logo Sign In

C3PX

User Group
Members
Join date
31-Aug-2005
Last activity
30-Sep-2010
Posts
5,621

Post History

Post
#371441
Topic
What (to you) is the most foreboding/tension filled star wars music track/cue?
Time
Jonno said:

Considering that there are hardly any actual songs in the Star Wars universe, let alone scary ones...

So far we have listed three (3), and all three of them are damn scary! There are several others as well we have yet to mention, especially if you want to count things like the theme song to the Ewoks cartoon series (which is also of the stuff nightmares are made of).

 

Post
#371387
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time
Darth Venal said:

I hope my Alderaan destruction comes off as well as it's shaping up, because it is definitely something worth doing. Seeing a planet blown up in seconds while never seeing the people who live there isn't very strong dramatically, and I never liked how Lucas pulled it off...

I'm also considering showing the Death Star travelling through hyperspace, and bending it because of its size...

 

Sounds like you have some pretty neat ideas.

Post
#371366
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time

Hmm, interesting development...

 

Perhaps this is Mr. Ghostface's friend who he mentioned was working on an edit? Mr. Ghostface didn't strike me as the type who'd sink to the level of creating an alter ego to defend himself with, but then again, you never really can tell with the internets.

Post
#371362
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time
Darth Venal said:

Thanks for the welcome!

I'll probably keep any unenthusiastic comments to myself, because no matter how well-intended they are, you always get attacked for them.

Unfortunately true in this thread.

However, I reassure you, there are plenty of other thread where this will not be the case. For example, in Trooperman's Shroud of the Darkside thread, quite a lot of criticism has been given over the years, some constructive, some just meant to be discouraging, and in all cases, everything was handled pretty well. That thread never, that I can remember, degraded into anything unfortunate. Ady's thread has had a huge following, many people who only joined up because of his edit, and I think this is what resulted in the major sensitivity thing.

I'd like to encourage you not to remain just a background member, but of course you are free to do as you choose. But you might actually find this place to be a very enjoyable forum to post in. Over in off-topic, and the general SW discussion threads, we are pretty friendly an welcoming and are always happy to have new members join in on discussion. We are a pretty small community, so new faces are always welcome. Just please don't take what you have read in the last few pages of this forum as the norm.

 

Mr Ghostface said:

Well, I won't stop posting anyway, because I will be sharing some screencaps from my own edit (which is in conjunction with another forum member) and I'd like to know what the more mature members of the board think.

 

Glad to hear it. I am not really big on edits (most of them are just more of the same), but every now and then something strikes my fancy. I'll definitely be checking out the thread for your edit and your screencaps once you get them posted.

Post
#371355
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time

Mr. Ghostface, remember what I said about the sensitivity surrounding this project? Well, the zombie hoards are coming! It'll only get worse from here. I'd consider getting my shotgun and making a stand with you (which is not to say I agree with all you have been saying), but I think I'd rather just cut and run. No matter how many you blow down, more will just keep coming. It is a hopeless battle.

It makes me sad that some people consider a hacked up and modified version to be the "definitive", but what does it really matter to me or you anyway?

I guess the whole, the GOUT has pretty colors bit is out... because peace looks a long ways off. My feelings are that this discussion has nowhere to go but down.

Post
#371351
Topic
What (to you) is the most foreboding/tension filled star wars music track/cue?
Time
Jonno said:

I'd just like to state here, once and for all, that a SONG is a piece of music with VOCALS. The term does not apply to instrumental music, such as film scores.

 

Sure, he did just say, "Scariest star wars song?" in the title of his thread, but in his actual post he wrote,

what is the scariest star wars music/song/track to you?

I think this sufficiently proves he knows the difference between song and instrumental music.

 

 

Post
#371295
Topic
Tell me what [movies] to watch!
Time

All Quiet on the Western Front (1930's version)(WWI from the perspective of low ranking German soldiers)

Bridge Over the River Kwai (WWII film, starring Alec Guinness. Based on a book by the same man who wrote The Planet of the Apes)

Tora! Tora! Tora! (well known film about Pearl Harbor)

Midway (WWII, battle of Midway, film stars Charlton Heston)

Dr. Strangelove, or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb (Cold war, anti-war comedy by Stanley Kubrick)

Full Metal Jacket (Vietnam, another anti-war film by Stanley Kubrick)

 

I like all these films to some degree or another, but the first two on the list are the ones I recommend the highest. If you and your buddies don't mind old black and white films, All Quiet on the Western is HIGHLY recommended.

