Different lightsaber builds or crystals produce the variants in ignition noises. That’s why Sith lightsabers make their distinctive sound, while Jedi blades largely make the ANH ignition sound (the ROTJ sfx being specific to a certain hilt/crystal designation).
Also, wasn’t the PT (especially ROTS) known for reshoots? Weren’t Anakin’s reasons for falling to the dark side completely changed during production?
I just donated. Wishing you and your mother the best.
His whole channel is overanalyzing things in the search for misogyny where none exists.
That and taking so long in between uploads it’d make Fredrik Knudsen/Atrocity Guide blush. Except your average Fredrik Knudsen video has five times the research that Pop Culture Detective does and is invariably more engaging. Why watch another “these movies don’t like women and are therefore bad” video when I can learn about the Austrian Wine Poisoning, the Dolphin House, Deep Blue, the HaseKara Calamity/doxing saga, or TempleOS?
Pop Culture Detective got popular because he was on the “good” side of GamerGate, not because of any serious talent as a video essayist. While I do like some of his videos and agree with a lot of his points (e.g., why prison rape jokes are terrible), he’s hardly a standout.
But back on topic. My suggestions for little edits to better blend OT and PT would be to add back in the “this Sith Lord, sent by the Emperor, will be our undoing” line into ANH, the aforementioned Obi-Wan line tweaks, and maybe a little vision sequence in ROTJ to include a slight ROTS throwback (so Luke knows the face of young Anakin/Padme’s name). That way, an upgraded Hayden ghost (i.e., no Shaw body and a more wholesome smile) and Vader saying “Padme once thought as you do.” makes sense.
These are really good ideas, I especially like the one about adding Tagge’s Sith namedrop to ANH. Has anyone been able to find HD footage of that scene? I’ve only been able to find the hand-held celebration camera footage.
I think it made its way into some Lost Cut footage, with far cleaner audio. It’s from the same camera set-up as Tagge’s later shot in the conference room scene, so it could be as easy as animating his lips to match the words.
His whole channel is overanalyzing things in the search for misogyny where none exists.
That and taking so long in between uploads it’d make Fredrik Knudsen/Atrocity Guide blush. Except your average Fredrik Knudsen video has five times the research that Pop Culture Detective does and is invariably more engaging. Why watch another “these movies don’t like women and are therefore bad” video when I can learn about the Austrian Wine Poisoning, the Dolphin House, Deep Blue, the HaseKara Calamity/doxing saga, or TempleOS?
Pop Culture Detective got popular because he was on the “good” side of GamerGate, not because of any serious talent as a video essayist. While I do like some of his videos and agree with a lot of his points (e.g., why prison rape jokes are terrible), he’s hardly a standout.
But back on topic. My suggestions for little edits to better blend OT and PT would be to add back in the “this Sith Lord, sent by the Emperor, will be our undoing” line into ANH, the aforementioned Obi-Wan line tweaks, and maybe a little vision sequence in ROTJ to include a slight ROTS throwback (so Luke knows the face of young Anakin/Padme’s name). That way, an upgraded Hayden ghost (i.e., no Shaw body and a more wholesome smile) and Vader saying “Padme once thought as you do.” makes sense.
It makes me think of Pop Culture Detective’s video on the flaws of the Jedi Order.
You mean he made a video that wasn’t about characters’ sexual misconduct?
He did! Shocking, I know. He did read a fair bit of misogyny into the prequels, claiming that they had the subtext of “women lead men to ruin” or something similar. It’s… a bit of a hot take.
Replace the Imperial March/Vader’s Theme with the entrance theme music for the wrestler Big Van Vader.
Are we sure this is the worst ideas thread?
Better yet, deepfake Leon White (the guy who played Big Van Vader) as the unmasked Anakin.
Also, replace his final speech to Luke with this speech.
Replace the Imperial March/Vader’s Theme with the entrance theme music for the wrestler Big Van Vader.
The Lego Batman Movie is pretty good. Sadly, it’s probably one of the best of DC’s last eight years of movies.
The 25-year import law (read: a car has to be 25 years or older for it to be imported into the US) is a good rule. It’s fun to see the speculator market around vintage Japanese vehicles go crazy when a new model year gets “unlocked.” It makes the random Kei car or odd sight (like a Toyota Century or Toyota Sera) more fascinating.
