Sign In


User Group
Trusted Members
Join date
Last activity

Post History

The Cloak of Evil. (Clips available)

I originally had the whole pod race in the film, transitioning from the cockpit to the arena reveal, however the race even in its shortest version didn’t work for me. I very much adhere to the philosophy, cut it late leave early. In regards to the Hutts, I think it’s best they’re referenced and not seen. This is Chapter 1. Though I do like your idea for revealing Anakin.

In your head is the reveal:

a) It’s Anakin.
b) It’s a small boy?

Just curious.

The Cloak of Evil. (Clips available)

Cheers for the feed back.

It really bothers me these lengthy pauses before dissolves throughout the prequels, I’ve been trying to get them closer to the OT especially ANH. I may have slightly overdone here, though I personally think it works.

snooker said:

I feel like there needs to be more pause between the Cockpit and Podrace scene.

The Cloak of Evil. (Clips available)

That’s a good point, though I might argue that if Yoda in death can physically interact with the real world aka calling down the lighting, he could conceivably interact physically whilst astral traveling. At this stage I’m on the fence in regards to having him astral travel, except in The Phantom Menace, where he communicates with Obi-Wan on Naboo as seen in the preview above.

The Last Jedi : Fan Edit Ideas - ** <strong>SPOILERS INSIDE</strong> **

I think the best way to solve the lack of introduction is to keep Maz’s transmission and end the scene when Rose and Finn give each other that “look” after Maz implies that her and the code break have been intimate. Then cut straight to the radar blip, stolen ship etc. That way in can be implied that DJ is who they are looking for. It will also fit with expectations/ reality theme of the film…

The Cloak of Evil. (Clips available)

After watching The Last Jedi, I’m considering having the Yoda disappear after the fight with Dooku, to reveal that he has not left Coruscant. Cutting to the footage of him in his meditation chamber after the Tusken Massacre. This helps explain his sudden limberness.

I also plan on exploring further other force abilities…

This way when Anakin complains that there are thing they are not telling him it doesn’t completely come out of nowhere.

The Cloak of Evil. (Clips available)

Here is a list of FX changes that I’m not nearly knowledgable enough to achieve.

Remove Padme from the all of the Lars Homestead footage.

Also, when Obi-Wan sends his message to Anakin, I need the view from the windows to be changed from Tatooine to space as the message will now be received as Anakin and Padme return to Naboo.

Green or blue sabre for Dooku.

(Probably wishful thinking)

Place the wedding at the Lars Homestead.

STAR WARS EPISODE I: Dawn of War (On Hold?)

The Sun Rise as he exits the tent in infinitely better than the original. Great stuff!

I love the love binocular effect, however he is quite obviously not holding binoculars.

The first matte replacement is better that the original but needs a little work blending it with original image.

Really interested to see how your edits turns out, a lot of good ideas here.

The Cloak of Evil. (Clips available)


Star Wars: Episode 1

The nefarious Trade Federation has blockaded the peaceful planet of Naboo in an attempt to tighten it’s strangle hold on the outlying systems and force Queen Amidala to relinquish her rule.
Hoping to bring a swift end to the crisis THE SUPREME CHANCELLOR has dispatched legendary JEDI MASTER Qui-Gon Jinn and his apprentice Obi-Wan Kenobi to the besieged planet.
Unbeknownst to the JEDI the TRADE FEDERATION are merely pawns of THE DARK LORDS OF THE SITH, the eternal enemies of the JEDI KNIGHTS…

Without loosing any major plot points, I have trimmed The Phantom Menace down to roughly one hour, taking inspiration from the pacing of both The Clone Wars and Thor Ragnarok.

I’ve tried to create a sense of fun and humour through the cutting.

There is now no pointless exposition, repetition of information, and as few walking and talking scenes as possible. My goal was tell the story of the film as if through the eyes of a child who was repeating the experience of watching a Star Wars film.

