That's really dissapointing. Not for me, but for you. I've been interested in this edit for awhile now, but that interest is nothing compared to the time and effort you must have into this edit. I can't begin to understand what you're feeling. Stay strong, and good luck.
Bingowings said:
To a degree I'd agree with you there Mr Cobb.
It could be argued that some of these 'inconsistencies' add realism.
As in the real world, damaged vent covers sometimes wouldn't get fixed and lightbulbs (or whatever they use on Bespin) wouldn't get immediately changed.
One of the reasons the PT looks so plastic is because it lacks little details like that which may have been accidental but add to the flavour of the piece.
But there is no harm in pointing them out so if Ady does want to screw a bulb in there he knows where to set up his ladder (so to speak).
For what its worth I actually don't think any of those vents need to be fixed. My comment was more of a response to muddyknees' general statement about telling a story vs. fixing things in the background (which was a joke? I'm sorry, I guess I need to pay more attention).
muddyknees2000 said:
Dude, you know theres a story being told during this film right? Its right in the foreground, more or less right in front of all those tiny little lights in the background. If you squint real hard you can just make it out...
I might be mistaken but I'm pretty sure that ESBR is essentially ESB with updated visuals. Fixing these inconsistencies is kind of the point.
Clothes
I'm glad this thread was made. On this site changing the OT to fit the PT is avoided like the plague. I understand the sentiment, but I don't agree. My preferred versions are the theatricals and the revisited (well they will be when released). But the problem with these is that they don't work 1-6. I've always believed that the correct order is 4-6, 1-3 (although now I'm for 4-5-1-2-3-6) and I've stuck by this belief because its the only way the movies work as is.
I would love to see versions of the OT that were specifically made to satisfy those watching 1-6. Sure the movies probably wouldn't be as good, but that's not really the point. People argue that putting PT elements in ANH would take away the ability for it to stand alone. Well, don't we already have TWO near perfect versions of ANH that stand alone? Why not one that would follow the PT more closely?
MrInsaneA said:
Another possible music alteration for the lightsaber battle.
Thoughts?
I personally liked it. It wasn't an emotional piece like the other one you had, and, well, I just think it works really well. I love the idea of putting OT music in the PT. Keep up the good work.
CatBus said:
I was 7 when Empire came out, and while it was certainly a cool movie I liked a lot, it had a lot of stuff that was hard for a kid to process. Down ending, moral ambiguity, not to mention the sexual tension. Star Wars and Jedi were much more satisfying for kids--the bad guys got beaten and there was a big KABOOM to prove it.
I liked Star Wars better until I had time to grow up and have a better understanding of Empire. Empire is certainly the least kid-friendly of the movies, and when a large chunk of your fans are kids, that means it's not going to be as popular at first. But there's no doubt in my mind it's the best of the movies.
That's funny. I always preferred Empire as a kid, but if you ask me now, I rate the original ever-so-slightly higher.
This seems intriguing, but I'm confused (although maybe it seems intriguing because I'm confused). What's the general objective of this edit? I would like to know more.
Kongerne said:
hey guys,
Found this on youtube, I thought it was pretty funny, just wanted to share it you guys
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ae1AiFNKFBk&feature=feedu
back to the topic
You "found it", but it only has eight views...
And I actually thought it was kind of funny, but only because of the accents (which I don't believe are fake).
back to the topic
Battleship: the Movie...with aliens!
Oh, wait...
ImperialFighter said:
Considering he was falling straight down, right in the middle of a very wide chasm...this 'vent' must have had an extraordinary amount of 'suction' to pull him in from so far away... Fair enough, but how come none of the other 'vents' in the wall that he already plunged past managed to 'suck him in' when he passed?... This particular one must have had 'turbo suction' I guess...
Why do the stormtroopers always miss? Why is there gravity in the meteor? Why does Leia make out with Luke?
All very good questions...
I always thought he used the force to guide him to the vent, but after just watching the scene, its pretty clear that I'm stupid. I think its very obvious that he's sucked into the vent, though the shot definitely needs a touch up.
