logo Sign In

JadedSkywalker

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Jun-2020
Last activity
21-Aug-2025
Posts
1,531

Post History

Post
#1525817
Topic
Question about SW: Definitive Collection Set
Time

The Japanese Commentary on the Analog channel?

The second release is the one to get if you want the making of trilogy, but it also goes for a lot more whenever it shows up in auctions or for sale.

i’m actually getting the making of separate. I’ve got making of Empire without OBI. Good squid has making of ROTJ for 30 bucks, i’ll just need making of Star Wars.

Post
#1525235
Topic
List of films with lossless original tracks not available on Blu-ray or UHD
Time

The Star Trek TNG films in 4K will have the same 7.1 audio as the 2009 Blu-Ray discs.

Not sure how original that is or not. Once again there is no Stereo 2.0 Dolby or DTS mix.

But i have my 2 Disc DVD releases of the TNG films and my Laserdiscs of Generations, First Contact, and Insurrection for the original audio. Its not HD but what can you do.

Post
#1524261
Topic
Heir to the Empire Trilogy. A General Discussion
Time

I like The Thrawn trilogy and Duology the most, the rest of his EU stuff is okay if you forget the prequelisms. The Disney stuff is solid writing but boring as hell without a Luke Skywalker, or Mara Jade.

The original arc of the trilogy and duology are almost perfect. Except for the invaders hinted at beyond the galaxies that turned out to be the Vong. Hated Thrawn and Palpatine being turned into the good guys. Hated Mara saying she didn’t believe the emperor reborn was Palpatine, that was Zahn taking a shot of Veitch.

Don’t care for in the trilogy how it is described Palpatine used the force to give strength to the Imperial Navy and after his death how they were routed. Too lord of the rings and Sauron.

Post
#1524189
Topic
How did you prefer to watch SW before the fan edits came along?
Time

The VHS Faces Cassettes, yeah all i could afford was the pan and scan not the more ritzy widescreen boxed set. And i had the earlier non THX Star Wars set, which i preferred to watch Star Wars on because the 1995 release had the smashing glass in the detention block which i never liked. The one i watched the most on tv and on tape was the 85 sound mix.

I didn’t get a laserdisc player or the definitive collection til around 2005. About ten years too late for it to mean anything but by that time they were cheap enough. Then i got some of the fan made DVDs and the rest is history. All the way up to the release of the GOUT DVD’s and 4K77 hitting the net. Buying the awful Disney 2020 4K Special Edition watching it once and putting it on the shelf.

Post
#1524185
Topic
Star Wars novels and comics review thread
Time

He had a lot more legends stories planned as well. More Thrawn, Mara and Talon Karrde. But of course Disney had the EU shelved and rebooted. And his new stuff is tailored to the Disney verse. Boring and uninteresting and political. Chiss politics. Imperial politics. Couldn’t finish Thrawn Treason. Don’t care for Disney Thrawn either. Not in Rebels, Not in the novels. Don’t care if he is in live action. He was slightly less unbearable in that comic Marvel made. Only because of its brevity.

Post
#1524179
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, & Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

The Nolan Batman trilogy is overrated. And Batman 89 and Batman Returns are underrated. I used to believe the opposite but Batman begins hasn’t aged all that well IMHO. Nor has Rises. I will say i still view Dark Knight as almost flawless except for Aaron Eckhart’s Two Face. Bale is just okay in it, Ledger plays Joker to the hilt.

Post
#1523908
Topic
How would you restructure Anakin's turn to the dark side in the Prequels?
Time

I would keep it basically the same. But have his turn to the darkside not be about learn the dark side to save Padme. Would require a total rewrite of the prequels. He would be a moisture farmer on Tatooine who gives up his farming to join Obi Wan on a damn fool idealistic crusade joining the Clone Wars. Obi Wan recruits him sensing a he has a gift for the force. Obi Wan is a general in the republic. The Enemy is clone masters and Mandalorians not Jango Clones fighting trade federation. Anakin is a great starpilot and a cunning warrior, and a good friend. He is slowly seduced to evil and a descent into madness. There is no Qui-Gon, we see Vader in the suit destroying the Jedi Temple but we aren’t sure who he is. Obi Wan thinks he killed him over the volcano they dueled over.

I’d keep Padme basically the same but have her actually be a character with something to do in II and III. She would help surviving Jedi escape the Purge, be a senator and one of the founding members of the rebel alliance. She does this in secret because she knows Anakin sees it as treason and a betrayal of his mentor the President of the Republic former Senator Palpatine.

She’s doesn’t die til later on Alderaan when Leia is very young. She is one of Queen Breha’s handmaidens to be close to Leia until she dies somehow?

Post
#1523788
Topic
I don't think Revenge Of The Sith is as good as everyone says it is.
Time

I like the opera scene. and how slick and evil Palpatine is. Still not sold on choose the dark side to save Padme. The movie needed something else for Anakin’s turn.

Worst aspect other than the out of place slapstick comedy, or cartoon cgi graphics are the lightsaber duels, or lack of them.

Wish they had done the battle of the heroes more like Empire’s fight except with the Jedi in their prime. And i wanted Mace to duel Anakin.