logo Sign In

crissrudd4554

User Group
Members
Join date
10-Sep-2012
Last activity
1-Jul-2025
Posts
1,254

Post History

Post
#941871
Topic
OT Special Editions to have USA Roadshow Summer '16
Time

moviefreakedmind said:

crissrudd4554 said:

I was going back and forth on YouTube

Can’t win there.

Never. That’s why I try to avoid commenting on SW videos as much as possible. I failed this time though granted this was something I commented on like a month ago and only in the last few days has it been going again.

Post
#941854
Topic
OT Special Editions to have USA Roadshow Summer '16
Time

I was going back and forth on YouTube today with someone about the Hayden change. He says its logical because Anakin didnt know what he looked like when he died because he was scarred and hence his appearing younger made sense. I told him it doesn’t make sense since in most cases ghosts can take whatever form they want but I think in Anakin’s cases he would still project himself as an old man since that’ll likely be more familiar to Luke. He wrote back again that Anakin didnt know what he looked like old and neither did Luke cause Anakin’s scarred. My last post to him was we will agree to disagree. I give myself credit. I was going back and forth with him for a bit and not once did I bring up the nostalgia/OUT vs SE factor into it. Hopefully that conversations done but considering my luck these days probably not.

Post
#941540
Topic
OT Special Editions to have USA Roadshow Summer '16
Time

Granted I don’t particularly agree with any of the changes. I get George’s logic behind changing Boba’s voice in Empire but really is it necessary?? Plus the delivery in my opinion is really bad and not convincing. He speaks too fast and it just sounds off. As far as the 97 SE’s go well if I had to choose any versions of the SE’s I probably would pick those. At least some of the changes added from '04 onward are not there. We still get the original Emperor, Ghost Sebastian, no ‘Weesa Free’, and yes the coloring is somewhat closer to the originals. The fact is EVERY version of the SW films are flawed but then again what movies aren’t?? Am I hyped that they’re showing the SE’s?? Not especially but I’d be off me rocker if I said I expected them to show the old cuts, as much as many of us would like them to have.

Post
#940049
Topic
"Lucasfilm currently has no plans to release the original versions of Star Wars"
Time

Wazzles said:

joefavs said:

Can someone quickly direct me to the part where the idea that they’re waiting until next year’s 40th anniversary is closer to make a statement was debunked? Until then, “It’s been four years” carries no weight at all for me.

A journalist for the Wall Street Journal made an article with loads of inaccuracies and said Lucasfilm has no plan to release the OUT any time soon. Master detective work. Completely debunked. Case closed.

It’s on the front page of this thread

Post
#940048
Topic
"Lucasfilm currently has no plans to release the original versions of Star Wars"
Time

Wazzles said:

joefavs said:

Can someone quickly direct me to the part where the idea that they’re waiting until next year’s 40th anniversary is closer to make a statement was debunked? Until then, “It’s been four years” carries no weight at all for me.

A journalist for the Wall Street Journal made an article with loads of inaccuracies and said Lucasfilm has no plan to release the OUT any time soon. Master detective work. Completely debunked. Case closed.

It’s on the front page of this thread

Post
#938468
Topic
If you could only remove one Special Edition change...?
Time

Trooperman37 said:

Wazzles said:

imperialscum said:

TV’s Frink said:

Big fan of Jedi Rocks, I see.

Nah, not a fan of it at all. It is just that the original scene is about as embarrassing as the new one. So I don’t care which one I have to endure.

I disagree in this case. Yeah, Lapti Nek is cheesy, but in a sleazy 80’s way that’s easy to forgive, and fits in well with the atmosphere of Jabba’s palace. Jedi Rocks is cheesy in an uncomfortable 90’s way. I feel embarrassed every time I see it.

In addition to adding a sleazy atmosphere, which you noted, Lapti Nek was written by John Williams. The new one was not if I recall correctly. Also Lapti Nek is consistent with the 80s, and like it or not, ROTJ is an 80s film.

Well put. Agreed 100%