- Post
- #229759
- Topic
- We're Still Immature Whiners to MSNBC
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229759/action/topic#229759
- Time

Tiptup
- User Group
- Members
- Join date
- 4-May-2006
- Last activity
- 26-Apr-2012
- Posts
- 1,696
Post History
- Post
- #229612
- Topic
- The "original crawl" on the new DVD is NOT the original crawl! Screenshot inside!
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229612/action/topic#229612
- Time
Originally posted by: Mike O
I assume that you are kidding?
After all, it's interesting to see the immensely-intellectual depths his viewpoint brings to all of this.
I assume that you are kidding?
Hmm, I'm not sure. Do you assume that I'm kidding?

- Post
- #229587
- Topic
- The "original crawl" on the new DVD is NOT the original crawl! Screenshot inside!
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229587/action/topic#229587
- Time
Still, it's not the real crawl but a simulation. Just another reason not to buy these DVDs.
Anyways, I believe it is unreasonable to consider banning JediRandy. After all, it's interesting to see the immensely-intellectual depths his viewpoint brings to all of this. Sure, he's kind of a dick, but that's not the end of the world.

- Post
- #229578
- Topic
- I got a response from Leonard Maltin.....
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229578/action/topic#229578
- Time
Originally posted by: Mike O
I never said it was. Thanks for reminding me for the 63rd time though.
Its not your movie, never was, never will be.
I never said it was. Thanks for reminding me for the 63rd time though.
Uhh, that's his signature. It's in every post of his until he changes his signature.
- Post
- #229573
- Topic
- What did the Prequel Trilogy need?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229573/action/topic#229573
- Time
Originally posted by: auraloffalwaffle
I think that the Jedi would only get involved when they found out that the Sith were trying to take over the leadership of the senate. This could then logically lead to the senate being turned against the Jedi. Perhaps some systems would side with the senate and some with the Jedi. This would give rise to the Clone Wars. The division of the senate would allow for the systems that stay to become the Empire. The Empire have a clone army which has been assembled in secret, plus a vast fleet of Star Destroyers. This unexpected show of force overwhelms the opposition.
I think that the Jedi would only get involved when they found out that the Sith were trying to take over the leadership of the senate. This could then logically lead to the senate being turned against the Jedi. Perhaps some systems would side with the senate and some with the Jedi. This would give rise to the Clone Wars. The division of the senate would allow for the systems that stay to become the Empire. The Empire have a clone army which has been assembled in secret, plus a vast fleet of Star Destroyers. This unexpected show of force overwhelms the opposition.
That's definitely a good idea right there. But, like was stated earlier, I believe it might be best to have the clone wars in progress as the stories begin.
- Post
- #229387
- Topic
- OUT Audio: Pablo Speaks
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229387/action/topic#229387
- Time
Are there supposed to be links on that site that allow you to play a sound clip from the mix versions?
- Post
- #229386
- Topic
- OUT Audio: Pablo Speaks
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229386/action/topic#229386
- Time
Originally posted by: Moth3r
No, because the first two are in ANH and the last one in TESB!
However, the original mono mix for ANH had both C-3PO's "tractor beam" line and the "close the blast doors" line.
No, because the first two are in ANH and the last one in TESB!
However, the original mono mix for ANH had both C-3PO's "tractor beam" line and the "close the blast doors" line.
Heh. Wow, my mind sure checked out there.
Anyways, is the original mono mix for Star Wars considered the best audio track?
- Post
- #229357
- Topic
- OOT DVDs - interlaced or progressive?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229357/action/topic#229357
- Time
"Deinterlacing artifacts were visible throughout the clip, showing as horizontal combing in every bit of motion and in every shot transition. Speaking with my friends that I attended with, they all saw it clear as day as well. Not good. I’m rather lousy at understanding IVTC, but what I saw on screen was not acceptable."
I'm not sure what he meant about "deinterlacing artifacts" but horizontal combing during motion would be the result of an interlaced image based upon what I know of interlacing. That probably means the source was missing that data. Perhaps they were showing the films on a crappy interlaced projector? I doubt it.
- Post
- #229356
- Topic
- first viewing of the 2006 OOT dvds
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229356/action/topic#229356
- Time
Originally posted by: Marvolo
I got this from the Digital Bits and it pisses me off that the OOT isn't getting the same treatment!
" Moving on this afternoon, here's something else that's very cool from Comic-Con. File this as Rumor Mill-worthy, but I learned while down in San Diego that not only is Paramount working to release The Ultimate Star Trek Movie Collection in high-definition on HD-DVD and (possibly) Blu-ray Disc... the studio is quietly remastering all 79 episodes of Star Trek: The Original Series for eventual high-def disc release as well. Paramount also has sparkling high-def masters of all 4 seasons of Star Trek: Enterprise to release on disc. Can't wait to see all of the above!"
Yeah, George is an idiot. Still, I watched a lot of the original Star Trek as a child and that news makes me excited.
Originally posted by: Darth Richard
The only way he could get my total resect back was if he did an only OOT release somthing like this
Star Wars-
Remastered
Audio choice of mono/70mm/35mm/new 5.1 mix
crawl choice
Empire Strikes Back-
Remasterd
35mm and 70mm version on one disc via seamless branching
5.1 mix
Return Of The Jedi-
Remastered
Audio choice of 35mm/70mm/ 5.1 mix
I would be so happy if something like this was released, all in 16x9 format of course. One can dream though. But I think something like this will be in the 30th ann. boxset. I mean they just cleaned the prints last year agian.
I got this from the Digital Bits and it pisses me off that the OOT isn't getting the same treatment!

