logo Sign In

JadedSkywalker

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Jun-2020
Last activity
21-Aug-2025
Posts
1,531

Post History

Post
#1538224
Topic
It seems like nobody involved in the making of the Original Trilogy has spoken up about George Lucas’ oppression of the unaltered theatrical version of the OT.
Time

The strangest thing is George Lucas promised Kershner final cut on Empire. The Special Edition is going back on his word and changing a film he didn’t direct. Worse on Return of the Jedi Richard Marquand was dead and couldn’t be consulted or asked. Only on the first film did he have a right as the director to change the movie. Still should have preserved the original for posterity.

Post
#1538220
Topic
The Weeb topic
Time

Don’t consider myself a Weeb. But i like Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Complex season 1 and 2, and Cowboy Bebop and Outlaw Star. I liked Soul Eater quite a bit, and Samurai Champloo but the ending was kind of meh.

I really liked the first season of Fireforce and the second season less so. But its not Soul Eater good. And the amount of fan service can distract from the overall story.

Liked the First season of Demon Slayer as well.

One Punch man was good for a few laughs.

Post
#1533176
Topic
'Rey Skywalker' (Upcoming live action motion picture) - general discussion thread
Time

If i watch it i’ll probably go in with an open mind and no preconceived notions. To be honest i have seen 8 of the 9 saga films in the theater and haven’t loved any of them since 1983. If i don’t bring in the baggage of 40 years of fandom maybe it will be an enjoyable 2 hours.

Going to do the same for Indiana Jones Dial of Destiny, but that will be tough it is hard to say goodbye to a favorite character and franchise. Star Wars ended twice for me. Once in 83 and again in 2017. I had the EU for some years but i only sort of have nostalgia for things in the 1990s up to the sale to Disney. Went to episode 9 to say goodbye to Luke and to celebrate the memories. That ticket was a gift i didn’t pay for it, probably wouldn’t have gone if it wasn’t.

I just don’t have an attachment to Disney Star Wars to quote Lucas its not my Star Wars. It is great it exists for the young and young at heart who haven’t turned in their fan card.

Post
#1532371
Topic
A '<strong>Rumour and News</strong>' thread for reported new Star Wars films and tv series
Time

I hated the new Indiana Jones V trailer. I’m a big fan of James Mangold, but if that flops will his Star Wars film happen at all. Hey maybe it will be his first real misstep as a director. Doesn’t mean Dawn of the Jedi has to suck though.

i’m only on board with Rey Skywalker’s movie if John Boyega returns as Finn as a Jedi Knight.

Filoni not sure on, his live action has been downright poor to mixed. His animated stuff has been phenomenally successful except for that one show Resistance.

Post
#1531967
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, &amp; Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

Sick of all the piling on and hate for Last Jedi. Does that make it a good movie in my opinion no. Its worse than the prequel hate at this point. I’m just as guilty for hating how Luke was written, but its a far better movie than Force Awakens, and Rise of Skywalker. Luke has story purpose and is a character no matter how he is written he isn’t the worthless maguffin Michael Arndt and JJ made him.

Making a sequel 35 years later to Return of the Jedi probably shouldn’t have been done. If it had to be made doing it as a one off is a terrible idea. Hiring a guy who hates sequels and the very idea of them, and only likes making original films not franchises also probably was a bad idea. The only place i’ll defend Rian is his film wasn’t by corporate committee, he didn’t make it to fan demand. He is an auteur like George Lucas. Unlike Abrams who tried to copy Lucas or Spielberg, and always had the fans in mind. Though never pleasing them, or earning their praise except when he remade A New Hope.

Post
#1531942
Topic
Your DVD Collection
Time

added Sword Art Online Blu-Ray Ordinal Scale. Aniplex America
added Sword Art online II box set Aniplex America Rightstuf Exclusive Blu-Ray
added Last Jedi Steelbook best buy 4K
added Rise of Skywalker Steelbook 4k

Going to get SAO season 1 but can’t afford the 173 bucks at the moment.Alicization is going to cost me more like 500 bucks to complete. Aniplex prices are untenable.

