This is all coming together so nicely. I can’t wait to see this version.
I’ll be doing some test screenings over the next month so if anyone is interested in my cut please PM me with “test screen” in the title.
Hal, if you’re doing the same can I put my name down for yours?
That captain Jack gif is extremely accurate 🤣
Here’s an alt for the end celebration including Coruscant in place of Endor!
Coruscant End Celebration
pw: faneditThe incredible backplate was made by jonh, and I comped in the ships and added a bit of texture.
This is beautiful!
Are the Ewoks being cut or moved?
Nice, poppasketti! That’s a wonderful surprise for this afternoon. You and jonh both.
And thanks for continuing to pioneer the Mustafar scene. I’m hoping LILLIAN will get me the other footage soon. That’ll be a little fun to put together, I reckon.
I’ve kept the separate .PSD files for each clip so if you pick a different colour gradient for your edit I can either sent you them or do it for you.
Exactly! Anything but what we got.
If anyone wants to use this I’ve just hand painted each blue blast frame yellow for the Mustafar scene just to get them to match, with help from kewlfish with colour balance.
https://vimeo.com/429055516 pw: fanedit
Poppa that looks epics mate! 👍
Wasn’t that already done in TLJ?
Not that I remember, He was in a generals uniform not a stormtrooper in TLJ? I just think that would have suited that story better rather than just walking straight in with barely an issue. Captain’s medallion was bad enough.
Here’s that clip for you: https://vimeo.com/429010558
Nice job. Appreciate you sharing. I’ll do a side by side preview and see which one fits. I cut the line “voices of the Jedi before” to fit with my narrative.
@Jonh, I couldn’t see anything wrong with your last upload. Your perfectionism is worse than mine. 🤣
It frustrated the hell out of me that they didn’t allow Finn to go full circle and to dress as Stormtrooper when they storm Kylos ship. I think they would’ve actually echoed ANH and actually worked with the storyline much better than everyone just walking around without triggering any alarm etc.
I didn’t know about the other Finn storyline. They would’ve been awful!
What do you mean by tick scenes, though?
I meant the missing scenes you haven’t ticked yet. I thought all those scenes were finished? They look great imo.
As an American married to a Brit, I think the confusion here is that Hal doesn’t know that a “tick” is a checkmark outside of the US
I didn’t know that. Nice! Thanks for clearing that up. It’s hard to know where everyone is from with just an avatar 😃
I meant the missing scenes you haven’t ticked yet. I thought all those scenes were finished? They look great imo.
Chase 🤣 Has jonh not finished lukes hair scene? Again, it looks finished but I have asked him to look at Zorii’s crazy hair segment.
I’d like to see your version of Rey & Leia if you have it posted? I think the audio was ok but I was just nit picking my own version as I know what tricks I used.
Do you not have the missing tick scenes?
Kewlfish and Lilian finished the mustafar scene.
DominicCobb finished the flash backs.
Can’t remember who finished the lightspeed edit but it’s was great.
Glad you’re using my Rey & Leia scene. I’d like to see how you execute it as I’m still nip picking mine as the passing of the Saber is still a little jittery as I’ve extended the slow mo to fit the score.
Jonh finished the hair.
In case you missed those?
latest and final version! corrected yoda height, luke’s hair in the last shot improved, and two more details improved … this is the final! hahahha, thank you very much!
BLUE
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1KZju5TYhqExWXN13T6Krqs-ZS9UL1cL9/view?usp=sharing
PURPLE
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1tSe7mW6WXpG4uTlyqsND-k2CBh6M4_NI/view?usp=sharingthere will be no more changes! I’m sorry, friends! 😉
hahaha! Are you sure? 😉
Amazing work, mate! Thanks for putting so much time and detail into getting this right.
Now I’m on the final lap of my edit, I’m starting to notice really stupid edits.
Has anyone noticed that J.J has over dubbed Poe saying “this way…” with “follow me!” Several times in the movie?
Can anyone recall Poe saying “this way.” In any other movies so I can replace the original audio?
Ive just aquired a box of original 1979-85 Star Wars toys but they’re lots of missing parts.
Has anyone tried to scratch build parts from casts?
I’ve been researching something called ‘blue staff’ and used milliput in the past but wondered if anyone has experience doing this?
Well done for setting out these rules. They’re very clear to me and the law.