 

 

EDIT: FF posted while I was typing this, I must agree with him, Black Adder Goes Forth (fourth season of British TV series Black Adder starring Rowan Atkinson), is quite good. My favorite season of the series in fact.

 

Post
#371286
Topic
Film Certificates.
Time

Sometimes I really like to get into the era when watching a movie. I really like to grab several films from the same year, and to watch them all in the course of a week or so. Wikipedia has made this even easier. I now also like to check wikipedia for important things that were going on that year. Kind of silly, but it puts the films in fun context, bringing myself a bit closer to the mindset of the original audience.

 

Post
#371221
Topic
Film Certificates.
Time

Can't help you with the BBFC certificates, but as for other films being advertised, this might be useful:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_in_film

I have always found wikipedia's year lists to be very useful for putting films into the context of their time (which is something I always like to do.

 

The Spy Who Loved me came out that year, not sure what month, but that might be a cool trailer to show along side CE3K's trailer.

Post
#371216
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time
Mr Ghostface said:

...

I think most people who also did will agree that digital editing, once you learn the software, is easy. Yes, Adywan added many more elements, and some of them are excellent. Some of them are not. But the editing part is nothing special, almost anyone can do it if they try...

It has never been the editing bits of SW:R that has had people impressed, but rather those added elements. It is just down right ridiculous how easy it has become in to do editing on your home PC in the last few years. It is no exaggeration to say that it can be done by absolutely anyone who is willing to give it a try. But those added elements are the thing that makes Ady's edit unique, it, not the editing, is what puts many here in awe.

You did come off a bit strong in your initial posts on the subject, but also realize that Ady's edit has had a history of sensitivity around it (though not from Ady, but his fans. This can be seen by browsing the pages, the bits linked to about MojoLA are an excellent example). It has some extremely loyal fans who feel the need to defend its and Ady's honor to the death. But like any creative endeavor, it doesn't need that, there will always be those who think it is smack you in the face brilliant, and those who think it is pure crap, and of course everything in between. That is the beauty of real life, you can like whatever you want, and dislike whatever you want.

 

Post
#371188
Topic
Star Wars: Deleted Magic (Released)
Time
pittrek said:

The new version is pretty good, but I still prefer the original

 

I have the original version, and was thinking about replacing it with this new version. Any reasons not to? You said you preferred the original, the original is the only one I have seen, but I think it is great. Is there anything on it I will miss if I chuck it out and get the new one? Is the new one worth taking the time to dl?

Post
#371186
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time
Bingowings said:

If you aren't on here to help in anyway why are you here?

If you aren't prepared to back up you claims with hard evidence or your membership on this forum with some useful advice or projects of your own it's perfectly reasonable for us to surmise that you a useless fraudster and should be defenestrated from Castle OT.COM ASAP.

 

Perhaps we should be cautious of how high in the air we hold our noses, I have heard of good people drowning from this when a big rain comes along.

I don't think anyone needs to defend their membership here. These boards are open to anyone with a computer and an internet connection. This isn't an exclusive club where you have to make some amazing SW fan edit, or have made suggestions to an editor of one in order to be welcome. If so, then I suppose myself and several other regular members here are not welcomed either.

Mr. Ghostface is quite welcome here, and has absolutely no need to fear being defenestrated from OT.com so long as he doesn't go along breaking any of the forum rules, and so far, he has not, nor has he given us any reason to suspect he might do so in the future.

 

Post
#371183
Topic
Thread I saw on IMDb: When did you realize Palpatine's true identity? (in the PT)
Time
Mielr said:

I always knew Padme was Queen Amidala, too. If either of those were intended to be plot twists, then they didn't work.

 

The problem was everyone knew Portman was playing the role of the queen before even going to see the movie, then sudden she is introduced to us as the queen's hand maiden. So that was another one that wasn't too hard to figure out.

Post
#371127
Topic
10 years after Episode I - Jake Llyod interviewed
Time

Because Baronlando, discontentment is immoral. Jesus wants you to be happy. That is why he convinced George to give us the GOUT. When you are not happy with your GOUT, it makes Jesus very sad :(

The TFN-superfan-type have seen the light and recieved a calling to go out into all the world and convince those in the darkness that the 2004 SE is the one true version of the films. Those other films... well... lets just say they are on VHS. VHS is Satan's preferred format and what the citizens of hell are damned to watch for all of... damnation.

