NeverarGreat

As I said, either approach works for me 😃

Indeed. I believe I was one of the damn fools who argued for adding the second charging due to it being unrealistic for Poe to let his emotions get in the way of a pointless mission that was already too costly in terms of lives.

This was mere weeks before TLJ’s release, as I recall.

Yeah, the idea of it being multi-use makes some sense based on the remaining solar material at the end, and it works for me either way.

Of course if it bugs you too much there are other edits that remove the multi-use implication altogether 😉

If you would like the workprint you have but to ask, however here are some screencaps:

Not at all, I’m happy to get feedback on the work 😃

I’ve put the Dice scene into the edit, though there remains work to do on that front. Overall however the edit is shaping up and the color grade in in place. I’m pretty pleased with it, but there remain some things still to do, a few miscellaneous notes for small tweaks. The changes are small enough that I’m hoping to get it done pretty quickly and have a final render here after…(checks notes)…four and a half years.

But seriously, I’m running out of things to tinker with, so if anybody finds another deleted scene that must be included, kindly don’t let me know 😉

Oh, I thought you were physically masking out skin tones and fire and such.

Selective color is something that I use quite heavily in the Jakku grade, but even with fine control and selecting only certain hues at certain saturation/luminance levels it’s still really difficult to find settings that knock out the hues of the sand while leaving all of the skin tones and explosions, or at least enough to not look weird. In the end, I found that taking out all the color in the sand shadows would always play havoc with the skin tones, which is why I settled for settings that targeted mostly highlights and high midtones.

Servii said:

Just remove all the opening crawls. Screw it. Let the audience figure it out.

That may actually be a good change, at least for all films but the first in the trilogies.

Oh masking every scene of Jakku would work, but is it worth the trouble for a subtle improvement? To me, not really.

…

The link is updated with the background and prettification. I haven’t added glare to the windows yet, but everything else is about done.

Chase Adams said:

Amazing, amazing stuff Nev! That arm reconstruction work is so seamless I had forgotten where the camera covered it up.

One thing I did notice that I should probably point out is that the little piece of metal that Han hangs the dice on seems to slide around quite a bit, might be a good idea to stabilise it in some way…

Definitely planning on it.

In regards to the face though, my suggestion for the simplest solution would probably be to just trim the clip and make do with a little bit of a loss of continuity between shots. Not sure how other people would feel about that though.

I feel like for such an important shot it should go as long as possible, as it’s the only one where we see the dice.

Anyway, I’ve updated the mockup to include the work on Han’s face and some scratches on the glass which will be toned down later.

https://vimeo.com/590342667

Password: fanedit

The distortions on the face have literally given me a headache, so I’m calling it quits for now. It might be good enough if I put a bit of glare on the windshield near that spot, or it could be chalked up to distortion through the glass. What do you think?

You’re welcome and thank you for your thoughts!

• The Jakku regrade is pushed about as far as I can take it without the washed out grade negatively affecting the explosions and skin tones and such, and so I’m pretty happy with it.

• You’re right, the scene is too contrasted so the interrogation will be toned down in the final version.

Also, I’ve gotten Han’s arm and left shoulder reattached!

https://vimeo.com/590342667

Password: fanedit

Now what to do with the face…

jarbear said:

Thanks for the update Hal on the state of things. So it’s simple, we just need to make Faraday work all night, since sleep is over rated. Also, just hunt down Jonh and convince him actual work, providing for family, etc. is obviously less important than clipping Luke’s hair. Oh, and Nev to work. My goodness! /S

(Of course joking, I just wish I had the tools and the know how to do anything.)

Don’t forget the saber shots! Though if it’s just the beginning of the film that is incomplete maybe the effect could be faded in throughout the film to imply a physical degradation of the crystal as well as a mirror of Rey’s struggle?

