smithersthree said:(I only wish I understood half of the technical terms being discussed here).
Same here. That applies for every preservation and/or edit thread. :p
Two more words: Huh?
Octorox said:Ripplin said:That's a really cool idea! But, as BarBar said...it just feels unnecessary. To me, it would feel like when I'm watching a movie and it'll start raining to enhance the mood or something. Sometimes it works, and sometimes it just feels very hokey. Maybe Ady can give an opinion on this interesting idea.
Well. I can see how some might find it distracting. However I wasn't suggesting it be visibly clearing up while Luke is still on the planet talking to Obi-Wan, just as Luke is flying away in his X-Wing and we see the planet from afar.
Oh, I knew exactly what you meant. Hopefully Ady will chime in.
That's a really cool idea! But, as BarBar said...it just feels unnecessary. To me, it would feel like when I'm watching a movie and it'll start raining to enhance the mood or something. Sometimes it works, and sometimes it just feels very hokey. Maybe Ady can give an opinion on this interesting idea.
Looks very nice! I must say, though, that I think the dirty audio should definitely be the bonus track. ;) I think after a short time, I'd be thinking 'I wanna hear this in proper CD quality.' Know what I mean?
Another goody! Thanks, Ady. Feeling better now? Heh.
Having never heard you before, your voice sounds pretty normal to me. Haha. Funny part about the 2D cutouts being moved around, and not more CGI, as many thought. Thanks for the kudos to all us OTers, too. ;)
^Correct. The only Purist edition was the NTSC DVD5.
Very nice, Ady! Neat to see the turret firing. And they kick back, too! :)
Is there anything that can be done with the guy who says "Echo Station 3TA"? The audio/lip sync is so...off. It has never looked like he's saying what he's saying.
That is an interesting idea for sure, but falls into the 'doing it just because you can' territory, I think. And that's not the purpose of these edits. :p
90%?! Wow. Makes me wonder; what scene/scenes require the most work, not counting the color correction? I figured it would be the Hoth battle, so...?
Maybe you could mention that in the thread title. Might speed things up. (I don't even know what a lasermatte is)
Take your time. (your news is encouraging, though) I know you're getting into Shroud now, too. School comes first, though.
PaulisDead2221 said:This is a pretty cool project everyone. You should all be really excited.
Acknowledged, sir!
Sorry for bumping two of your threads, but...any updates on this continuing edit? :) Maybe you can just give a small answer that can be applied to each?
Any updates on this continuing edit? :)
Octorox said:I understand your point, I just think the way Dagobah looks it could easily be Hoth or Bespin.
If it created confusion, I might be onboard with changing it, too, but has there ever been any doubt that Luke was heading down towards Dagobah? I think Ady's explanation really makes sense.
Oh, and my guess after having seen that clip of the fat dancing guy, and Ady's ROTJ:R comment afterward is...4 more breasts? ;)
Is anyone interested?! Just wait until Josh sees your later post, Trooperman. ;) Then you will know the true meaning of interest. Or obsession. Whatever.
It would be neat if you would be in Paul throughout his work to help out with little things. Do you plan to do so? I think it's important that you're happy with the final product, too. I can't speak for Paul, of course, but I bet he feels the same way.
I'd love to do some voice-over stuff, too. I doubt it'll happen, but it's something I've been interested in for much of my life, and I am a public speaker as well. :p
bkev said:I'd like to see them released episode-by-episode...
...but then again I'm HIGHLY anticipating this.
Once the first is done, the rest should be ready shortly afterwards anyway, because he'll have learned so much. Besides, when the entire PT and OT will each fit on a disc, releasing them individually would be a ton of extra time [and bandwidth, no matter what format was used] for him to deal with... Think of how fast the original versions came out, one after the other.
Having said that, I know you're HIGHLY anticipating them. Haha. :) So am I.
ImperialFighter said:you've gotten rid of that bloody annoying 'white blob' that mysteriously appears at the end of the cave shot!
Ah yes. At first, I thought maybe it was an asteroid appearing as they reach the end of the tunnel, but no...looks like a reflection or lens flare or something? Man, R2 looks great now! Excellent job on that, Ady!
Sounds good. :) If you do share video samples, will they have audio, or is this mainly to see how it looks? If they do have audio, maybe share one with the "dirty" audio?
astromech said:I don't like the way they seem to have someone who can just stick their own additional comments into someone's post
Seriously? I once quit a forum because of garbage like that.
They've got their own "Kliq"* over there, it seems.
*That's a wrestling reference, for those who don't get it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Kliq
'The Kliq was a backstage group in the World Wrestling Federation during the mid-1990s, which some claim held virtually all booking power and were accused of refusing to be fair to anyone outside of the group.'
Sound familiar? :p
I'm still interested to see how you do the 'No Hayden' thing. Will that require manually cleaning up each frame of that scene?
Well, I'm no physics professor or anything, so maybe someone who actually knows about such things can give an opinion, too. Shadows are tricky things sometimes.