" Moving on this afternoon, here's something else that's very cool from Comic-Con. File this as Rumor Mill-worthy, but I learned while down in San Diego that not only is Paramount working to release The Ultimate Star Trek Movie Collection in high-definition on HD-DVD and (possibly) Blu-ray Disc... the studio is quietly remastering all 79 episodes of Star Trek: The Original Series for eventual high-def disc release as well. Paramount also has sparkling high-def masters of all 4 seasons of Star Trek: Enterprise to release on disc. Can't wait to see all of the above!"
Yeah, George is an idiot. Still, I watched a lot of the original Star Trek as a child and that news makes me excited.

Originally posted by: Darth Richard
The only way he could get my total resect back was if he did an only OOT release somthing like this
Star Wars-
Remastered
Audio choice of mono/70mm/35mm/new 5.1 mix
crawl choice
Empire Strikes Back-
Remasterd
35mm and 70mm version on one disc via seamless branching
5.1 mix
Return Of The Jedi-
Remastered
Audio choice of 35mm/70mm/ 5.1 mix
I would be so happy if something like this was released, all in 16x9 format of course. One can dream though. But I think something like this will be in the 30th ann. boxset. I mean they just cleaned the prints last year agian.
Oh how sweet that would be!
- Post
- #229354
- Topic
- Those "Takes You Out Of The Moment" Moments...
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229354/action/topic#229354
- Time
Originally posted by: garethxxgod
I've never felt horrified by that scene although to be objective, I can't honestly remember my feelings as a young child when I first saw Empire. I remember my folks put that Empire was one of my favourite films growing up. I'm assuming though that if I felt anything it was awe.
I've never felt horrified by that scene although to be objective, I can't honestly remember my feelings as a young child when I first saw Empire. I remember my folks put that Empire was one of my favourite films growing up. I'm assuming though that if I felt anything it was awe.
I was in awe od Vader as well, but that never stopped me from realizing that he was the bad guy. Its not supposed to be pleasant to think of an evil man as our hero's father. It wasn't for me anyways. Darth Vader is an awesome villain, not just some random dude who disagrees with the main characters.

- Post
- #229351
- Topic
- If George did release a high quality OOT DVD, what is the worst that would happen?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229351/action/topic#229351
- Time

