ElectricTriangle

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/167733

Any sentence involving -1 can be started with “Why on Earth…”

Jay said:

I must be missing something, because most of the DC additions and alternate takes are an improvement (especially the bit about Scotty’s nephew, which wasn’t in the theatrical cut and caused Scotty’s subsequent emotional breakdown not to make sense) and the color balance and shadow detail are so much better on the DC.

Hunt mentions that he’ll have more news on Star Trek BDs, so I’m hoping we finally get properly restored versions of the rest of the filmography.

The Director’s cut is the dvd. The one labeled theatrical is the blu ray.

this image is now

the property of the team.

do not use please, thanks…

==========================

edit:

we will no longer

use markdown now. please move the

image, it is wrong

=======================================

all posts now should be

required to be images

or haiku. please lock

Ah. That makes sense.

I think the first DVD of Toy Story is also transferred from film. I remember the special features from “A Bug’s Life” making a big deal that the DVD is the first to be directly transferred from the digital files. I think it’s the 2nd DVD that’s a purely digital render.

VLC is confused because the audio stream disappears. (The audio is all GOUT synced, and does not extend over the extra credits). Other players are unaffected (Media Player Classic can seek through the extra credits fine).
It’s just VLC being confused by a uncommon setup.

Good job.
These should be the final chapters for Harmy:
TSMuxer:
http://pastebin.com/pHBwNhiH
MKVToolNix OGM Format (save as a .txt file and then attach):
http://pastebin.com/idtW9C51

You should use these chapters instead:
http://pastebin.com/pHBwNhiH
These are NSTC, and the originally posted ones look like PAL (they are incorrect by the end of the film).

Use these named ones for use with mkvtoolnix-gui:
http://pastebin.com/idtW9C51

You don’t need the names.

Working Links:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5iDjFsZ2L78
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wxgkkJOEHS4

Harmy said:

There’s definitely something to that Technicolor look though 😃

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/158521

Oh god yes. Those colors with this thing would be wonderful. (There is still the unfortunate light leak present through most of it, but the scan has a remarkable amount of detail for what it is. The fact that people don’t have smeary Loweryized faces is just great.)

Syncing the negative1 version to the GOUT and color correcting it to match Harmy’s reference material would produce a nice copy of the film. As it stands the colors on the negative1 version seem initial. (Their color correction removed most of the red tint, but it ultimately doesn’t look very great).

TV’s Frink said:

Too bad you aren’t hardcore about sentence structure, capitalization, and punctuation…

I think you missed his sarcasm.

That golden cast is very much intentional and based off film sources Harmy has.

Anchorhead said:

Delicieuxz said:
I can’t accept TFA as a real entry in the SW saga because it devalues the events in the original trilogy, and renders all those trials, lessons, and victories as nullified, by the very people who achieved them.

http://www.giantbomb.com/articles/off-the-clock-space-opera-millennials-and-their-gr/1100-5371/

This article is an excellent explanation of why some fans may be struggling with Lucas’ fairy tale ending being erased. Real life doesn’t always end with dancing plush toys.

This is an excellent read and Austin Walker is a treasure. I’m so glad Giant Bomb hired him.

I see so much being made out of the fact that TFA takes so much of its story beats and imagery from the first Star Wars movie, but never really much discussion about the context in which it does so. TFA focuses on protagonists who are living in the shadow of larger than life figures.
Rey has a Rebel Pilot doll. Kylo Ren seeks to follow in Darth Vaders footsteps. All of them have missing parent figures. There’s that wonderful scene where Fin recognizes Han as a war hero, and Rey recognizes him as a smuggler. Heck, at one point in the movie there’s a shot that frames the deactivated R2-D2 as a rather imposing and statuesque figure over the smaller BB-8. All of this colors the new character’s decisions and attitudes in a way that isn’t seen in the original trilogy.

TFA sufficiently retells the Star Wars myth in the way that the original Star Wars retold the old space adventure serials and the classic hero’s journey.

boffy said:
Also, was the sound completely/majorly remixed for 2004 DVDs, or is the 2004 mix largely the same as either/both of the 1997 mixes (apart from obvious changes like Emperor, Boba Fett, etc.?)

Star Wars was completely remixed. (In a terrible fashion; the 2004/2011 mix is atrocious). ESB and ROTJ are mostly the '97 mixes with more changes.

MeTV still runs the original series.

Wazzles said:

I’m not entirely sure it’s seamless. The color timing of the live action shots is much less saturated in the unaltered versions. Also, they only use the original mono audio.

I thought they match color wise very well, or at least to the degree they did in the SD masters (optically composited special effects are always going to look a bit different from the live action stuff).
You can switch from the mono to the surround track with your remote if you want. (The reason they don’t show this option in the menu is because the stereo pans are based on the new shots of the Enterprise rather than the old, so it can be disconcerting. The mono sounds good.)

Whooo! Very exciting. Your dedication to these audio tracks is incredible (and sounds great).

It looks like it was, Harmy. The GOUT seems to match the 35mm scan.

CatBus said:

The 77 mono mix, 85 stereo mix, and 93 stereo mix all have it. For stereo I’d recommend 85.

The '93 mix doesn’t actually have it.

Harmy said:

Yeah. I’ll use hh’s 5.1 audio, becuase it downmixes pretty well on stereo equipment, so people with both stereo and surround setups can enjoy it. Have there been any updated versions since the release of v1.0? And also, wasn’t there a version that syncs better with v1.0’s PAL-GOUT based sync? I’ve based the cut of this version on v1.0.

HH hasn’t done a new version, but Catbus resyned the 5.1 to the PAL version of Jedi.