logo Sign In

Lexa C

User Group
Members
Join date
26-Mar-2024
Last activity
15-Jun-2024
Posts
97

Post History

Post
#1592133
Topic
Lucas on the Prequels - "It is a kids’ movie. It’s always been a kids’ movie."
Time

Fan_edit_fan said:

Lucas is back at it…blaming fans for any of his weaknesses in writing or directing. ???

He still can’t keep his stories straight, either.

• George Lucas on TPM: “It is a kids’ movie. It’s always been a kids’ movie.”

• Also George Lucas on why he made the Prequels, in 2019: “I decided that it would be important to finish it off and do the backstory [the Prequels] because things that I thought would be self-evident about the story, the audience didn’t get. Over the 10 years after Return of the Jedi, I realized people misunderstood a lot – such as where Anakin came from. So it was a way of finishing the whole thing off.”

So George says he made the Prequels as the Original Trilogy “audience didn’t get” things in the years after ROTJ was released, but then made it for kids, many of which weren’t even born at the time in the 10 years after ROTJ? Sounds right!

• Even George admits himself. in 2005, that he wasn’t aware that the six Star Wars “form the biography of Vader” “until 1998”.
 

• Also:

Question: You’ve often said that Star Wars movies are primarily meant for children, but The Phantom Menace was always going to be a film that was going to be significant for twenty/thirtysomethings. How did you address this problem?

George Lucas: “Basically I didn’t. I kept it as it was originally intended. You can’t play too much to the marketplace. It’s the same thing with the fans. The fans’ expectations had gotten way high and they wanted a film that was going to change their lives and be the Second Coming. You know, I can’t do that, it’s just a movie. And I can’t say, now I gotta market it to a whole different audience.

Yet Lucas hyped, marketed and promoted TPM and the coming Prequels like no other franchise before, for that older audience. Only when there was criticism of TPM, did the “It is a kids’ movie. It’s always been a kids’ movie” attempt of a poor excuse occur.

This is despite George also previously stating things like Star Wars “is for forever - for all generations” in promotional spiel:

img

 
It appears George really does not take or accept any kind of valid or reasoned criticism well at all.

And quite a stretch to full on straw-clutching with George trying to equate a minority of fans’ dislike of Threepio in the OT, to Jar Jar in the PT. Maybe George forgets that some kids and youngsters also didn’t like Jar Jar, TPM, and the PT.

That adults can also critique any film aimed “for kids”, and it doesn’t invalidate any criticism because of that.

Post
#1591926
Topic
TheStarWarsTrilogy.com - and invite codes to it <em>(read the actual thread before posting!)</em>
Time

FrogLantern said:

Please send me an invite code for https://forums.thestarwarstrilogy.com/

I love these movies and I am fascinated by this project. Please send a code my way.

?
 

 
 
↓ There are invitation codes to the TSWT forums in each of the Opening Posts of these three threads below. Kudos to Williarob.
 

OT•com threads: OriginalTrilogy.com Page for 4K77 : OriginalTrilogy.com Page for 4K80 : OriginalTrilogy.com Page for 4K83

^ There are invitation codes to the TSWT forums in each of the Opening Posts of these three threads - many thanks to Williarob.

 

 
 

TheStarWarsTrilogy•com forum itself also has the information required on how to join the forum linked to on their front page… literally for anyone and everyone to see:-

Looking for Project 4K77, 4K80, 4K83, etc? & You need to register before you can see these forums
 

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Post
#1591679
Topic
Which one do you like more? The Prequels or the Sequels? And why?
Time

I think there is already a thread on this conversation? In the General Star Wars Discussion forum? Probably in the “Rankings” or “Vs & Similarities” sections?
 

Edit: I found it. Prequels or Sequels; Which do you prefer - and why? (2020 thread, in General Star Wars Discussion)

Ranking the Star Wars films (2016 thread, in General Star Wars Discussion, but likely a good source for reviews after TROS’ release)
 

For me, neither. I don’t like either of the ST or PT.

If it came to a push, I’d probably go for the ST, simply because it had the “Big 3” characters from the OT, and they all had impactful ends in the ST films.

And that the ST didn’t directly contradict what was previously established in the OT (and the EU) in the way the PT flagrantly did. Maybe that the acting performances were stronger in the ST than the PT in general, but I’m not sure what story the ST was even trying to tell.
 

Some really cool fan edits for both the PT and ST make them far more enjoyable than watching the official cuts.

Post
#1591616
Topic
<strong>The OOT</strong> : The changes to the OT films &amp; general OOT (1977 - 1996) discussion thread
Time

DarthSmaul said:

Lexa C said:

img

The ORIGINAL THEATRICAL version of Empire Strikes Back is here! - Project 4K80

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=12xpgmLk5YM - 7 minute video from Evan’s Media

It would be cool to try to restore the 70MM version as well now that more information about it has been confirmed.

Oh yeah! Do the TN1 guys have a scan? Or are they busy doing the 1997SEs and theatrical Prequels?

Post
#1590973
Topic
<strong>The OOT</strong> : The changes to the OT films &amp; general OOT (1977 - 1996) discussion thread
Time

Some OOT (1977-1996; and fan preservations) release comparison videos for color and quality comparisons

 

img

Original ROTJ Opening 4X COMPARISON | Despecialized, 4K83, Blu-ray, OTD83 | Return of the Jedi

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nHcEb54vkiU - 8 minute video from Star Wars Comparison

Post
#1590808
Topic
<strong>2011 SE</strong> : The changes to the OT films &amp; general 2011 Special Edition discussion thread
Time

Blu-ray sales for ‘Star Wars’ top $84 million - https://variety.com/2011/film/news/blu-ray-sales-for-star-wars-top-84-million-1118043276

‘Star Wars’ breaks Blu-ray sales records - https://www.cnet.com/home/smart-home/star-wars-breaks-blu-ray-sales-records
 

Surprisingly, the 2011 Saga blu ray didn’t appear to sell anywhere near the amount of 2004 OT DVD release - https://money.cnn.com/2004/09/23/news/midcaps/starwars/index.htm (thanks to Keyan Farlander for the link)

^ $84 million in the first week for the 2011 Saga blu ray set ($79.99 per unit), but $100+million on the first day for the 2004 OT DVD set ($42 per unit).