Post
#1530911
Topic
What is going on at lucasfilm cancelled un canceling cancelled Star Wars films and announced new Star Wars films.
Time

Would have loved Rian’s trilogy, and the old republic trilogy. Maybe even Rogue Squadron if Patty was able to prove the debacle that was Wonder Woman 84 wouldn’t be repeated. Beautifully shot movie, the script was kind of all over the place.

The problem is you are only as good as your last movie. If it flops Lucasfilm isn’t going to give you a shot at a Star Wars film. If it is controversial they will find a way to not move forward.

Post
#1530904
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

The attachment thing and keeping him from his mother should have been the reason he turned on the Jedi. Also a desire for justice, the Jedi didn’t care about the slaves. And his desiring power. Anakin wants the power to dominate life and the lives of others, and to maintain order through force. He aligns with Palpatine because they agree the Empire is the way to balance chaos. Obi-Wan doesn’t agree he trusts the people and believes in Democracy. He becomes an enemy of the new order.

Join the darkside to save Padme is just idiotic.

Post
#1530903
Topic
George Lucas: Star Wars Creator, Unreliable Narrator &amp; Time Travelling Revisionist...
Time

Why does Lucas feel the need to claim it was always one story about the tragedy of Darth Vader, and that was the subtitle when the evidence exists its not true.

Do younger fans take what he says in those audio commentaries at face value and believe him. I’m trying to be charitable, but how isn’t it a lie.

Post
#1530514
Topic
What changes would you make to the Sequels?
Time

Luke as a Jedi Master teaching a new generation of Jedi restoring the order. Leia as Chancellor of the New Republic, Han Solo as a leader in the New Republic Navy.

The rest of the plot didn’t need to follow the EU generally.

There is plenty of room to make up a story around the OT heroes without erasing their accomplishments and making them worthless. Luke doesn’t need to be a superhero just to be Luke and a wise teacher, kind and generous.

Write the story around the original actors so the new protagonists fit the established world Lucas created. At least they should have prominent supporting roles. Not one off cameos for shock value in killing them off. They don’t all have to survive the trilogy but there had to be a better way of passing the torch without killing the past.

Post
#1530140
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

There are some things i like in Episode II but they are few. Before Rise of Skywalker it literally was the worst film in the Saga. Some things Lucas implies or he just cut out of the film entirely but he left in those really bad romance scenes. Why didn’t he have that awful dialog rewritten like on the OT. That was something Kasdan and Huyck and Katz excelled at. I’m of the opinion Anakin isn’t supposed to be smooth like Han, but he is awkward. So it sort of works but it also is difficult to listen to. Especially considering this is Vader. But it kind of is reminiscent of whiny Luke. And we know Kylo whined too.

Post
#1529811
Topic
Last web series/tv show seen
Time

I have given up on Picard season 3. More Dark Dystopian Trek fanfiction. I’d watch a 4th JJ film but other than Strange New Worlds potential i’m done with Kurtzman Trek. I kept hoping Disco would get better the writing never improved. I adore the cast and i’m disappointed in its cancellation. Everything they did right was the more complained about aspects of the diverse cast and how progressive it was.

I’m enjoying the Quantum Leap sequel but it isn’t nearly as good or novel as the original. Doesn’t have the music or catchphrase. The background characters are better than the main though. The ones who work behind the time travel. But i can see it not making it past the first season.

Post
#1529806
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, &amp; Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

They leave a lot of money on the table with pirated DVD and Blu-Ray in general. Including the Original Theatrical Star Wars trilogy they don’t care. The bootleg of season 7 for clone wars for example from Malaysia has made the pirates a lot because Disney wants people to subscribe to a monthly service. I’m sure The Mando fanedits being sold is bad too. I mean at least the 4K77 and 4K83 stuff seems to have been pulled off Ebay.