It is just crushed blacks, not a problem with the 04 recomposite. To be fair though, one could argue that Harmy should uncomposite them back to the original to truly despecialize it.
They successfully out-nerded you then. ;-)
TV's Frink said:
Deal with it.
Let me again point out that my article is based on cap's post and has a link to it. It wasn't my idea, I just wrote an article on it.
The fact that this is a Special Edition mistake is what's really interesting. In recreating the wipe, some kind of half exposed frame was used. The fact that it's coming off a wipe means that it could have been Pacific Titles that made the mistake, but no one noticed during QC for the past 15 years?Mr Ghostface said:
Yeah you've got to wonder either what kind of people they have doing this work, or what pressure they must be under if they're missing stuff like this. It's staggering at times.
No problem, man. I really have a problem if I find something, even if its small, in what I keep calling "what the Special Edition should have been". Ghost Luke is even worse...Mr Ghostface said:
Sorry for my anal comment, then, I get it if once you've seen it you can't forget it. ;-)
I'm in this for the little things. I can't unsee continuity errors, this kind of thing is exactly why I'm helping out with this project.Mr Ghostface said:
Hey I'm not complaining about this edit for the sake of it, Ady did some exceptional stuff. I just find the minute details a little irrelevant, when there are bigger things you could address. So don't polarise what I'm saying, just because I dare to make a criticism. That would be truly sad.
Which is why I link to that post in my article, so people don't credit me.TV's Frink said:
walking_carpet said:
If 456123 does not work, I guess frink and 005 has the next best idea.
I don't know who had the original idea of 451236, but I will continue to point out that cap's post predates OO5's, and I was just agreeing with cap.
It's a continuity error. It's just as justifiable as half of the fixes in this edit.Mr Ghostface said:
LOL a tiny blue rectangle panel on R2... were you joking that it might need fixing or are you really that anal?
Ziggy Stardust said:
TV's Frink said:
I just checked and yes, you are in the credits Zig.
Awesome! Sadly, I can't see the edit. :-( Could you send me a screenshot of it in a PM?
The Purist version is unavailable on fanedit.info due to differences of opinion on what constitutes a "fan edit". The admins don't believe that there are enough changes to the Purist to make it a true fan edit. Apparently 240 changes aren't enough...
But we love them anyway.
Ah, one of the few times that Rinzler's shots from the GOUT weren't replaced by the publisher with the "higher quality" shots from the DVD.
The links seem to use the images from the screensaver collection, which someone uploaded at some point. If Harmy doesn't have them, I've got them available. None of them are any he seems to be having problems with though.
My thoughts, based on conversations here.ray_afraid said:
Back on topic, ruining the surprises of later episodes is like reading a book that begins by telling you how things will end and then proceeds to tell the story as if nothing was said.
It is a really slow start for not that many (good) jokes. And it spoils the best part, Anakin's TRUE parentage!TV's Frink said:
Oh, and I got another comment about the crawl length last night. I'm considering cutting out some of the lines and the first song, which would make it roughly 1/3 shorter.
KNOW YOUR MEME!TV's Frink said:
I've fallen behind on memes a bit. What is that one from (the pic, not the balls).
True, but people won't be begging for new clips from RotJR yet.TV's Frink said:
We could probably discuss this in the eventual ROTJ:R thread, no?
I forgot to give TRM a rating!
http://qkme.me/355ad3
No one said she'll be the only female pilot in RotJR. ;-)
fanedit.info
Indeed. It's similar, but from a different angle.Laserschwert said:
I guess this is the wrong hangar matte?
I think every fan edit should end with it. I'm going to put it on the covers I make from now on.TV's Frink said:
doubleofive said:
I really liked the absolute last credit. For some reason it brought a tear to my eye, but I'm a strange one.
I thought you'd like it.
After the 3rd time I saw my screenname, I was tired of cheering. ;-)TV's Frink said:
Wait...you didn't cheer for your own name? I guess you guys have done more splitscreening than I realized.
I did not, I'm going by the same logic TServo had, we'd have heard if it was the GOUT. Just the fact that the choice had to be made between a new version of the film or a crappy laser disc transfer is what gets me.SilverWook said:
Did you buy the set? Just curious, as I've been trying to find out which version was in it for months now. All the Amazon "reviews" were of no help.
Even the fellow with website showing off his huge SW video collection over at the Home Theater Forum was balking at buying that behemoth!
I really liked the absolute last credit. For some reason it brought a tear to my eye, but I'm a strange one.
And I don't blame you, I blame Lucas for making us have to cut around this thing to begin with.TV's Frink said:
There are a few little bits that could be cut out because they do nothing either for jokes or for keeping any sense of continuity. In fact, that quick shot of Anakin's intro at the podrace ("a local boy") is one that I could easily lose. A couple of ship landing shots also fall into this category. Not sure if it's worth the bother, however. Again, it really doesn't amount to much time at all.
And I like that Qui-Gon looks paranoid during the underwater scenes, always looking for the giant fish which never shows up.