doubleofive

Ziz said:

Either don't overuse it or take it to the extreme.  What could be funny would be to have everyone scream the same scream in the scene when Vespa takes out the whole squad chasing them to Lone Star's ship, right at "You shot my hair!"

That would be awesome, if it doesn't sound too ridiculous.

I agree completely!

Someone already made a partial refit Enterprise they were going to use in the Phase II fan episodes:

http://www.startreknewvoyages.com/images/sneek/PIIent0000_st-MED.jpg

The problem/blessing about this: it's made by Daren Dochterman, the visual effects supervisor for The Director's Edition! I'm not sure how willing he would be to help a fan film of the film he helped basically fan film a few years ago, but it might be worth a shot to ask him to render us some new quick shots. I follow his blog (http://blog.darendoc.com/), but when I posted a link to the Special Longer Version, he removed it for fear of looking like he was supporting piracy. Still, he might want to help...

FF, I think you should ask him! Maybe he'd render some Klingon battle shots!

Added Ming's suggestion the ship(s) that crash into the DS shield should be Y-wings.  You don't see many of them in the battle, might as well get them out of the way early!

Ackbar's on a collision course with AWESOME!

This is the first time they've ever been compiled in one post, so no worries.

These are the "official" pages:

ANHR

ESBR

RotJR

Revisited Series

OriginalTrilogy.com

BarBar Jinkx said:

the only reason I mentioned it is because for some reason it is popular with my peers

Then I'll mention "Napoleon Dynamite".  Perhaps the least enjoyable experience I've had watching something, and I've seen the Star Wars Holiday Special.

Another highly lauded movie that I did not enjoy was "Juno".  Ugh.

MORE MOCKUPS!  (as you can tell, I'm excited about mockups)

3-way Battle in the Cloud!

Which inspired this poster/DVD cover:

The mockup is available in full-res by "View Image", but I'm saving the full resolution poster for later.

EDIT: I've tweaked the poster further, but I'm still leaving this first draft up.

Bingowings said:

I know it's the wrong thread but it might be a great opportunity to point out this ROTJ Wishlist suggestion.

Add some “signature” pilots who can die in the main battle and we’ll feel like we’ve seen them before (perhaps including female pilots or an aliens).

It would be great to have a few more people we can root for and feel sad about if they don't make it.

I think Ming should be our signature pilot in RotJ. :-D

Matte him into the briefing, show him shooting TIE's, have him blow up.  Heck, make him the one who rams the Executor!

Rogue Leader said:

However, I'm sure he knows of Revisited and really... I think there's a good reason why Revisited hasn't had the hammer dropped on it. At least I have a good theory. ;)

Inside men have inside theories about Revisited?  I'm worried/excited!

Put Captain Solo in the Cargo Hold said:

I'd do the following things:

1. Removing the CGI dewbacks.

2. Restore the Mos Eisley scene to its OUT state.

3. Have several shots of the Alderaan explosion as in the OUT.

4. Restore the OUT approach to Yavin.

5. Restore the OUT Death Star explosion.

So, the OUT then. ;-)

SilverWook said:

The TOS footage could even be windowboxed, (ala the tv scenes in Galaxy Quest when it was shown in theaters) then you open up to the full theatrical aspect ratio.

I think windowboxing would make it even more obvious that we were reusing unrelated scenes to tell a story.  Cropping it to 2.35:1 might make you wonder where the footage was found a bit longer.

Another scene from "This Side of Paradise", where a smiling Uhura informs Kirk she's disabled communications, and then leaves the bridge might also work in that montage. :)

You wouldn't wonder though.  You're really good at this.  I'll add it to the mockup.

FanFiltration said:

Back to the Future (All of them)

And here I thought we were going to be friends.... ;-)

As others have said, there's something about the original shot, with the sun breaking through the clouds to reveal the city in the distance...  I wouldn't want to lose it.

han-do said:

whats the title of the latest edition?

i really would like to download it but the few dl i found range from 2006 to 2008, no 2009 versions.

There are 3 main versions:

XVID/AVI
single layer DVD
dual layer DVD

They're not titled by years, but the DVDs came out in 2008.  You'd want to find the dual layer version in PAL or NTSC depending on where you are.

Bladerunner wasn't as awesome as I hoped, but I can't say that I "hated" it.

