logo Sign In

Sluggo

User Group
Members
Join date
29-Sep-2004
Last activity
24-Jun-2018
Posts
6,820

Post History

Post
#186247
Topic
Info Wanted: What is the best Episode 4 Edit to incorporate deleted footage?
Time
If you want a feel of what the rough cut would have been like, watch Deleted Magic a few times, and if you could watch it on a really old TV that you can turn the color off, that will take you half way there.

So, two things to think about if you are going to do this:

1. Remember that the "Lost Cut" had only 30 to 40 percent different footage. Try to look at this in a glass is half full kind of way.

2. Also remember that there were two different rough cuts. The first was in July of '76 made by John Jympson. This is the famous rough cut of that Insider article. This one had no sound and was in black and white. It had very minimal effects and model work (likely none) from ILM. Also the scenes that were later on the shooting schedule (such as the scenes on the Tantive IV) were not filmed and were represented by a 'Scene Missing' card.

The second rough cut was the one George showed to his friends (like Speilberg and Coppola) and Fox executives. This version already had the Biggs and Anchorhead footage cut out. It had the early opening crawl. It also had temp music from other films and classical music as a temp score. WWII dogfight footage was here in this version, I don't know if this temp footage was in the first rough cut.

3. Remember that since many of your source materials aren't gonna be that great, you want to focus on content instead of quality. Since this is a rough cut, I think most viewers will understand.

Okay, three things. You get the idea.
Post
#186015
Topic
Star Wars DVD Covers
Time
Coov, I think I am going to cry. That is one good looking set

And Pepsi-dude, I'm glad you are bringing up the box ideas again. I think that there was a thread somewhere on this site long time ago. If there isn't one already, maybe you or Coov could start a seperate thread for it. I know I have several designs I could throw on there.

-TheSluggo
Post
#186008
Topic
Idea: a Virtual "Lost Cut"
Time
LFL is soooo totally uncool that way. It would be great to have George release all that stuff some day. But right now I feel like Dan Brown trying to break in to the Vatican vaults.

I think we are at the point where this thread ought to be combined with the other one on "the best edit that re-incorperates lost footage".

This would be an edit that I would watch all the time. No joke. Convert the whole thing to a rough cut look, make it in black and white, add projector noise instead of the sound, the works.
Post
#185832
Topic
Info Wanted: What is the best Episode 4 Edit to incorporate deleted footage?
Time
It's just my opinion, of course, but some of his re-creations were just too artificial, if you take my meaning, sir. Footage from the Hasbro Interactice Game just didn't fit. I think it is a great idea in theory, just not when I was expecting maybe something a little more finished. But I guess you have to do the best with what you have.
Post
#185563
Topic
Info Wanted: What is the best Episode 4 Edit to incorporate deleted footage?
Time
Last I heard, Bernd Dötzer hasn't released it. It would be interesting to see all of his changes together on one tape, but some of the changes are pretty radical, so I don't think I would be watching it for anything other than reference. I think a more refined hand should tackle the changes, someone like Darth Editous. Or Opcmovie. Anything those guys touches turns to gold.
Post
#185448
Topic
The Empire Strikes Quack! - 8 minute video edit
Time
A thread about that? I'll put it in the crock-pot and think about it. A Newfangled Hope would be fun to see again. My pal Fry and me once made a small clip called The Newfangled Menace seven or eight years ago. It was fun to work on, but it didn't end up as funny or interesting. Definately not as funny as When Senators Attack. That thing was freaking hilarilous.
Post
#183946
Topic
Sluggo's Valentine's Day NEW PiF photoshop contest
Time
Holy crud. I laughed my butt off with these. I'm glad I waited until they all were up before I checked in again.

And...

In the spirit of feeling the love, I've decided get EVERYBODY who submitted a set. It'll take a few weeks, but it's all about the love. If all you folks who could put up a pic could send your address to my hotmail addy, I'll start getting those out.

http://img154.imageshack.us/img154/665/hoth6se.jpg



And don't tell anybody, but I think I liked Infodroid's the best.
Post
#182073
Topic
//RETURNING TO JEDI\\: NTSC & PAL DVD
Time
Originally posted by: ReverendBeastly
Go easy on the punctuation. All of those question marks made my brain hurt.

And it's not a workprint of the whole film, it's just a workprint version of the 1997 SE ending. I don't even recall it being that different.


Let's see, the music was different, lots of sketches of the background of the new planets and If I remember right, I think there were Ewok dolls used there. I posted it a while ago on one of those downloads sites. I don't remember where it ended up.