Episode I: A New Foe
Episode II: The Republic Fights Back
Spence's edit has the best ending in my opinion. Finish with the Vader's funeral. Its perfect.
Judge said:
Or, if you wanted to take the effect even further, start with Anakin's march on the temple as a closeup of his face that gradually zooms out to reveal all the stormtroopers.
That's honestly one of the best ideas I've ever heard.
MrInsaneA said:
The first trailer for Star Wars Definitive, done in the style of the original 1977 Star Wars trailer. Any comments/criticism would be appreciated :)
And I thought the colors in the 3D trailer were messed up...
Jaitea said:
DominicCobb said:
The real question is how long would it take people on Tatooine, the outer rim of the galaxy to find out about the DS. A week? I think Coruscant works.
Just had a thought, at the end of Jedi (the SE versions) there are scenes of worlds celebrating the defeat of the Emperor, including Tatooine......
J
True, true. I still think Coruscant is plausible. To even just be there for a day, to overlook the Senate when the Emperor announces its being dissolved, seems likely. Why would any Senator argue against the Emperor when a weapon that could destroy their planet looms over their heads?
Jaitea said:
I don't really care for any part of the prequels to be integrated into the original trilogy.....maybe thats why I'm being negative.
This just sounds like the sort of modification the modern Lucas would introduce
J
I understand the sentiment, but it just seems like hating for the sake of hating. Adywan added a planet right? So why not Coruscant? Adywan added a battle droid too, but I don't usually see people complaining about that.
Jaitea said:
Yeah it sounds like a good idea, but when our heroes discover the Death Star at the remains of Alderaan, Han especially can't believe what he's seeing, if it had been stationed at the Empire home planet, the nerve centre of the galaxy every star system would know. The ultimate weapon may end up guarding Coruscant, but I think at this early stage it would still be hidden,....dunno
J
I knew this thought would come up. Who says its been stationed at Coruscant for long? Considering at the start of ANH the Imperials are starting to reveal the DS to the galaxy, wouldn't it make sense to unveil above Coruscant? Maybe there was some sort of launch party of some sort. It sounds silly, but it seems a possibility. The real question is how long would it take people on Tatooine, the outer rim of the galaxy to find out about the DS. A week? I think Coruscant works.
I know people are always looking for ways to put Coruscant in the OT (or at least I am), so I was thinking, remember the planet the Death Star orbits in ANHR? What if it was Coruscant?
TV's Frink said:
DominicCobb said:
TV's Frink said:
Throw an x-wing at the button?
I don't like the scene where Luke tries to lift the X-wing. Since we already know he can lift a rock, why can't he lift the X-wing with a rock?
Well there you go, he's supposed to lift the X-wing with the force.
In all seriousness, Luke says "it's too big." Yoda replies "size matters not," so the problem is clearly in Luke's perception of his task. I don't understand why this is a problem.
Or were you joking? It's tough to tell.
Definitely joking. I was following up your ridiculous idea with another ridiculous idea. It probably didn't help that I was the one who suggested the change to the Rancor scene in the first place.
Joshua_Blue said:
Here it the new conference room video: http://vimeo.com/31169717
I still does need some tweaking, but generally this is it.
At :38 there's a shot of Tarkin that lasts about a second. It's a bit jarring. You should either make it longer, or take it out all together.
doubleofive said:
Adywan says:
"Well i've almost finished transferring all the FX work to the new blu-ray sourced video. The difference in quality between the HDTV and the Blu-Ray is pretty noticeable. Some shots weren't as easy as just importing the new source video because of the slight differences in colour, grain structure etc. So these need a lot more work. But i've tweaked most of the shots in some small or large way."
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/89537
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/89539
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/89542
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/89543
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/89544
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/89545
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/89546
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/89548
AH! I never noticed no-neck Vader. Now I'll never miss it when I watch ESB. Thank God for ESB:R!
TV's Frink said:
Throw an x-wing at the button?
I don't like the scene where Luke tries to lift the X-wing. Since we already know he can lift a rock, why can't he lift the X-wing with a rock?
^This.