And Lawrence of Arabia was just long, nothing against the movie itself.

Much better!

I like the idea of it overlooking the superlaser (though I think the angle is all wrong currently), but I've always imagined him pointing at the Rebel fleet, or a targeting screen.  Or when I'm being stupid, a picture of Will Riker on the Enterprise ("Fire at Will, Commander!")

Leonardo said:

Hated, hated, hated "It's a wonderful life". Heard so much about it before seeing it, finally watched it, and mentally puked. I think it's overrated (Imdb says 8.7/10), and the story and the characters... please. So, if George had never been born, life wouldn't have been that different for everybody else, and Mary (oh gosh!) would have never gotten married and took the job as a bespectacled librarian!!! What a scandal !!

Bullshit, George, you're not a "lucky" guy, you're an idiot. All of the times you could've gone and chose to travel and lived your life and your dreams outside that stupid little town, you always chose to stay and "help" others, or should I say let them live off of you? I'm sorry, but you're an idiot, George Bailey, you're not an altruist, you're a doormat!

There's not even a payoff for the Mr. Potter character. When I saw it, I was like "WTF movie, aren't you even gonna give me the pleasure to see the "evil" Mr. Potter get punishment?"

Fuck you, fuck you very much, "It's a wonderful life".

That was awesome, and I like the movie!

This is really hard to not make this a "You didn't like that movie?!" thread or in Axia's case "Raging Bull didn't make you want to die?!"

Sorry for all the posts, but they are on different subjects at least:

FanFiltration said:

Question:

Should Ilia be on this ship already as a crew member (remove most of her introduction, but no all of it), and we cut all reference to her sex powers and oath of celibacy? This way, Ilia can meet up in the hallway with Decker just after the ER scene (in which he is demoted) and not after he gets chewed out about not following Kirk's phaser order, in the now deleted Whormhole scene. I'm not sure how this can work. Suggestions??

I think if someone's traits have no relevance to the story (Padme's assassin being a shapeshifter, etc.), then it should be cut.  She never uses her sex powers, so why not just have Decker and her relationship be awkward because its an old relationship, not because she has mystical powers.

SomethingStarWarsRelated said:

Bingowings said:

The direction of the shot should be sorted without resorting to flipping.

Either film new elements or turn as much of the existing element so the inconsistency isn't so obvious.

 I certainly agree there. I think Adywan did that with a few shots in ANH and ESB already...didn't he?

He flipped the entire sequence after Han and Co arrive at Yavin (at least a minute straight of flipped footage!) and he flipped some shots on Hoth of Han cutting the TaunTaun so that its feet and arms didn't change position between shots.

More mockups!  This time I've darkened Earth and used the orbital office complex and drydock from TMP (ignore the Refit already in place there).  I like the idea of the E blocking the stations and revealing them during the shot.

SilverWook said:

Ziz said:

SilverWook said:

I really like the idea of seeing the ship return home at the end of the 5 year mission.

Could Kirk's final log entry V.O. from TUC be reworked for this?

As much as I would like to see that as well, you would then expect to see everyone in TOS form getting off the ship and some kind of scene implying that they're going their separate ways for a bit while the ship gets refit.  That will be very difficult if not impossible to create from TOS footage.

Well, there are plenty of shots of the crew lining up to beam off the ship in "This side of Paradise", plus shots of Kirk packing his belongings. There's also shots of Kirk alone on the bridge. "The Mark of Gideon" also has Kirk wandering an empty ship, but mixing shots of first and second season Shatner would be pretty tricky!

A shot of Spock brooding in his quarters alone from "Amok Time" could emphasize his leaving Starfleet and his comrades. "The Ultimate Computer" has shots of the empty Enterprise corridors going dark. "The Omega Glory" also has some deserted starship shots sans dissolved Exter crewmen. ;)

There are enough shots in other episodes that in a montage could portray a tired, yet happy crew arriving home.

MOCKUP TIME!

They could be faded a bit, could be in slow motion, maybe pan across the 4:3 image.  This could be during the credits, each shot in between a credit or two, then after the Kirk on the Bridge start using the Refit in drydock.

FF, I think the credits have to come first so you could do something like this or just the beauty shots of the Refit.  If not, it looks like the refit occurs after V'ger blasts the Klingon ship.  I'm torn, because I like the idea of a cold open / teaser like the original series!