logo Sign In

TV's Frink

This user has been banned.

User Group
Banned Members
Join date
22-Jul-2009
Last activity
19-Oct-2018
Posts
63,449

Post History

Post
#376727
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time
brash_stryker said:

The problem with the Obi Wan Kenobi: Space Detective storyline is that it goes absolutely nowhere and makes not only him, but the entire Jedi order look like retards because even after unconvering an obvious conspiracy, they do nothing about it, but instead play right into its hands.

And specifically, the map reader scene really makes Obi Wan look like an idiot.  It's a very cool looking scene, but he really couldn't figure out that the planet was erased from the archive?  Even after mentioning himself the effects of gravity still remaining?  He never even considered flying off to where the planet should be?  Maybe if the youngling who had the right answer had also trained Anakin, the empire would never have been born...

 

Post
#376658
Topic
Frink's Prequel Cutlist Project
Time

I've been working on a project to provide complete cutlists (in script form) of every Star Wars Prequel edit I have gotten my hands on.  I thought I would share the cutlists I've completed so far.

EP1:
ADM
Father Merrin
Hal9000
Horace
JasonN v2
L8wrtr
Magnoliafan
Magnoliafan Phantom Re-Edit
Modernknife
The Phantom Editor
Sithlord
Slumberland

EP2:
ADM
Diamond Wan
Father Merrin
Hal9000
Horace
JasonN
Magnoliafan
The Phantom Editor
Sithlord
Slumberland
Spence

EP3:
ADM
AEmovieguy
Corgicar
Father Merrin
Hal9000
JasonN
Sithlord
Slumberland
Spence
Stankpac v2

EP1-3:
Blankfist
lewis886 disc 1 AND lewis886 disc 2

I've also created a spreadsheet summarizing most of the edits made by the different editors, sortable by character or time.

Ep1 Summary Spreadsheet
Ep2 Summary Spreadsheet
Ep3 Summary Spreadsheet

Post
#376562
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time
mrbenja0618 said:

I saw JasonN's edits, but I don't remember... Did he remove the Dooku scene with the death star plans?

Here's *everything* JasonN did for AOTC:

http://rapidshare.com/files/245028747/ep2jasonncutlist.doc

And if you are interested in what was done in his other edits, or what other editors have done to the prequels, follow the link in my sig.

EDIT: Just remembered you have to be a member of that forum to follow my sig link.  If you aren't a member, let me know what other edits you are interested in and I'll post the links to the cutlists.

Post
#376549
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time
Timstuff said:

I really like the idea that Dooku isn't really evil-- he's an idealist who sees the corruption in the Republic, and is trying to do something about it. One question though: would the connection between him and Sideous be removed completely, as in the scene where he meets up with Sideous at the end is gone? I have mixed feelings about it. On the one hand, it would show that Dooku is playing both sides, which keeps his true motives a bit more ambiguous. However, on the other hand, if he really is an idealist it's possible that he under no circumstances would lower himself to working with a Sith, even if he's going behind Sideous' back. I'm not really sure which way it should go, but also I did like that there was some foreshadowing to the Death Star in Episode 2 (though I do feel like showing its construction in ROTS was unnecessary and chronologically sloppy).

Have you watched JasonN's edits? He completely cut Dooku's relationship with Sidious, including that scene at the end of AOTC.

 

Post
#375856
Topic
STAR WARS: EP V &quot;REVISITED EDITION&quot;<strong>ADYWAN</strong> - <strong>12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW</strong>
Time
Ripplin said:
Johnny Ringo said:
adywan said:

I don't think the innards of the arm need anything done to them. It's the arm itself that needs fixing so it no longer looks like a horrible latex falsie

Why not film your own arm again?

Because he doesn't have robotic parts inside it, duh... ;)

 

How do you know he doesn't? ;)