In the first half (The Phantom Menace) the Jedi first appear after the Republic Cruiser is destroyed. This is a much stronger and iconic introduction.

There is no journey to the Gungan City at the beginning. Boss Nass is not a character in this film.

Anakin is not a slave.

He has already won the Pod race when the heroes arrive on Tatooine.
Instead of offering to enter the race, Anakin offers his race winnings to pay for their parts.

He doesn’t work for Watto. Watto only appears twice, first in the “Republic Credits” scene and again briefly telling Qui-Gon they have a “deal” after which we cut to Qui-Gon dropping the hyper drive at the ship for Obi-Wan to install.

I have have kept Qui-Gon testing the blood and the midichlorians.

The next morning after Maul arrives, Qui-Gon talks to Shmi about Anakin. “If he had been born in the Republic…” ending at “Can you help him?” "I don’t know.

I’ve tried to tie in as much as I can the arrival of Maul with the scenes talking about Anakins potential.
3-PO is still in the film at this stage, he was two scenes.

They leave Tatooine at the half hour mark currently.

Coruscant is streamlined.

No mention of the Queen being elected.

The Trade Federation do not have a seat in the Senate.

Malastare intervene still.

I’ve moved the conversation with Qui-Gon telling Obi-Wan he’s a “far wiser man than I” to the balcony at the Jedi Temple.

The crew return to Naboo.

The Queen and Anakin wait as Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon and Jar Jar swim to the Gungan City to procure their assistance.

The first time we see the Gungans in mass is when they emerge from the mist.

Jar Jar is a semi-capable warrior, though the Gungan’s don’t last long agains the droid army in this edit.

Anakin isn’t an accidental Pilot.

No celebration.

The Funeral Scene and Obi-Wan/ Yoda scene are in reverse order.

The final scene is Palpatine talking to the Senate, informing them that he plans to make a Clone Amry to counter the increasing threats of “The Trade Federation”. Essentially the beginning of the Clone Wars.

I’m currently refining the cuts to Attack of the Clones, so much of this is subject to change.

VFX assistance will be required for some of these edits.


Crisis! Thousands of star systems under the leadership of the enigmatic Count Dooku have declared their intentions to leave the Republic.
Seeing this as an ACT OF WAR the Senate has called for the deployment of the Republic’s CLONE ARMY.
Having declared her planet a democaracy, Senator Amidala former Queen of Naboo, embarks for the capitol to plead for a peaceful resolution…

A streamlined Attack of the Clones.

The Clone Army is already in existence so there is no secret army mystery, just the mystery of who is trying assassinate Amidala. This also makes the link between Dooku and Jango more ominous, and the Jedi look less stupid.

Qui-Gon begins his communication with Yoda in this film, and will be heard faintly by Anakin and Obi-Wan…

The journey to Naboo is cut.

Padme and Anakin’s first kiss is not until the arena.


Vader was ordered by the Emperor to make sure that the Death Star is operational, by the time the rebel fleet arrives.
He can’t leave. He must obay his master.
He might send some troups though, if he has any at his disposal mind you, since the legions are stationed on the Endor moon, waiting for the rebels.
Plus the Emperor knows that Skywalker will come to Vader, and he tells this to Vader exactly when he needs to. When Vader’s job is done on the Death Star, and has some time to kill before the rebels arrive.
So logically, Vader is not going anywhere.

I see what you are saying, especially in relation to Vader’s character as presented in ROTJ. However it is clear in ESB that Vader is undermining the Emperor and plans to betray him. (The Emperor informs Vader of there new enemy, who Vader has already been searching for.) I would personally do away with most of the “I must obey my master” type dialogue, I see Vader as a slave to the dark side more than to the Emperor himself. If Luke, Vader and Palpatine all have different intentions it makes for greater drama and tension. As well as this, I like the idea of Vader returning to Tatooine is what was meant to be the final chapter.