it was

I don't believe anyone said it was great.  It was fun, which is more than can be said about TFF, at least in my opinion, which is the point I guess.  These are all opinions.  Just because a majority of people think Star Trek V sucks doesn't mean that you have to think that.  I acutally think its cool that you're giving TFF more than a fair shake.  TFF was actually the first movie I can remember seeing in theaters (I was FIVE), so I guess it will always hold a place in my life (McCoy having to relive letting his dad die will do that to a kid).  But I don't have to enjoy it more than TVH.

Marvolo said:

Hey, Ady, I doubt you even remember me, and I wouldn't blame you. I havent been logged on in a long time. The last time was back before ANH:R came out, and I didnt make a huge contribution to that project. I gave my oppinion here and there when and if I could, and I wanted to say that I think your final product turned out phenominal. Congrats to you and everyone else involved!

 

P.S. I found my username in the credits, and I gotta say that was a bit weird seeing that in a fanedit. I love this forum and to be engrained in one of its biggest project means alot to me. Thanks for throwing that in there even though I feel like I did nothing to contribute to the project.

And now you're in the credits for ESB:R!  Funny how that works.  I look at it more as a "contributions/encouragement" list.  I considered separating the two, but that would have made the compilation of the list 1000x harder.

fishmanlee said:

in ROTJ can the FB be upped in epicness like this?

I don't know how to tell you this, but repeating and flipping shots from random points in the battle and cutting it down to less than 2 minutes does not make it epic.  It makes it whatever the opposite of epic is.

The battle part of the Final Battle is nearly perfect.  That's the difference between the OT and the PT.  The PT is mostly jumping, grunting and hitting each other with sticks.  The OT is a dance with people trying to kill each other.

ben_danger said:

could there be an anti credits roll on ESB:R, like a list of shame where names are displayed in red?

LOL

NO THANKS TO:

The British Postal Service
That One Guy Who Made Fun of Me in Secondary School
Whoever Colour-Corrected The 2004 DVDs

I have to go:

Wrath of Kahn
Undiscovered Country
Voyage Home
Search for Spock
The Motion Picture
Final Frontier

Not that I think SFS or TMP are bad, that's just my ranking.  TFF is bad though.

adywan said:

Ziz said:

Ady, how do you know those other people didn't get your Falcon?  They could have just gotten a $200 model for $6 for all you know!

well i'd say it was highly doubtful. the thing is on the invoice it had June 1st as shipment date so they probably don't even know its been lost. you should have seen the state of its packaging. there is no way it had accidentally  got that way. It looked more like it was deliberately opened. After seeing so many news reports of packages going missing and that postal workers were stealing packages all the time or just dumping mail i'm not surprised anymore when something like this happens. now here's the latest. a postal representative rang me a few minutes ago about my compensation claim. he mentioned that i had gone in and claimed the model so they will be closing the claim now. Well i told him that he would have to prove that i accepted it. i asked him if i had would i have had to sign for it and he told me yes. well i then told him that i did not accept it because it wasn't my model and that i signed for nothing and that the package was reposted to the correct person with a note explaining how they were willing to hand over their item to someone else because they refused to resend it  and if they want to make a claim against the post office i would be willing to testify against the PO. he then said that they would have CCTC footage of me picking up the item and tried to make out that this would eb evidence enough to protect them. Well that's bullshit. i wasn't stupid anyway. i took the model out of the package, kept the model and the invoice and handed back the ripped package . the model was small enough to fit in my inside pocket out of view of the camera, so to them it looks like i handed the package back and walked out. i didn't sign anything. so screw you PO. lol. needless to say he wasn't too happy on the phone.

Just goes to show that England needs more CCTCs to catch other angles!  LOL

You're sneaky and quick thinking.  I would have paniced long ago.

Also very odd that the Mail lost TWO completely different Falcons at the same time.

Ziz said:

Ady, how do you know those other people didn't get your Falcon?  They could have just gotten a $200 model for $6 for all you know!

I thought the same thing, but the chances of that happening are astronomical.  I was hoping that it was going to be Ady's so he could build two, one to BLOW up next movie. ;-)

fishmanlee said:

i dont think even he knows hence the "fatness" of the blades in ANH:R though i could be wrong 

If you look on the images on the first page, you'll see he can do it.

Ripplin said:

doubleofive said:

I HATE CONTINUITY ERRORS!

I'd love to find an old post of yours that says 'I love continuity errors!' but I probably wouldn't find it, right?

If I said it, you would have to take it out of context to do it. :-P

But I think that most movie reviews on posters and trailers do that, so I couldn't be too hard on you.

Ok, if we can combine Angel's panorama with Serji's landscape to make a 3-D field for the battle to take place, we can elimate all continuity errors!  I HATE CONTINUITY ERRORS!

show LV-426 system entrance similar to RETURN OF THE JEDI when rebel fleet jumps to Endor - stars would slow and stop to indicate N+R slowing to sub-light, and the planet+moons in background will grow slowly in size to indicate movement,

But they don't have hyperspeed, that's the point of the sleeping pods.  Or at least, that's my understanding.

And I would change "Revisited" to something else, to avoid confusion.

Serji-X Arrogantus said:

Bare in mind that this is still just a test shot and Adywan may decide to take another route with this, but here's what I've come up with to show a sample of what might be possible in helping with this scene http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wseA4UHgS8Y

The AT-AT model is one I downloaded from Sci-Fi:3D just to help add a focal point to this shot, the scale of the walkers is probably out, but you get the idea, also it isn't walking, they're having a rest after a busy day of shooting rebels !

Awesome!  Yes!  You can do this in 720p, right?

Seeing some of the stuff done on the Prequel Radical Reduex thread and the ROTJ Wishlist, I think that with our combined strengths, we CAN do anything.

Darth Solo said:

^Stryker.....stryker????

STRIKE-HER!

(Im sure theres an Airplain reference there some where).

We have no tower sir.  Only a bridge.

Its my opinion and the opinion of my friends that he is smelling the troopers and reacting like they smell bad.  It's juvenile, yes, but its still funny!