I already saw Palpatine’s laugh from the IX trailer coming from the start.
I’m trying to handle some of it, but I keep running into it sounding unnatural when I try to separate the different parts of Sir Ridley’s clip. Here’s one that incorporates the reverb and some additional fading/other items.
I’m not a big audio editor, so I suspect that it still sounds rough. It’s doable and a more talented editor can find better clips/equalization/reverb effects to make it work. I would suggest finding a clip where James Earl Jones says a drawn-out “mother” (probably from his Bible audiobook). One of the more audio-minded people here could really make this idea a reality for Adywan’s edit.
This fan-made Steven Universe spoof of the “I am your father!” scene replaces “father” with “mother”.
Hey Adywan, what software are you using for your ANH:R HD edit?
I think you just nailed it perfectly Dre with “cinematic inbreeding” being the most efficiently accurate way of explaining the ST’s constant borrowing and repurposing of the OT along with a near constant appeal to nostalgia in so much that the latest trailer uses pretty much half of its runtime for actual OT and PT footage with the OT footage itself making up around a third of the total runtime.
So a 9 film saga trailer (even though its more of a sizzle reel exclusively for D23), that shows clips from the films in release order (ending with new clips from Ep9) , uses a third of its runtime to show the OT (3 films out of 9 turns out to be a third 😉 ) and this is supposed to show how Disney is constantly trying to appeal to nostalgia?
I think the fact that they’re showing footage from the previous films in the trailer is supposed to be inspired from the second trailer for Avengers: Endgame before it released in theaters.
I don’t have a problem with Leia using the Force. I don’t like the “flying Leia” scene because it looked really ridiculous (maybe it’s the CGI or the way it was shot).
Do you plan to release the edit in 4K?
I also wouldn’t show Vader as a redeemed Anakin. IMO, Vader has committed, ordered, and been compliant with too many war crimes for a single decent act to absolve him of his guilt. The farthest I’d go is showing Vader as a haunted Force ghost, still bearing his wounds in life, who’ll have to earn redemption in the afterlife.
And yet Luke still sensed the good in him.
Luke reveals to her that their father is Darth Vader and that he must defeat him personally.
Surrendering to Imperial troops, Luke is brought before Vader, and he tries to convince his father to return from the dark side of the Force.
Okay, what? Luke starts off wanting to defeat Vader, yet now he wants to redeem him?
That is a good idea! I think a helmet works. A corpse feels like a little too much I think.
Work’s been insanely busy the last few months, so not sure when, but that is something I’ll look into!
Is it because there’s no images or renders of Phasma’s corpse?
Sir Ridley made an edit in which Kylo’s scar is changed to be consistent with The Last Jedi. Do you plan on adding that change?
Was the “Revisited” title inspired from Adywan’s edits of the original Star Wars films?
I just rewatched Ice Age: Collision Course last night, and I couldn’t even make it halfway. It’s a really, really bad animated film.
When will you post your ideas for Episode II?
Honestly, I’ve forgotten what ideas I had.
Just come up with new ideas and write them on a piece of paper or even Notepad.
When will you do the rest of the saga?
Oh speaking of the DSII, Ady: I had always preferred the original DS even though the second “looks cooler” but, when ever I watch ROTJ it just doesn’t seem right. And I finally think I know why, its a 2D picture. I don’t how they managed to go from effects as stunning as those from ANH - which brought a giant space ball to life - to something as awful as what is in ROTJ but hey they did it. What puzzles me most, is that the DSII does actually have a physical model, but for some unfathomable reason they only shot if from one angle for the whole movie, and proceeded to just copy/paste it to every shot.
So idk whether you can do anything about this or if there a DSII models (3D or physical) out there or any or some other footage that can be composited to work but if you can, could you give it that same subtle spin that the DSI had?
Hope the edits going well!
Here is a model of the second Death Star that I found on Amazon!
This thread is for discussing anything that is related to the animation studio Pixar, whether it be their movies, characters, concepts, story, etc.
The “Despacito 2” parody video by FlyingKitty.
I am still watching the first Harry Potter movie.
Broom Kid said:
Luke’s story in ROTJ is not one of becoming successful in spite of his flaws. It’s overcoming those flaws, losing self doubt, and insecurity that make him successful, that make him a Jedi.
And people don’t just overcome things once and then they’re never a problem again, either. If a story has to continue, then drama must ensue. And Luke is a focal point of that drama. Nobody becomes a perfect person at age 30, no matter how fantastical the story is. There’s still a lot of learning and overcoming to be done, backsliding and correcting that has to be accounted for. Our heroes are still people, and people are inherently flawed. That they triumph over their flaws is inspiring. But triumph doesn’t erase everything. But that speaks to your next point:
To me that’s kind of the point of myths, and fantasies, that it isn’t reality. That we do not find out our hero is secretly a drunk, beats up on his loved ones, neglects his or her children, is afraid of hights, suffers from all sorts of compulsions, etc, etc. I don’t get the idea, that making the Star Wars characters more realistic automatically makes them better.
It doesn’t “automatically” make them better, but it does make them more sympathetic and more relatable IF the execution is done well.
Well, I might be more sympathetic, if I didn’t have issues with the execution as well. I feel TLJ failed to really sell Luke’s point of view. That even if you accept Luke letting his fear of a possible outcome get the better of him (despite being a Jedi, who are trained to not let fear control them, and know that the future isn’t set), I don’t see how abandoning everything, and leaving the galaxy at the mercy of two dark siders is in any way a solution to the problem. I feel given our history with the character we deserved a proper setup to his character arc in TLJ. In stead the movie gives us one flashback, where Luke seemingly forgets everything he learned, and then runs from the consequences. This to me makes Luke less relatable, and less sympathetic. In the end Luke needs to be convinced to do the right thing by Yoda, even after he learns of his best friend’s death.
This is the REAL problem with Luke’s character: the problem isn’t that he is depressed or has PTSD, the problem is that they didn’t justify Luke’s behavior enough. They could’ve given more reasons for his depression: maybe he went and tried to find a way to save Ben, but everytime he tried so he failed, and decided to give up. They could’ve also explained that Luke felt like HE was the monster for accidentally unleashing a new dark sider onto the galaxy, leaving his friends behind because he felt like he’d make things worse.
I knew something was off the moment he showed up in his old outfit (and if you think about it, the blue saber) but I was confused the entire time on my first viewing until the lightsaber. I thought it was great.
Speaking of his old outfit, I’m sure Luke might have kept it in his hut. I mean, we don’t really know what actually happened to it.
The clothes and the beard were a dead giveaway. So was the saber. I got what was going on right away. It was a great scene.
Don’t forget the hair.
Luke used Kylo’s own emotions to his advantage.
No, really. Rian Johnson confirmed this in an interview with IGN.
Did he still have it on his belt in that final shot of the first flashback where he’s kneeling next to Artoo watching the training temple burn?
I’m sure Luke would’ve Force-pulled it out of the debris of Ben’s hut off-screen.