logo Sign In

SilverWook

User Group
Members
Join date
9-Dec-2004
Last activity
6-Apr-2023
Posts
22,080

Post History

Post
#1072686
Topic
The Worst Star Wars Characters
Time

Ratio Tile said:

TPM Anakin, AotC Anakin, RotS Anakin, and Phasma.

Phasma doesn’t make sense towards the end of TFA. Why would she give up just because she has a blaster pointed at her head? If she’s some sort of hard core Stormtrooper she would have shown a little more resiliency. It doesn’t make sense for her character. She should have said screw you guys, shoot me, I’m not helping you.

Sometimes someone’s resolve crumbles when a blaster is pointed at them? And it would look nasty for our heroes to shoot her once she’s a prisoner in that situation anyway.

Post
#1072417
Topic
The Force Awakens: Official Review Thread - ** SPOILERS **
Time

Amano said:

I succeeded in liking the Phantom Menace at the cinema. I knew that it was some kind of a forced love (which Lucas trumped with Anakin vs. Padme one movie later). But I kinda liked it.

Then the DVD arrived and everything got worse. The pacing was off (an already too long race got longer) and some CG scenes surrounding the pod race got longer and more embarrassing. That was the moment when I knew that Lucas himself got off the track. I didn’t know about the special edition changes back then.

Ironic that the theatrical cut of TPM has never been on DVD at all.

Post
#1072318
Topic
General Star Wars <strong>Random Thoughts</strong> Thread
Time

Then they fixed Artoo up by pulling an all nighter? 😉

It’s also possible Tarkin wanted to hog all the glory, and kept a blackout on where they were going. The question of why the Imperial Navy didn’t show up soon after was addressed in the Marvel comic. The Empire was trying to conceal that their biggest weapon went kaboom, and massive fleet movements would betray something was amiss.

ESB certainly proved the Rebels could take out a stardestroyer or two while bugging out.

The simplest explanation is Star Wars was originally intended as a standalone film.

Post
#1072229
Topic
George Lucas - your opinions of him? a general discussion thread
Time

Haarspalter said:

NeverarGreat said:

Why didn’t they just make the fighters larger?

Why the need for R2 droids in the PT anyway? Lucas could have come up with a new and totally different kind of droid for the Prequels.

Lucas said way back during production on ESB that Artoo and Threepio were the only characters intended to appear in the entire saga. Therefore R2 units have been around a long while.