- Post
- #229349
- Topic
- OUT Audio: Pablo Speaks
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229349/action/topic#229349
- Time
- Post
- #229348
- Topic
- What did the Prequel Trilogy need?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229348/action/topic#229348
- Time
For me, much of what I look for in movies is meaningful in an ethical or spiritual way. The PT was so superficial in this regard and most of my ideas about what would make the PT better work along those lines. Exploring the force and the Jedi religion, or the existence of evil and falling to the dark side, and that sort of stuff.
- Post
- #229338
- Topic
- I got a response from Leonard Maltin.....
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229338/action/topic#229338
- Time
- Post
- #229001
- Topic
- What did the Prequel Trilogy need?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/229001/action/topic#229001
- Time
Originally posted by: Darth-Adroit
I couldn’t have said it better myself. Here’s my suggestion for changes it’s long so feel free to glance at it or ignore it altogether.
- The series should’ve started with the Clone Wars in progress.
- The Jedi are devastated after years of war with few members left in their ranks.
- Obi-Wan does some impulsive and dangerous shit every once in a while.
- It is made clear that Yoda was once Ben’s master.
- Anakin should’ve been from some planet other than Tatooine.
- Establish that Anakin and Owen had some sort of relationship.
- Establish that Ben and Owen had some sort of relationship.
- Ben discovers Anakin, sees that he’s a great star pilot and is amazed at how strong the force is with him.
- Ben should convince the council to let him train Anakin. Yoda will object, but will be overruled by the rest of the council because they are running low on Jedi.
- Ben and Anakin both fall in love with Princess Padme of Alderan.
- Ben realizes the danger and stops making advances on Padme. He tries to convince Anakin to stop as well, but Anakin thinks Ben is trying to trick him.
- Anakin can’t seem to best Ben so he seeks out the dark side in order to win the love of Padme.
- Late in the trilogy Owen gets a land grant. It could be revealed that the grant is on Tatooine or it could remain secret until we see him in Episode4, but it is critical that Anakin doesn’t know where he went nor does he care where he went.
- Padme succumbs to Anakin’s advances and he knocks her up, but he doesn’t know it.
- In the duel with Ben Anakin causes a Star Destroyer or something to destroy the Alderan Royal Palace killing either the King or the Queen.
- Anakin thinks Padme and Ben are dead, Alderan swears off the use of weapons and turns isolationist for a while, cutting itself off from the rest of the GFFA.
- Anakin looses body parts over the course of the films becoming more like the Vader we know and love, but the accident on Alderan messes him up on a whole new level.
- Padme and Ben both survive the accident on Alderan and Vader wants to confirm their deaths, but Alderan’s isolation prevents him form gaining access to the planet.
- When the twins are born Ben immediately senses how strong in the Force Luke is. He thinks Leia might have potential as well, but the force just pours off of baby Luke. Ben convinces Padme to let him take Luke.
- When the trilogy ends Ben has taken off with Luke, Padme stays on Aldrean with Leia and Vader is hunting Jedi.
I couldn’t have said it better myself. Here’s my suggestion for changes it’s long so feel free to glance at it or ignore it altogether.
- The series should’ve started with the Clone Wars in progress.
- The Jedi are devastated after years of war with few members left in their ranks.
- Obi-Wan does some impulsive and dangerous shit every once in a while.
- It is made clear that Yoda was once Ben’s master.
- Anakin should’ve been from some planet other than Tatooine.
- Establish that Anakin and Owen had some sort of relationship.
- Establish that Ben and Owen had some sort of relationship.
- Ben discovers Anakin, sees that he’s a great star pilot and is amazed at how strong the force is with him.
- Ben should convince the council to let him train Anakin. Yoda will object, but will be overruled by the rest of the council because they are running low on Jedi.
- Ben and Anakin both fall in love with Princess Padme of Alderan.
- Ben realizes the danger and stops making advances on Padme. He tries to convince Anakin to stop as well, but Anakin thinks Ben is trying to trick him.
- Anakin can’t seem to best Ben so he seeks out the dark side in order to win the love of Padme.
- Late in the trilogy Owen gets a land grant. It could be revealed that the grant is on Tatooine or it could remain secret until we see him in Episode4, but it is critical that Anakin doesn’t know where he went nor does he care where he went.
- Padme succumbs to Anakin’s advances and he knocks her up, but he doesn’t know it.
- In the duel with Ben Anakin causes a Star Destroyer or something to destroy the Alderan Royal Palace killing either the King or the Queen.
- Anakin thinks Padme and Ben are dead, Alderan swears off the use of weapons and turns isolationist for a while, cutting itself off from the rest of the GFFA.
- Anakin looses body parts over the course of the films becoming more like the Vader we know and love, but the accident on Alderan messes him up on a whole new level.
- Padme and Ben both survive the accident on Alderan and Vader wants to confirm their deaths, but Alderan’s isolation prevents him form gaining access to the planet.
- When the twins are born Ben immediately senses how strong in the Force Luke is. He thinks Leia might have potential as well, but the force just pours off of baby Luke. Ben convinces Padme to let him take Luke.
- When the trilogy ends Ben has taken off with Luke, Padme stays on Aldrean with Leia and Vader is hunting Jedi.
Heh, I was just thinking to myself how the clone wars should have been in progress at the beginning. Now that I'm thinking about it, I believe I expected that before the Phantom Menace was released. Oh well.
Anyways, those are great ideas. If I ever write a fan-fiction of my own I migt have to steal some of those. So many of us could have written a better outline for the PT than George Lucas.