BTW, I vow to the best of my ability not to singlehandedly hold up the project - if it’s good to go apart from my last shots I’ll push them to the top of the list. 😉

Entire cockpit clean, now on to the surgery…

Eh, ESB had Yoda convincingly levitate an X-wing, I don’t think it would have hurt to give Anakin a moment of Force demonstration on that level.

Are we sure that’s higher quality than anything we have, or is he just implying that he got a fan project?

Chase Adams said:

That’s pretty amazing Nev, nice work! 👍

Bringing this scene to life now seems like much more of a possibility.

Though not sure what can be done about the temporarily obstructed elbow and face… 😕

Thanks! I’m cautiously optimistic that I can do the reconstructive surgery, but only time will tell…

You’re welcome, glad you liked it so much!

JEDIT: updated the mockup again, now most of the cockpit has been restored.

https://vimeo.com/590342667

Password: fanedit

Star Wars in 360 degrees. Looks to be 4K77 as well. A trippy time for all.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zTaz1DB8yAU

jadenkorr41 said:

I’ve been doing some of my own rotoscoping and masking for scenes for my own edits. I’ve shared some early WIPs in this thread. For starters I want to remove the ILM logo watermark from the galaxy fleet charging the star destroyers. Hal’s ascendant has most of the clip with the watermark removed, but there’s a longer clip of that and I was wondering on how to give that a go.

Which thread should I go to? I can’t seem to find a search feature for these forums… sorry

This thread is a good place to start, and though it doesn’t specify TROS I’m sure no one would mind that being included.

https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/Star-Wars-deleted-and-extended-scenes-database/id/51879/page/1

This is also a good general info area, though it again doesn’t include TROS since there are no official deleted scenes for the film so far.

Updated the prior mockup with the shot stabilized and the front console moved down. Next up - removing the camera and crowd.

This implies that JJ cares about anything past ANH where Luke was the galaxy-saving hero.

Oh it’s Star Wars related, JJ.

I think if the Vader scene had some lead-up, such as a scene where the Rebels worry about this ‘Vader’ character that seems to be close to discovering their operation, then it would work a lot better. As it is it comes rather out of left field in the context of the film and feels gratuitous in its horror and violence. I wouldn’t say it portrays Vader as a cool badass, but I understand why some would think this way.

In any case, RO’s problems are bigger than this one scene.

I haven’t made much progress recently, due to the fact that I’m working in art full-time and unfortunately that takes most of my creative energy. I haven’t forgotten about the project of course, it just might take longer than I originally thought to pull it together.

TLJ had the unenviable job of reconciling the characterization of Luke in TFA of being simultaneously a mere man with some Force power and also the most dangerous and powerful person in the galaxy, capable of singlehandedly saving or destroying empires.

I think making Luke into the cantankerous hermit he became is a fairly deft way of solving the problem, since it’s still imperative that Luke not take up too much of the air in the room and leave some for the new cast. Sure, it makes more sense for this Jedi Master to be actively working on a new Jedi Order but the same could be said for Yoda in ESB.

The problem of Luke is one of JJ trying to have his cake and eat it. Luke can’t simultaneously be the savior of the galaxy in perpetuity while also allowing the new heroes to shine. Luke’s death in my opinion was the first chance for the ST to really stand on its own creative feet, and it should have happened in TFA like the death of Obi-wan. Of course JJ couldn’t write an ending to Jenga so we got TROS, but the chance for greatness was there, set up by Rian’s necessary choice.

I think one of the main reasons there aren’t more good prequels is that they work best when recontextualizing the world, characters, or events of the original film in a way that makes them better in hindsight. However, if the film badly needs this recontextualization it usually wouldn’t be a good enough film to financially or creatively warrant any prequel or sequel. This leaves making prequels to successful, self contained stories that have narratively ended which almost always ends up lessening the impact of the original, not improving it.

Also, people are usually really drawn to the characters and world of the original films, which is why they would be interested in making prequels to them, and this means that unless they’re a madman like George they won’t significantly change the world or characters resulting in flat or nonexistent arcs like the monolithically powerful Rebellion in RO compared to later films.