I’m seeing far too many editors publically posting mega links etc to full movies and people not understanding it’s still piracy.
I’m not sure that’s the original. There’s a better example here https://youtu.be/RiBqZoVe92U
I really wanna try this deeplab program but you need to render for far too long. It’s really impressive what you can do on home computers now though. I’m thinking of adding it to my edit.
Personally, while I have allowed anybody to send in pretty much anything they wanted to record, I prefer to emphasize names and voices that we came up with ourselves. Ideally, it would be a bunch of fan edit enthusiast inserting themselves into the universe directly.
That’s a fantastic idea. Love it! 😃
Movies Remastered said:
I’d really love to change the end music. JJ seems to play the whole soundtrack in the last 40 minutes and doesn’t know who’s theme goes with what.The main new theme of the soundtrack (aptly titled Rise of Skywalker) is arguably its best and it really works during the triumphant Star Destroyers falling montage at the end, and during the final scene with Rey, Finn and Poe, so I wouldn’t change that particular track.
It’s the rest of the score during the celebrations on Ajan Kloss, however, the one that’s all over the place. Why use Yoda’s theme? Luke and Leia’s theme? They’re awesome pieces of music in their own right, but a great part of the appeal of Williams’s themes is the association between the actual music and the character/place it represents, otherwise they lose their meaning and become trivial.
I don’t see any issues with Yoda in jonh’s ghosts scene. For me it’s perfect the way it is.
Yeah, Luke & Leia’s theme over Lando and his daughter was off too. I’ve changed the ending significantly to fit that piece and made it second to last scene a very mixed emotional feel. I do think the score works well when Poe, Rey and Finn meet, I just seem to feel very aware of the changing tracks nearer the end of the film.
This guy made some great points https://youtu.be/L_8-dWSLDWI
So this video clip is a must for the final edit, Right?
FYI, Jonh has done a few updates to the scene done this upload. It looks even more awesome now.
A friend has told me that the proportion of yoda in the general shots is wrong, fucking shit, and now I can not stop seeing it too high, what annoyance, I will try to do an update in a few days 😓😓😓
It bothers me, because I have made you all download a thousand versions
Please don’t change the epic pan shot from Yoda to obi. Love that shot 💚. The only one the stood out for my was in the recent update where to do was an image from ESB?
Non of us are racing to a finishing line on this edit so don’t burn yourself out. You’re a valued team member so take your time. 😎
not! Only my friend told me that in the shots with Rey, he looks too high …
I’ll try to fix it
Yoda is just levitating to be in the shot more 😉 haha
So this video clip is a must for the final edit, Right?
FYI, Jonh has done a few updates to the scene done this upload. It looks even more awesome now.
A friend has told me that the proportion of yoda in the general shots is wrong, fucking shit, and now I can not stop seeing it too high, what annoyance, I will try to do an update in a few days 😓😓😓
It bothers me, because I have made you all download a thousand versions
Please don’t change the epic pan shot from Yoda to obi. Love that shot 💚. The only one the stood out for my was in the recent update where to do was an image from ESB?
Non of us are racing to a finishing line on this edit so don’t burn yourself out. You’re a valued team member so take your time. 😎
How’s this rendition of the victory celebration for the ending, especially if other planets are added to the falling Star Destroyers and maybe with people cheering
I’d really love to change the end music. JJ seems to play the whole soundtrack in the last 40 minutes and doesn’t know who’s theme goes with what.
This celebration track would be great if someone has been able to isolate the sound from the music?
So this video clip is a must for the final edit, Right?
FYI, Jonh has done a few updates to the scene done this upload. It looks even more awesome now.
Cool, Do you have the link to Jonhs updated version,Oh and Hal 😋
HAHA Hal 🤣
Here’s the current link. There are other changes by it’s tricky to navigate this site on my phone. If you go back a few pages on here Jonh has posted them all.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1vc8F3NObBvpb0Imb-ye6XSFRtYZEIP28/view?usp=sharing
So this video clip is a must for the final edit, Right?
FYI, Jonh has done a few updates to the scene done this upload. It looks even more awesome now.
Han Solo flashback concept idea I had, this could be executed alot better just a thought I had.
think it could work for maybe just 1 shot during the scene.
I like the idea but I feel it would get a little too inception type with a memory within a memory.
Either way it’s pretty awesome. I just thought the “for skywalker” part could be in surround as they’re everywhere. As is really works too.
