logo Sign In

SilverWook

User Group
Members
Join date
9-Dec-2004
Last activity
6-Apr-2023
Posts
22,080

Post History

Post
#389244
Topic
Fractalsponge's 3dmeshes used in Family Guy : Credit Not Given - Awaiting RotJ
Time

thecolorsblend said:

SilverWook said:

Where is Fractalsponge doing that?

He's not; you are.

 

It's "whining and crying" to merely comment on how a studio that reaps millions of dollars went and stole your CGI model?

 

From what I know of the situation, he's giving it away for free.  How can that possibly be theft?

 

By that logic, this whole site is devoted to "whining and crying".

 

Nothing is being taken from us without permission, we're simply denied the opportunity to pay for something we want and we come here, as much as anything, to vent.  Apples and oranges.

Oh really? I thought we were having a civilized discussion!

The crux of the matter is the guy ought to be given a little credit for creating the model that was used. It wouldn't hurt, wouldn't cost them a thing, and generate a little positive fan PR.

Plagiarism is bad, whether one swipes from an author or a model maker.

 

Post
#389197
Topic
Fractalsponge's 3dmeshes used in Family Guy : Credit Not Given - Awaiting RotJ
Time

thecolorsblend said:

Then it's on them to seek a legal remedy.  But whining and crying about it on the Internet solves nothing.

Where is Fractalsponge doing that? It's "whining and crying" to merely comment on how a studio that reaps millions of dollars went and stole your CGI model?

By that logic, this whole site is devoted to "whining and crying".

Post
#389127
Topic
Fractalsponge's 3dmeshes used in Family Guy : Credit Not Given - Awaiting RotJ
Time

Probably not. But permission would have to be sought to use it. (Probably easily obtained if it's a Warner Bros. show.)

The film "Hollywoodland", about the death of Superman actor George Reeves had no end of trouble with Warner Bros. over the use of the Superman logo and other related items.

Studios are supposed to cover their legal asses on these things. When they don't, they can get sued. This happened over the film "The Devil's Advocate".

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118971/alternateversions

The artwork I referred to was specifically commissioned for a website about dragons. It was used without permission. The artist and the people who paid for the art retain reproduction rights.

Post
#389044
Topic
Fractalsponge's 3dmeshes used in Family Guy : Credit Not Given - Awaiting RotJ
Time

Someone else in that thread claims to have seen the whole episode and no credit was given. I'd be willing to bet someone at an overseas animation sweatshop is the culprit.

Sadly, I've seen this sort of thing happen before too.  There's a SciFi channel movie where some fantasy artwork is seen on the wall of someone's lab. It seems someone involved with that production simply downloaded images from the website they were created for, and printed them out. No credit or compensation was given at all.

Post
#388776
Topic
Possible news of new Star Wars EU movies
Time

Alas, Thomas Dolby (the source of the quote) has corrected himself.

http://blog.thomasdolby.com/?p=968

The last wave of rumors got started when Lucasfilm was shooting new stuff for the Star Tours ride.

If the live action show ever gets underway, there will be more speculation.

My fondest SW wish is to see Mark Hamill back in the saddle playing an older wiser Luke, (as prophesied by Starlog magazine decades ago) but I'm not holding my breath.

In the meantime, we need to let Mr. Dolby know we want the soundtrack to Howard the Duck on CD! :P

Post
#386995
Topic
Info: 70mm reel 2 of empire strikes back up on ebay, not my auction and sadly the film is pinkish
Time

Ebay is so asleep at the wheel half the time, I'm surprised they would even notice. (They screwed their search engine up royally several days ago.) Can't find the listing, so I presume it's gone now. :(

A 70mm reel might be useful in documenting the visual differences from the 35mm version if nothing else. Doubt anybody has a projector in their basement.

Post this sort of thing in the preservation section next time! Talk of old film reels has not been verboten so far.