The Golden Idol

Darth Solo said:

The way i see it is that there are 4 types of followers here. Ranging from the totally open minded and love everything thats just Star Wars, to the extreme hardcore un-changed OT fan that doesn't want the films changed in anyway but of the highest quality (I understand Ady got some friction when doing ANH:R from this group aswell in the early days). I think most of us loath the SE's changes, but will embrace "some" changes for the better (thats always going to be walking a bit of mine field, as GL may have found out after the release of the SE's and the birth of tu net). That group gets split almost 3 ways with 3 filums. ...Well, 2 ways mostly, but most want to look on it as equally as 3 ways /:-P

I love Jedi regardless as i read the book before seeing the filum, and its the only time i haven't ever been dissapointed by doing so (erm, i guess i loved everything Star Wars back then).

Conclusion being then, erm, yeah, why are you here? (Not directed at any1, just a concensus).

 Just curious, why do you spell it "filum"? o.O

BelloqLugosi said:

I have done some very basic but in some cases radical edits to scenes and wanted some feedback. Is this thread alive? If not, where is the one that is, if any?

 Let's see em! :D

Johnny Ringo said:

ChainsawAsh said:

Fixed ;-)

And I haven't noticed a green tint myself, but I'll definitely give it a closer look when I get to actually editing it.  Thanks for pointing it out.

I'm NOT posting this as a correction, just to help point out the green. Like I said, sometimes it's all well and subtle but at other points it stands out. This scene isn't too bad really, it's just a shot I had handy...

 I definitely like it better without the green tint.

vaderios said:

The studio set is completely the wrong scale. It's actually too small as can be seen when they are repairing the falcon in ESB and we see Chewie in the cockpit from outside. The cockpit is about 40% smaller than it should be when we see them in the cockpit set. So to match the scale of the cockpit set and the model the studio version should be a lot bigger.

he is right.

Just for proofs

-Angel

Will this be fixed?

vaderios said:

Show us the scrapped  wampa one then :)

 I second that! :)

Very nice job on Yoda, Ady, but I think that when Yoda is trying to get the lamp back from R2, his brow should be furrowed, to show that he's struggling. I think that would be a nice touch, and would give more life to Yoda. Also, I agree with whoever said that Yoda's blink seems just a bit too smooth and slow.

Also, it seems that the food stick Yoda takes a bite out of is whole again when Luke inspects it and tosses it.

Monroville said:

rcb said:

The Golden Idol said:

Bingowings said:

 Jeez, that's just creepy.

 that might turn it into a horror movie. it would be better with flashbacks, but that would be stupid anyways

Actually, I can't really tell what is going on here... it looks like a "three fingered hand" to the right of Luke, but other than that, it looks like the RAIDERS ghosts from the Ark have seen better days...

Step back from the monitor and tell us what you see. Hint: What looks to be a three-fingered hand is an upper eyelid.

Bingowings said:

 Jeez, that's just creepy.

More scenes with Obi-Wan are completely unnecessary.

Double post.

vaderios said:

Ghost said:

Just an idea, would it be good to see Ben's Ghost again in ESB?  Mabey a shot of him looking on at him on Hoth from a distance.  Or mabey at Dagobah watching Luke train?

why?

 I second Vaderios' question.

adywan said:

Is this better?

Again uploading the pic has changed the colours :(

 That's definitely much better, as Luke's blade is now straight. :)

Wow, what happened? o.O

EDIT: Nevermind.

ChainsawAsh said:

I was just watching the Director's Cut, and noticed something that I just know will pull me out of the movie every time I see it, so it will be cut:

When Laurie and Dan are eating dinner, one of the patrons says, "I'm glad I ordered the four-legged chicken."  I mean, really?  What the fuck?

 This is present in the graphic novel. I thought it was a nice touch, what's so terrible about it?

Beautiful work, Ady.

Ghost said:

How about showing a cut scene of Yoda meditating and reacting to Lukes failure at Bespin?

 Also, what are the plans of showing Coruscant in the OT?  I heard that it is a possibility from members on this site.  It would be great to here from Ady on this one.

Ghost, stop repeating the same thing in each post. We understood you the first time you said it.

What the hell is the point of having a scene of Yoda meditating? It's completely pointless, and would break the pacing of the ending.

Ghost said:

Does anyone think that Vader's entrance in the Hoth battle is weak?  He comes out of nowhere.

 

Why isn't there going to be a ground battle on Hoth?  I know that it would take alot of time to do, but it would make sense if there was one added.  Mabey if Lucas does an edit, this will be added.

 

I think some PT music should be added.  Nothing noticible, but just background music.  The PT's music is much more epic than hearing the same old Imperial March every scene.  Mix in a sad version of force theme from the PT when the Empire is close to winning.

At least add some epic music to the Vader/Luke scene.

Anakins Betrayal would work somewhere to.

 

 

 

 -__-

I have a suggestion.

It never sat right with me when Luke says "Father!" in the Falcon when Vader is calling to him. Shouldn't he still be in total shock and disbelief/denial?

rcb said:

in the funeral pier scene, a lot of my friends say that it would of been better if vaders helment was off.

 well, i dunno if u can fit sabastian shaws head on there or hayden's. i think it would look akward.

 I disagree, I think the suit burning along with the helmet is a powerful visual metaphor for the end of the Empire.

Darth Solo said:

NO COPY AND PASTE! okay there?

 Oh, wait, that's what got us in trouble in the first place...

OK, then, can someone summarize what was said? :)

Can anyone please copy and paste the posts on the previous page after Ganamae's post? I'm not able to see them.

Thanks.

Ganamae said:

heh..I haz brøken teh førumz??!

 Yes u haz! Phix it nao! lol

Sorry, make that post 13232.

Ganamae, you broke the thread! lol

I can't see any posts after 1!

Darth Solo said:

Okay im convinced now. Ganamaes post in Adys the empire revisited has broken that thread on IE7. Looks like the old bug strikes back.

Anyone getting the same problem with later post counts there beyond post (hang on let me check)13232?

Theres another one of those bugs (itchey scratchey horrible things).

Ganamae broke the thread! What u do dude? Not that its your fault, just need to inform the web master theres a glitch in the forums with what u did on that post ;-)

 Same here. :(