Hard pass.
lol, Understandable. If I were making an edit, I’d try to keep it, but it’d likely never sound like it actually belongs there no matter how many times I’d watch it and end up detracting from the scene. It’s probably just the idea of it that I like.
An alternate Audio track would be cool with it in tact if possible. It’s not perfect, but it helps tie in Padme- this line change feels like the start of his transformation, drawing out memories.
I’ve always liked the first “No” as Vader picks up the Emperor. Obviously not the scream, but it feels like he’s finally broken through the fog. People that are fighting an alternate personality almost always access voice control first.
I, too, like the first “no”. Even though it felt like it really doesn’t belong, the idea of it works for me. It’s the 2nd, ROTS-style, bellowing “NOOOOO!!!” that totally ruins it.
I’ll leave Han tossing the guy to the rathtar.
Here’s the ‘no look’ shot with an added surprised ‘huh’. I’m not sure it works as well as I pictured. Maybe I’m missing something. I’m leaning toward leaving this shot out, as in V3.
https://youtu.be/VNai7UpPuao
Would it be possible to create a reaction shot? I feel like the ‘huh’ would work alot better with a brief reaction shot of Han. With something as short and simple as ‘huh’ you wouldn’t even need a shot with his lips moving