doubleofive

Tobar said:

That would have been neat, canon does support that she was there. But it probably would require too much work to get a hold of a proper Ghost model.

It could also be argued that she missed the battle completely because she was doing a food run and everyone left without her. 😉

EntireSagaFanboy said:

adywan, will you put the Ghost in the battle of Endor?

I think he mentioned he wouldn’t be doing that.

Judge said:

Speaking of mistakes, it’s always bothered me that in this shot - and all the other shots looking out the window of the Super Star Destroyer’s bridge - the hull is not visible (I believe that’s the surface of the Death Star in the background).

Isn’t the SSD supposed to be 20km or so long? Consider this scene from ESB. I always thought the SSD’s super structure should have been visible in the background.

This might be a tricky one to achieve as I’m not sure if there are any quality SSD models out there, 3D or physical.

Back on ESBR, Ady determined that none of the camera angles allowed you to see the super structure out the window, perhaps even deliberately shot that way. Not sure about the head-on shot there though.

You can quote a post with an image to figure out how to do it yourself, but don’t worry, I’m sure Ady is aware of this one, it’s one of the classic “movie mistakes”.

Very interesting!

RiffTrax recently upgraded their download of the HS to a much better quality version. I wonder if they used Zion… Are there any telltale signs?

Warbler without his trademarked *sigh* is hardly a Warbler at all.

I think Frink was joking that Yoda and the Emperor do a lot of stupid things in their fight.

It’s possible he’s freaking out and forgets he has the Force in his encounter with the Rancor. I know canon says Rancors are not native to Tatooine, but I used to imagine he’s facing his greatest fear, the monster he used to hear echoing across the desert. Now he’s trapped in a room with it, and for a moment forgets everything he’s learned.

However, I feel that it would be worthwhile for this edit to attempt to make Luke throw the skull or hit the button with the Force.

Harmy said:

So, would I find volunteers, who would help me by going through Doubleofive’s galleries and putting all the shots down in this table and looking them up in GOUT and BD and putting in the timecodes?

No pressure, eh?

I don’t have a master list of changes already unfortunately, so I can’t get it kick started. But once the list is done, I’d love to utilize it to track which ones I’ve already shared on the @starwarsviscomp twitter.

I’m going to research getting an export from my Google Photo albums to give us a baseline.

EDIT: I’m not having much success in the export to spreadsheet department. I would like to ask that the final spreadsheet have the names of the actual JPGs too, for my uses.

chyron8472 said:

Tobar said:

SilverWook said:

Not sure the world is ready for full frontal Klingon nudity though. 😉

Obviously you haven’t kept up with Discovery. 😐

Wait, what?

Yep.

But he Force grabs the guard’s gun.

SilverWook said:

Once again, an SE shot got into something that’s supposed to be all about the original version. 😕
https://youtu.be/uZKgpzjYaVY
At 2:29.

Jesus

Yeah, there’s nothing wrong with the third moon just not being in shot.

It was two moons until AOTC showed 3 in the sky.

Now that I’m watching it, it makes more sense. This “airplane edit” is shifting aspect ratios, but pan and scanning the slow scenes and widening for the action scenes. It’s completely different shifting aspect ratios from the IMAX.

Not sure it’s worth preserving, but it was at one point Director-approved.

I’ve always liked the shot of Luke grinning at the ghosts, but it sounds like we’re getting a more somber ending for Revisited. Fine with me, since he’s going to find more appropriate music to go along with it.

Collipso said:

Adywan, do you plan on changing the font used on “RETURN OF THE JEDI” in the title crawl to the font used for The Empire a Strikes Back and A New Hope’s crawls? Sorry for asking again if you have already answered this.

He already fixed the crawls!

https://youtu.be/F51kdD6raUc

I think a human/cyborg relations droid expressing pain is different from a box with legs that I think is basically a walking battery?

Obi-Wan never hints that there’s any good in Vader, in the prequels or as a ghost. Padme does, up to the end.

I have the final file, but I don’t think it would help this project.

adywan said:

But that is enough now

Editroid said:

doubleofive said:

adywan said:

Editroid said:

doubleofive said:

Editroid said:

TV’s Frink said:

EddieDean said:

Just another voice to back up this ^.

While the PT isn’t as great as the rest of the saga, a lot of us here do consider it canon and part of the full Star Wars story. So even though it’s understandable that some want to ignore it, please at least don’t make any changes that contradict it!

The PT did it first.

Examples?

Examples of what the Prequels changed from the Original Trilogy? You can find those on many other threads.

I’m sure there are very legitimate explanations for them.

Explanations made after the fact to try and cover up the bad writing

Oh come on, Ady! You know as well as I do that having someone die in childbirth 20 years after writing that her daughter remembers her is poetic and rhymes or something.

In Chapter 19 of Star Wars: Bloodline (a CANON novel), in a voice recording Bail Organa addresses Princess Leia “not expressing much interest in knowing who her birth parents were.”

This means that in that scene in ROTJ, Leia WAS, in fact, talking about Padme, because Luke clarifies that he is talking about Leia’s REAL mother and the recording of Bail obviously is from before Episode IV, which means Leia would have had some form of conversation about the adoption with him FAR before this scene happened.

adywan said:

Explanations made after the fact to try and cover up the bad writing

The point is they shouldn’t HAVE to try to explain it on a novel decades later. Why not just write the new movie to line up with the movie you made years before?

Cool story.

adywan said:

Editroid said:

doubleofive said:

Editroid said:

TV’s Frink said:

EddieDean said:

Just another voice to back up this ^.

While the PT isn’t as great as the rest of the saga, a lot of us here do consider it canon and part of the full Star Wars story. So even though it’s understandable that some want to ignore it, please at least don’t make any changes that contradict it!

The PT did it first.

Examples?

Examples of what the Prequels changed from the Original Trilogy? You can find those on many other threads.

I’m sure there are very legitimate explanations for them.

Explanations made after the fact to try and cover up the bad writing

Oh come on, Ady! You know as well as I do that having someone die in childbirth 20 years after writing that her daughter remembers her is poetic and rhymes or something.