- Post
- #228992
- Topic
- The "original crawl" on the new DVD is NOT the original crawl! Screenshot inside!
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228992/action/topic#228992
- Time
Originally posted by: Shimraa
omg you cant be serious your mad cause they removed teh starwars title and had it move at a different speed... wow...
omg you cant be serious your mad cause they removed teh starwars title and had it move at a different speed... wow...
We're not mad about that exactly. It's more like being mad about that in light of how easily Lucasfilm could have done so much better. I guess it's also sad as well as infuriating.
- Post
- #228989
- Topic
- What did the Prequel Trilogy need?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228989/action/topic#228989
- Time

Originally posted by: Gaffer Tape
But, yeah, the prequels just had to have some alteration on everybody that wasn't a major character. There were so many almost human with a slight difference races.
But, yeah, the prequels just had to have some alteration on everybody that wasn't a major character. There were so many almost human with a slight difference races.
Is it just me, or did the alien Jedi display the most generic and uninspiring designs?
- Post
- #228986
- Topic
- first viewing of the 2006 OOT dvds
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228986/action/topic#228986
- Time
Originally posted by: Gaffer Tape
Wow, you know, it really makes it feel worth it to be a Hyperspace member to be able to see things like that. I mean, wow, clips from 30 year old movies we already own. That's certainly worth paying money for. But what a crappy trailer. "And learn the shocking truth about Darth Vader. 'I am your father.'" Well, I guess I just learned that shocking truth. No need to buy the movie now... I mean, I know everybody knows it, but do they have to trivialize it that much? I don't see any Citizen Kane trailers saying, "And learn the shocking truth behind Rosebud..." followed by an image of... well, I'm not going to ruin it in case somebody doesn't know.
But, anyway, I digress. It was a crappy trailer. They spent more time talking about that damned video game than they did about the theatrical versions. And they made sure to include as many SE shots as humanly possible. "Now more convenient to own!" I really can't understand their contradictory marketing campaigns, especially when it comes to the wonder and amazement of being available separately. Maybe it's just me, but I don't recall any movie company ever bragging about having to buy three movies separately. They usually start raving about movie collections, but I've never seen anybody brag about how wonderful it is to pull them apart. If they're going to market them as being the OOT, then market them as being the OOT. If they're going to market them as being... um, rebellious individualists, then market them that way. Maybe they're just doing it to cover their own asses, so that when people complain, they'll just point to trailers like this and say, "See, we only devoted about five seconds to that part of the trailer," which is probably how much time they devoted to the movies, "so why would you expect it to be that great?" Um, because your evil twin brother marketing campaign tells us to buy them solely because of that.
Uhg, I know, the marketing is probably the most insulting element of this whole fiasco. From the bad-boy hype of "Han Shot First" to their disrespect for the trilogy's greatest moments (they MUST think the PT is better) . . . it’s just . . . insulting.
But, what is their crown jewel to entice customers? The trilogy separated into three individual packages?! How on earth could that fact ever be special to the degree they're promoting it? They should have used the trailer to talk more about the movies if anything. How absolutely blind can they be?
Oh, and did you notice the generic, radio-station DJ they used as the announcer? He tried making everything sound all impressive in his pathetic voice. It was laughable.
Originally posted by: Darth-Adroit
I also agree that we should all do what we can to keep cash out of George’s pocket. I just see that SOME (not all) people are being a little intellectually dishonest about all of this. They say that anyone that buys the DVDs in September is a fool and part of the problem. Then these same people rush off to buy Battle Front 2 and Empire at War and place an even larger chunk of cash in GL’s pocket.
Wow, you know, it really makes it feel worth it to be a Hyperspace member to be able to see things like that. I mean, wow, clips from 30 year old movies we already own. That's certainly worth paying money for. But what a crappy trailer. "And learn the shocking truth about Darth Vader. 'I am your father.'" Well, I guess I just learned that shocking truth. No need to buy the movie now... I mean, I know everybody knows it, but do they have to trivialize it that much? I don't see any Citizen Kane trailers saying, "And learn the shocking truth behind Rosebud..." followed by an image of... well, I'm not going to ruin it in case somebody doesn't know.
