This user has been banned.
Has anyone tried changing Yoda’s saber to gold? That way, so in TRoS it’d imply Rey would become a Jedi grandmaster and start a new Jedi Order?
Hal sent me one a while back. I’ve seen the actual TRoS twice, yet can still understand story decisions (even if some are flawed or don’t really have that sense of finality).
I’m giving out suggestions and contributing to the edit.
Apologies. I didn’t actually watch Ascendant, I just judged based on the movie’s plot and the list of changes.
Regarding Boba Fett, I think it’d be confusing for casual movie viewers.
@Burbin That could work with sherlock’s crawl, specifically, but not really with my proposed one. It deals with the FO on the verge of collapse, and the civilians gaining the upper hand. With Palps, Kylo knows that the civilians are far too strong, whereas he doesn’t know how powerful or weak Palps might be in comparison to the FO, Resistance or civilians. Palps could be the only other threat Kylo could stop.
@BrotherOfSasquatch How about I lower-case it? Or what series of words would you use to describe the FO being on the verge of collapse?
TestingOutTheTest said:
TEETERING on the EDGE.😂
It’s to highlight the importance of the FO not doing so well post-TLJ as well as Kylo wanting them to become a new Empire.
Then how about, “We’ve passed on what we know…”? It could be interpreted as Luke and Leia, as well as the Jedi texts.
Is it possible to add “We’ve passed on all we know” into the Luke and Rey scene?
Also, wanted to mention that you’re flat out wrong Testing. Kylo has seen the throne in Ascendant. He sees it in his Vader mask vision, right after Palps tells him to do as he asks. Basically enticing him to take it. But we want Kylo to NOT want that throne, because it is Sith. He only cares about the fleet.
Oh. I was referring to in the theatrical cut. Apologies.
Your point about Kylo and Palps doesn’t really apply to the theatrical. Kylo doesn’t know Palps wants to be killed, and thus doesn’t know whether it means obeying Palps or not. This problem kinda exists in Ascendant, as Palps warns Kylo about the spirit stuff - I understand that decision and do like it in theory, it raises the stakes… but… yeah.
If I were in charge of the movie, I’d have Palps urge Kylo to kill him only in anger and hatred specifically, and during the hangar scene when Kylo proposes to Rey the killing quote would be changed to this: “We’ll kill him, but not out of anger, not out of hatred. Then we’ll take the throne.”
Again, Kylo doesn’t know about and hasn’t even seen the Sith throne specifically. If the movie actually showed us Kylo Ren himself discovering the actual Sith throne, then I would see your point.
But a mysterious message has been transmitted across the galaxy. A threat of REVENGE, rumored to be from someone from the wars of old, hiding within the unknown!
There. It does add some mystery and build-up.
without necessarily spoiling the Palpatine reveal.
That’s why I put “rumored to be from the late PALPATINE!” in my crawl. We’d be unsure as to whether it is the real Palpatine or not. It also adds to the Resistance being skeptical of his return until Poe’s confirmation.
Key word: rumors.
The Resistance doesn’t believe it’s Palpatine at first. Hence why Poe says: “We’ve coded the intel from the spy, and it CONFIRMS the worst: somehow, Palpatine returned.” Implying they didn’t believe it was Palpatine at first.
Regarding Finn and Poe, neither of them are spies. Also, I feel like they have to do their own missions and stuff pre-TRoS, post-rumors/broadcast.
Regarding the silencing thing and preventing new alliances, then I don’t think there’d be any point in wanting to get more resources and make the FO a true Empire.
Can I have a link?
Episode IX
THRONE OF THE DARKNESS
The flame of hope burns! Following the heroic sacrifice of Luke Skywalker on Crait, the daring Resistance has been reborn. The diabolical First Order, facing insurrection on a thousand worlds, is TEETERING on the EDGE.
But a mysterious message has been transmitted across the galaxy. A threat of REVENGE, rumored to be from the late PALPATINE!
Determined to annihilate this phantom threat to his declining rule, Supreme Leader Kylo Ren is chasing whispers of an ancient ARTIFACT that could lead him to the very source of the broadcast…
“Mysterious origins of Snoke”? Come on, his backstory can already be inferred from TFA.
There isn’t any indication he knew about the Sith throne specifically.
Regarding the throne line, I pointed out my interpretation of it a couple of comments ago. Also, doesn’t Kylo say the line after he takes the helmet off?
As someone who defends TRoS, Kylo rebuilding his mask, and his relationship with Palpatine, and understands the story reasons and necessities behind them, I do agree that he didn’t feel exactly like Kylo Ren from TLJ specifically. I propose a new line after his proposal to Rey for them to kill Palps and take the throne.
KYLO REN: We’ll kill him together, and take the throne. Reform his Order into our own, berid of the things of old.
I just wanna say I’m glad LEGO SW: The Skywalker Saga is coming out, since that’s a remake I’ve wanted for ages. Hopefully Harry Potter and Indiana Jones get the same treatment.
Zelda needs to learn to do proper remakes. The only remakes its done so far are OoT, MM, and LA, all of which added little to no new features, making 99% of the difference purely graphical. They need to take a page from Pokemon (which actually has a problem of too many remakes and should’ve stopped after HG/SS) and actually add meaningful new content to their remakes. Here’s a few I’d like to see.
Take notes from Super Mario 64 DS as well.
@RL I think that would be too on-the-nose and kinda pointless. And I talked about Holdo and Poe a couple of comments ago.
@JJB The line would also be pointless in the movie since it’s an inference and thus isn’t explicitly spelled out. That would be like Kylo Ren going up to the audience and blatantly telling us that his injury was the reason he lost to Rey.
Yeah, that’s what I’m referring to. A hypothetical spy.
But how else is the FO supposed to win at this point?
Also Holdo wouldn’t tell anyone she thinks there’s a spy, because if anything it’ll get any spies to become even more desparate to find out any information.