logo Sign In

Tiptup

User Group
Members
Join date
4-May-2006
Last activity
26-Apr-2012
Posts
1,696

Post History

Post
#289109
Topic
IGN Star Wars movie poll.
Time
I totally understand what you're saying, Marvolo. I too enjoyed RotS when I first saw it. However, once I began watching it a few more times, and I was able to better digest the fast-paced barrage of scenes and events, the movie began to really fall apart for me. I found very little that I wanted to like anymore. There really isn't anything to the movie, but its all assembled and portrayed as if there were (as far as I'm concerned).

Anyways, just to sound repetitive on a Star Wars forum one more time: Star Wars deserves to be #1 in my opinion because it started Star Wars and because I've watched it hundreds of times and it still hasn't really gotten old for me. It's one very good movie from those two perspectives. (Though I do not begrudge ESB being more popular.)
Post
#289009
Topic
LOST
Time
I finally saw the finale yesterday evening. Pretty good stuff. I knew that Mikhail wasn't really one of the others, but now he clearly doesn't seem like he could ever be a benevolent philanthropist in disguise, so I guess that might kill my Alvar Hanso idea.

I'm thinking the coffin contained someone they knew on the island (because Jack thought that Kate would care) and that the person is the kind of person who would seem as if he or she would have loved ones who'd come to his or her funeral (to explain Jack's shock). Also, it seemed like the death of this person provoked Jack's feelings of regret over leaving the Island and multiplied his suicidal mood. Since Locke didn't want to leave the Island, the criteria would all point to him the most I guess.

I just have one problem, when the funeral guy asks Jack whether he is friend or family, did you guys hear him say "either" or "neither"? I have two friends who heard "neither," but even when I listen closely and try to hear "neither" I still hear "either." Both either and neither create problems in terms of guessing who was in the coffin, but I don't know.
Post
#288589
Topic
A Crime, but Not by the Man Doing It
Time
Hmm, what's the argument in this thread about exactly?

People can read or not read if that's what they want. While it's kind of sad that the practice of reading is declining (and that I don't read more books myself, heh), a book store owner's warehouse doesn't necessarily speak to that fact directly. I suppose I find his burning of books to be an interesting way to promote reading (if that's what he's doing it for). Otherwise, I don't see the controversy here. :\
Post
#288490
Topic
Blu-ray (or HD-DVD) questions
Time
I'd hope that all movies being put on HD-DVD or Blu-ray are transferred in their proper aspect ratio and that the players are then properly programmed to alter that ratio for specific TVs based on what the viewer prefers. That would be the smart way to ALWAYS do it considering how DVDs were often so crazy when it came to aspect ratios.

Otherwise, lordjedi, I don't think new codes would erase the old codes (if they did that would be just-plain sick). So if your old discs need the old code, it will still be able to play them.
Post
#287659
Topic
Darth Vader's Psyche: What Went Wrong
Time
Yeah, I'm definitely not sure what happened there. As a child he seemed to have a perfectly adjusted relationship to the world around him. He selflessly cared about other people and endured the hardship of being a slave with stoic contentment. Something happened along the way though, while under the tutelage of Jedi, that led him to start enjoying his own happiness above that of others to the degree where one loses all sense of a proper perspective.
Post
#287602
Topic
Comics Fans
Time
I loved Watchmen when I read it. (Far better than V for Vendetta.) Fantastic book. Rorschach was the hero of the story as far as I'm concerned. Too bad he failed in the end, but I think he also kind of won strangely.

It would make a fantastic film if they could get a director to completely reproduce the story/images faithfully at each and every point. It had the most compelling and realistic take I've ever seen for "super heroes" and what their lives would really be like. It deserves an equally realistic translation to film in my mind, one that captures all of the character drama and doesn't try to insert a bunch of special effects or other sensational crap.
Post
#287601
Topic
Darth Vader's Psyche: What Went Wrong
Time
Not just any personality disorder. I've been arguing for a long time that Anakin (of the PT) displayed all the signs of a bona fide psychopath. For instance, he regularly showed a complete inability to balance his own personal desires with those of the people around him; there were many times that he had extreme reactions to relatively tame problems, but those reactions only seemed to come when those problems affected his own happiness. Also, he only seemed to care for the wellbeing of others when they served as emotional supports for him, and the minute they stopped serving as such even slightly, he reacted in extremely violent ways against them, no matter how close his relationship to them had been previously. When it came to the lives of strangers and innocents, he had no trouble murdering them without empathy or remorse. Just one sick puppy all around.
Post
#287504
Topic
Heath Ledger as The Joker (new pic)
Time
At this point I trust the people who did Batman Begins to have not made a bad choice in casting the Joker. The Joker is my favorite Batman villain however (so long as its the kind of Joker who laughs a lot and cracks twisted jokes all of time), and I would have never thought of Ledger as a good choice. I'm hoping I'm wrong though. I want this set of films to be good.