But, anyway, I digress. It was a crappy trailer. They spent more time talking about that damned video game than they did about the theatrical versions. And they made sure to include as many SE shots as humanly possible. "Now more convenient to own!" I really can't understand their contradictory marketing campaigns, especially when it comes to the wonder and amazement of being available separately. Maybe it's just me, but I don't recall any movie company ever bragging about having to buy three movies separately. They usually start raving about movie collections, but I've never seen anybody brag about how wonderful it is to pull them apart. If they're going to market them as being the OOT, then market them as being the OOT. If they're going to market them as being... um, rebellious individualists, then market them that way. Maybe they're just doing it to cover their own asses, so that when people complain, they'll just point to trailers like this and say, "See, we only devoted about five seconds to that part of the trailer," which is probably how much time they devoted to the movies, "so why would you expect it to be that great?" Um, because your evil twin brother marketing campaign tells us to buy them solely because of that.
Uhg, I know, the marketing is probably the most insulting element of this whole fiasco. From the bad-boy hype of "Han Shot First" to their disrespect for the trilogy's greatest moments (they MUST think the PT is better) . . . it’s just . . . insulting.
But, what is their crown jewel to entice customers? The trilogy separated into three individual packages?! How on earth could that fact ever be special to the degree they're promoting it? They should have used the trailer to talk more about the movies if anything. How absolutely blind can they be?
Oh, and did you notice the generic, radio-station DJ they used as the announcer? He tried making everything sound all impressive in his pathetic voice. It was laughable.
Originally posted by: Darth-Adroit
I also agree that we should all do what we can to keep cash out of George’s pocket. I just see that SOME (not all) people are being a little intellectually dishonest about all of this. They say that anyone that buys the DVDs in September is a fool and part of the problem. Then these same people rush off to buy Battle Front 2 and Empire at War and place an even larger chunk of cash in GL’s pocket.
I'm not saying that anyone who buys these DVDs is a fool, I just see it, at this point (knowing what we know), to be a bad move unless the money spent is not big deal and the Star Wars trilogy is really that important to you.
Otherwise, giving George money will reward him for giving out crap, but I do not think that causes any problems for us. Even if George Lucas gets less money, that won’t help him change his mind.
From my point of view it’s a basic economic principle only to spend your money on things you want. At this point, I'd rather never see the films again than ever purchase this release. That's the value that I believe everyone else have as well, but if other people feel differently I'm not going to criticize them. George Lucas has effectively destroyed Star Wars for me and that's all.
(Thankfully I still have viewable VHS copies too.)
Oh, and those other products don't bother me if they're good enough. If I want them for the offered price then I'll get them. I don’t care if insane, old George profits from releasing the occasionally good product (he is an impressive business man after all). For example, KOTOR was always enticing. The only reason I never purchase the game was because I knew I wouldn’t have the time to play it and because I like to save my enjoyment of Star Wars for the films only.
- Post
- #228882
- Topic
- first viewing of the 2006 OOT dvds
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228882/action/topic#228882
- Time
Originally posted by: Darth-Adroit
I agree with those that are angry about this DVD release and I think a message does need to be sent I just hope people aren’t fooling themselves. If you are avoiding the September releases to hurt George you had better avoid ALL LFL licensed products or you’re not doing much.
I agree with those that are angry about this DVD release and I think a message does need to be sent I just hope people aren’t fooling themselves. If you are avoiding the September releases to hurt George you had better avoid ALL LFL licensed products or you’re not doing much.
While I don't really go for any of the extraneous products in the Star Wars franchise (most of it sucks), my point is that i don't want to waste money on crap I don't want.
If any of you out there don't mind getting a crappy-bonus-feature version of the original theatrical releases, then I won't blame you for buying these DVDs. Otherwise, George Lucas should not be rewarded for this if any of us can help it. I'll buy the DVD and own it just long enough to help boost the sales figures and then return it, if I do anything.
- Post
- #228793
- Topic
- News on the TV Series if Anyone Cares.
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228793/action/topic#228793
- Time
- Post
- #228791
- Topic
- If George did release a high quality OOT DVD, what is the worst that would happen?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228791/action/topic#228791
- Time
Originally posted by: JennyS1138
Seriously, what terrible act could come of a proper OOT release?
Seriously, what terrible act could come of a proper OOT release?
Well, George Lucas says the theatrical releases are "dead" to him, and perhaps the knowledge that he was the murderer causes the films to haunt his dreams at night. Therefore, if the original versions were resurrected, they might become some horrible zombie that seeks to repay George for his crimes.
(Edit: fixed grammar and a typo.)
- Post
- #228788
- Topic
- Those "Takes You Out Of The Moment" Moments...
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228788/action/topic#228788
- Time
Originally posted by: garethxxgod