Hey, man… the Book of Henry was awful, but DotF was still better than TRoS.
Let’s just say Treverrow said stuff that made me doubt his competence with the franchise.
From a Slashfilm interview in 2018:
“It’s a foundational myth. It’s a noble ghost story. Where a character lives on after death in order to guide a hero to find their strength and defeat ultimate evil. And structurally, I can’t…but you’re gonna print this, unfortunately. I’m saying this now. But the way that I look at movies, I do see Avatar and Titanic and Jurassic World [as] very similar movies. Henry was Obi-Wan Kenobi. And he died in the middle. And he left a set of instructions on how to take out the Death Star where Darth Vader was holding a Princess captive. And at the very end, when he had the target in his sights, he had to remember his training. Guided by this ghostly voice. And then Han Solo comes in with the Rube Goldberg machine and gives him the moment. And ultimately the Princess saves herself.”
I implore every DOTF fan to watch The Book of Henry.
Mauler is just CinemaSins taken to its logical conclusion. And my goodness does it suck.
Heck, I don’t even like the Plinkett reviews that much anymore, given how so many people took the wrong message from them and perpetuated this “listing little problems as critique” method.
I’m sorry, but I can’t see the word “literally” anymore without thinking about Leafy.
Also, this “every frame a pause” style of critique is terrible and I despise Mauler and his cronies for making it popular.
If Anthony Ainley’s Master can come back from being disintegrated and from being torn apart by angry folks as his simulation falls apart, Palpatine can come back from the explosion.
I’d prefer the six-track mix with insertions from the mono mix (“Blast it Wedge, where are you?,” “Close the blast doors!,” tractor beam line, Cantina music outside, the other Beru voice, and “It’s secure, move onto the next one.”). If I can’t do that, then it’s mono all the way for me.
Last I heard, he has a YouTube channel and is doing well.
Indeed, he is doing well.
Dragon Ball Dissection is arguably the best Dragon Ball-related series on YouTube.
If adywan isn’t incorporating Rogue One into his edits, is he going to incorporate The Mandalorian?
I don’t care either way, just curious…
What would he incorporate?
Boba Fett not dying?
Add LEGO Yoda death sound to Yoda’s death in ROTJ
Better yet - photoshop in a 2001 Honda Civic next to Yoda’s hut.
I find Rogue One to be the worst of the new batch of media and it’s not even close.
PM sent!
The PT was never meant to be seen before the OT.
While it does very much show in the finished product, I wonder if there are any primary sources backing up that notion during the prequels’ production.
Let’s just say Cobb Vanth removed the voice-altering settings from the OOT/Revisited.
One what does that mean.^^
Did you watch the premiere of this season of The Mandalorian? If not, Fett’s armor fell into new hands. The guy who owned it then, Cobb Vanth, might have tweaked the helmet’s voice modulation settings. That would explain the difference in voices.
Let’s just say Cobb Vanth removed the voice-altering settings from the OOT/Revisited.
The BCS example may not have been the best (since Walt never appears), but it is one of the few prequels that actually enhances the work instead of being terrible. We get a better understanding of the fictional world and just about every character outside of Walt’s family. Heck, it can reframe both shows as Jimmy McGill’s rise and fall through three key figures (Chuck McGill, Lalo Salamanca, and Walt).
I much preferred getting some actual answers on how the Empire rose and Anakin became Darth Vader.
As would I, but I’d prefer if episode order worked and we saw Anakin’s fall without knowing that he’s Vader. Give Obi-Wan a second (also fallen) pupil, maybe turn Vader into a name carried by multiple Sith apprentices, etc. there were ways to show Anakin’s fall while preserving the twists. However, by making the PT with the assumption that you’ve seen the OT, they aren’t nearly as enjoyable.
Heck, Yoda not appearing in the PT would be an excellent way to play with expectations of OT fans. Knowing who Yoda is makes his exile from the order more emotionally powerful. What could’ve happened to make the Jedi exile the wise Yoda? Well, look at Windu and the state of the order. Having other twists like that for a release order viewing would be fantastic, while preserving the validity of episode order.