Post
#371126
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time
Mr Ghostface said:

Star Wars was a moderately budgeted sci-fi flick which happened to do big business. If there are minute discrepancies between the position of R2-D2 in one shot and the next, because of the practicalities of the shoot, who cares? Not very many people. If some scenes don't have music, maybe Lucas and Williams know what they're doing? And so who cares if someone spends hours of their time "correcting" something that never needed correcting?

I feel very much this same way. To me the only perfect version of SW will be the original. People can edit and hack all they want, and they will never make a better version of this film. What made Star Wars so special was never the special effects.

That said, I think you are missing the important point that some people DO care about all those nerdy little details in minute discrepancies, even if guys like you and I don't. Not that these guys don't enjoy it as is, but they obviously do find fixing all these things to be very worth while, otherwise Ady's edit wouldn't have been as overwhelmingly popular as it is.

 

Also, considering you are in "the business", which could mean any number of things, I will hazard to assume you are around special effects work quite often, and are used to seeing on a regular basis effects work being build from the ground up that makes Ady and WXM's stuff look like birdhouses made of popsicle sticks compared to skyscrapers.

You have to understand that something like this being made by amateurs is no small feat, and edits of SW:R quality and scope are not only rare, but entirely unheard of.

 

Post
#371112
Topic
&quot;When white will embrace what's right&quot;
Time

So today I was at IGN and saw a bit from Comic-Con '09 where Peter Jackson was asked about the Halo film he was at one point working on and if it was still a possibility. I couldn't believe how skinny Jackson looked, as I remember him being a bit plummy, this encouraged me to check out his IMDB page. From here, I noticed a film he worked on coming out this year called District 9, looked into it more and wound up being drawn in by the title of a thread on its message board, which gave me a link to a web site of crazy white folk who hate the world and are scared to death of minorities taking over the country (I am talking Micheal Weiner level worked up).

Kind of funny how one thing leads to another on the interwebs isn't it? You start out at one place, and who knows where you'll end up. Kind of like this new topic I started...

Alright so, to the point. At this crazy cracker fest of a website they were going on about how Hollywood has a big propaganda machine going about trying to destroy the white man. They mentioned a movie I rather liked, Gran Torino, as an example of how a prominent white cultural icon has sold out and joined the propaganda machine. Made me think of my own perception of the film, and what I read into it, versus what these lovely folk read into it. Just curious where others landed on this spectrum as well. Did anyone here sense even a modicum of anti-white sentiment when they saw the film?

 

<<Spoilers for said film follow!>>

In Gran Torino I saw a grouchy old man who was having a hard time facing the demons of his past deeds, while watching the world and the neighborhood around him change. The world he knew was fading, his wife died, through his grandchildren he saw how disrespectful modern youth were, and through the changing demograph of his neighborhood how different his country was becoming. He got to know his neighbors and realized even though they are different, they hold many of the same values as he does, even more so than his degenerating own family line. In the climax he sacrifices his miserably cancer ridden self and the few remaining years he might have lived in order to bring a better live to these two immigrant kids he has come to love. Having been less than impressed with his spoiled grand daughter who flat out asked him if he'd leave her his car when he died right after her own grand mother's funeral, he leaves his Gran Torino to Tao, his young immigrant next door neighbor who he had been mentoring and had been his closest companion during the last weeks/months (not sure of the films timespan) before his death.

 

These crackers at the site I mentioned interpreted it as follows:

"Eastwood shames himself in ‘Gran Torino’. He plays a flawed man who, by the movie’s climax, redeems his sins against non-whites by a Christ-like death. In his final gesture of capitulation, he hands the ownership of America (symbolized by his beloved American-built auto) over to a younger, morally superior immigrant, who drives off to a future without whites."

-first post regarding the subject

 

"It’s hard to believe these white men would lend their images as American icons to such blatant propaganda.

I agree that Grand Torino was hideously anti White - one of the worst ever and yes the death image of the Clint Eastwood character being crucified at the end, giving his life to give America over to the Laotian Hmong immigrants who would somehow renew America to the golden age of the 1950s - what #*$#@(@."

-post in response to the first post