This is more of an O-OT complaint than a Special Edition complaint. It's been fixed up for the DVD release and since I don't own a bootleg of the O-OT on DVD, this screen cap from the Special Edition will do. Witihin the original film and still in the SE, this fall always made me go "what the hell just happened?" I still don't get the purpose of this scene (and no doubt some of you will try and put it in perspective for me) and the fall always looked too phony....I can't help it purists but this is one O-OT thing I think was silly. Takes me out of the moment for a second but we're good again once he does get inside the tube although still...wait.....is he just trying to get away from Vader or is he trying to end it all and when he finally gets to the bottom he has a change of heart? heh...anyways.

This is more of an O-OT complaint than a Special Edition complaint. It's been fixed up for the DVD release and since I don't own a bootleg of the O-OT on DVD, this screen cap from the Special Edition will do. Witihin the original film and still in the SE, this fall always made me go "what the hell just happened?" I still don't get the purpose of this scene (and no doubt some of you will try and put it in perspective for me) and the fall always looked too phony....I can't help it purists but this is one O-OT thing I think was silly. Takes me out of the moment for a second but we're good again once he does get inside the tube although still...wait.....is he just trying to get away from Vader or is he trying to end it all and when he finally gets to the bottom he has a change of heart? heh...anyways.
First, that scene where Darth Vader reveals that he is Luke's father is meant to be a horrifying sequence. Our hero being the son of someone so evil is not supposed to be a pleasant thought. This is especially true for Luke who has invested so much anger and revenge towards Vader. Luke jumps to escape it all when he peacefully decides that death is better than falling into Vader's hands.
Otherwise, that fall isn't phony looking to me. It looks great. The tube is supposed to be sucking him in like a vacuum cleaner and so the fall isn't supposed to be completely natural.
- Post
- #228783
- Topic
- Another Form Of Protest?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228783/action/topic#228783
- Time
- Post
- #228780
- Topic
- Do you think they'll fix the sound issues?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228780/action/topic#228780
- Time
- Post
- #228778
- Topic
- first viewing of the 2006 OOT dvds
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/228778/action/topic#228778
- Time
Originally posted by: zombie84
Then, the real deal was shown. The cantina scene with Han shooting Greedo first was shown and received a huge round of cheers when Han, did, as they are pushing so hard and handing out buttons to state, shoot first. But, oh boy, was there something wrong with what was on screen. Please set aside the issue of the loss of image resolution that the 4:3 letterboxed discs, as what was seen on screen was far more concerning:
Deinterlacing artifacts were visible throughout the clip, showing as horizontal combing in every bit of motion and in every shot transition. Speaking with my friends that I attended with, they all saw it clear as day as well. Not good. I’m rather lousy at understanding IVTC, but what I saw on screen was not acceptable.
I was rather startled at the dismissive attitude from Steve Sansweet towards the informed concerns highlighted from forum users and industry professionals, and the calculated assurances that he made about the supposed quality of the sources used for this project. His final comments on the issue were basically along the lines of “George considers these versions dead to him, so you should be grateful you’re getting them at all.”
--THX 1138
Then, the real deal was shown. The cantina scene with Han shooting Greedo first was shown and received a huge round of cheers when Han, did, as they are pushing so hard and handing out buttons to state, shoot first. But, oh boy, was there something wrong with what was on screen. Please set aside the issue of the loss of image resolution that the 4:3 letterboxed discs, as what was seen on screen was far more concerning:
Deinterlacing artifacts were visible throughout the clip, showing as horizontal combing in every bit of motion and in every shot transition. Speaking with my friends that I attended with, they all saw it clear as day as well. Not good. I’m rather lousy at understanding IVTC, but what I saw on screen was not acceptable.
I was rather startled at the dismissive attitude from Steve Sansweet towards the informed concerns highlighted from forum users and industry professionals, and the calculated assurances that he made about the supposed quality of the sources used for this project. His final comments on the issue were basically along the lines of “George considers these versions dead to him, so you should be grateful you’re getting them at all.”
--THX 1138
So, the quality of this release will even be below proper non-anamorphic standards?
I was guessing there would be too much data loss. I'm just sad to realize that it's true. Nobody should buy these DVDs. I'm done with the whole deal now. All the excitement I had is now gone. If George ever stops being a dick long enough to treat the original theatrical versions like the amazing historical achievements they are, then and ony then will I come back. I don't need Star Wars.