logo Sign In

Rebel Scumb

User Group
Members
Join date
21-Mar-2003
Last activity
18-Dec-2005
Posts
618

Post History

Post
#31031
Topic
Oscars 2004
Time
Quote

Originally posted by: GundarkHunter
I'm amazed that Johnny Depp got the nod for PotK. Not that it's a bad performance, but the nomination seems so uncharacteristic for the Academy.


Its hardly an oscar worth perfomance, especially considering Depp's incredible portfolio of work. In general I found POTC to be very average, with Depp's role being the only real stand out element.

Post
#31028
Topic
Oscars 2004
Time
I haven't seen Lost in translation yet, part of me wants to vote for Master & Commander, because I really really liked it. But I think overall ROTK (despite many problematic elements) is still the best in many ways.

Even though I'm a fan of the books, I kind of think that the ending could of been cut and saved for the EE. When all of Gondor bows to the hobbits, that could of been the ending and left 90% of audiences very happy.

Still ROTK was great, not quite as good as FOTR, but much better then TTT, and all around the best paced of the three with a lot of solid entainment value.

I liked Mystic river when I saw it, but the more I think about it, it was actually pretty bad.

Still haven;t seen Seabiscuit either.
Post
#30733
Topic
THE LORD OF THE RINGS: Return of the King (spoilers)
Time
Quote

Originally posted by: motti_soL
think of it this way: youll flip the side of the DVD after 2 hrs... means that a normal film wouldve been over by now.


disk one ends in a weird spot in the TTT EE. It should be right after galadriels speech. That way when you start disk 2, it would be faramir opening up the map and summarizing the situation. SO if you took a nap between disks you get all caught up.

Post
#30731
Topic
THE LORD OF THE RINGS: Return of the King (spoilers)
Time
the saruman scene will be in the ROTK EE

whether the sauron coming back to fight aragorn scene will be in there, I'm not sure. However I do think there is some hints of it in the theatrical version.

If you watch there is a point at the black gates where Aragorn is about to be finished off by a troll with a big mace. I have a feeling that this scene iscut together from elements of the sauron fight and it has been altered, taking out the digital sauron they were going to use and replacing him with the troll.

I hope the scenes with Bruce spence as the mouth of sauron are in the EE.

And actually if you watch the trailer for ROTK, 90% of that stuff isn;'t in the movie
Post
#29752
Topic
THE LORD OF THE RINGS: Return of the King (spoilers)
Time
Yeah. Basically as I understand it from what Ian Mckellan has said in interviews and according to my middle earth dictionary, Gandalf and Saruman are demi-gods who have assumed human form while in the mortal world to try and keep things in check. The balrog was like the anti-gandalf, a demi-god of a different order who chose a form more lavish and deadly.

Quote

Originally posted by: HotRod
Oh right...Nice one. That does answer a few Bilbo questions.
I wasn't sure if Bilbo went into the same wierd world that Frodo did..!!

But how can they say the journey lasted 13 months?

I don't think that worked too well??

It was 13 months right!!

Otherwise ignore this shit!!



Actually in the books it takes like 20 years by the time its all done. When frodo gets the ring they don;t actually leave the shire for another 16 years, and when they get to rivendell they hang out htere for like 18months I believe. The urgency and the need to keep moving is greatly reduced in the book (or increased in the movies depending how you look at it)
Post
#29751
Topic
EVERYTHING HARRY POTTER
Time
Quote

Originally posted by: HotRod
Well that explains a little then. I'm from good ol' England!!!!!!!
And if you've ever seen kids TV over here, then you'll know exactly what I'm on about!:


Some times people think I'm british because I've picked up a lot of the slang (I always end up reading british books for some reason) like suss and quid. I've seen a lot of worse kid acting then the HP films. I think the casting is fine, the kids don't bug me, but I can see how it might bug someone else.

Post
#29722
Topic
THE LORD OF THE RINGS: Return of the King (spoilers)
Time
Bilbo had the ring for 60 years. He used it but sauron did not sense it because he had not started to come back yet (and because JR TOLKIEN didn't know he was going to write lOTR when he was writing the Hobbit).

the book explains it that hte ring was not "activated" or "awake" so when Bilbo was invisible he didn;t slip into the shadow world the way Frodo did.