BedeHistory731

Eyepainter said:

Change C-3P0’s voice from a british accent to a russian accent.

French Canadian is my pick.

Anakin Starkiller said:

I unironically want Qui-Gon in Jonh’s scene and have since the beginning, since I really wanna frame it as the finale to the entire Saga.

Same – it’s why I’d also insert Qui-Gon’s disassembled lightsaber into the deleted scene with Luke building his blade. Giving Qui-Gon more saga-wide relevance is a good thing.

Anyway, break into Lucasfilm’s archives to obtain TRoS deleted scenes, but give up and come home with only NSYNC’s deleted AotC cameos.

I’d rather come home with all the footage of the puppeteer piloting C-3P0 in TPM. That way, we can get even more Auralnauts videos!

Darth_Zounds said:

Add in a Force ghost of Padme at the end of ROTJ.

You’d be surprised with how many people would want that. Qui-Gon would make more sense, though (at least it did to TT Games).

Heck, jhon’s ghost scene with Qui-Gon and Leia added would be kinda cool.

Being serious this time, I also have tiers.

1. Hal9000’s prequel edits, Adywan’s OT edits (with 4K83 filling in for ROTJ), and Hal9000’s sequel edits
2. Clone Wars 3D cartoon, the Maul-centric episodes of Rebels, The Mandalorian and its spin-offs, and Solo.
3. The various Legends and Canon stuff I enjoy - even if it slightly contradicts itself. I’ll take the novel Death Star over Rouge One any day of the week. I’ll also acknowledge the Thrawn Trilogy over Rebels Thrawn.

I like to pick and choose.

Add the OneyPlays crew doing live commentary over the complete series.

Mocata said:

Oh the Obi-wan game… https://youtu.be/PvryRCf0-eE?t=914

That’s the most delightful glitch ever.

The only acceptable canon is Auralnauts’ Star Wars saga.

YOU PROMISED ME FLESH!

Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith, Starfighter: Special Edition, The Clone Wars, Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast have just been added to the Xbox backwards compatibility list.

That means that Star Wars: Obi-Wan and Lego Star Wars: The Video Game are the only titles from the original Xbox to be not available via backwards compatibility. I understand not wanting Lego Star Wars: The Video Game because Complete Saga has better editions of its levels, but Obi-Wan is a strange one to leave off. Given that the game can’t run on the two most prominent Xbox emulators (xemu and cxbx-reloaded), I suspect that the explanation is “technical reasons.” Either that or it’s a terrible game. I’m leaning towards a mix of both.

Somebody has modded Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga to use the Shaw ghost.

There have also been mods to give Episode III/modern ghost Anakin a more movie-accurate hairstyle.

I’ve turned hard on the prequels over the years, especially once I learned that the special editions were a tech demo for the PT. I used to be indifferent to them, then I got to the point of seeing the OOT and ST as the “true saga.”

The Clone Wars made the prequels even worse for me, especially because of how much better TCW is. ROTS now becomes a bigger letdown.

Anakin Starkiller said:

Robot Chicken already covered that scene.

I’m talking more from Vader’s perspective, where he calls Palpatine to confirm he’s alive and that the pilot felt “familiar.” Hence why a distorted hologram covers up any audio editing needed for Palpatine’s dialogue.

My idea for a Palpatine appearance would be after the Battle of Yavin, where he contacts Tie Advanced-riding Vader via hologram. Palpatine would inquire about the pilot and Vader would say he felt “a presence I’ve not felt since” (reused from earlier). One can imply that Vader is talking about the “son of Skywalker” and it sets the stage for their conversation in the next movie (where both guys know Vader is Luke’s dad). Distortion of the hologram can cover up whatever syllable mixing or speech synthesis is needed to complete the interaction.

Turn the Vader-Palpatine confrontation in ROTJ into the Prophet of Regret boss-fight from Halo 2. As in, Vader just punches a hoveringchair-bound Palpatine repeatedly.

Anakin Starkiller said:

I don’t see why you’d skip ahead a single season like that to Terror of the Autons.

Get to Delgado’s Master earlier?

Anakin Starkiller said:

Nice!

Series 1 is not really the beginning, but as a good a place to start as any!

Spearhead from Space is my recommended starting point. Either that or Terror of the Autons, because no more missing episodes (some in lower quality than others) and it’s a fun show at that point.

I’m really enjoying what you’ve done thus far! I’m curious, how are you accomplishing the audio changes regarding Greedo’s voice being “less digital?” Will it be a transplant from the '97 SE or '77 stereo mixes or is it a purely EQ effort?

Meh, the hallway scene still sucks. The Fandom Menace’s adoration for the moment ruined it for me.

4throck said:

NeverarGreat said:

As others mentioned the scene is important to complete Vader’s arc from the PT, so it should be in if possible.
Thanks for the suggestions and discussion, it’s helpfull.

Except it really isn’t. Like, at all.

On an idealistic level, I hate that scene with a burning passion. It represents all that the meatheads of the fan base want from the movies – two hours of people getting chopped up by lightsabers with no sense of magic or wonder in the fictional world. No proper character conflict or development, just Vader slashing people up for the pure visual spectacle. Heck, Luke’s re-introduction in The Mandalorian commits the same sin and those same people cling to it.

The hallway scene is the worst moment in the saga and deserves to be cut.

Anakin Starkiller said:

I watched Batman & Robin yesterday and I loved it!

I’ll defend the heck out of that movie. It’s so delightfully goofy and a genuine breath of fresh air after the DCEU nonsense.

I saw Young Frankenstein, Phantom of the Paradise, and Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story with a friend of mine recently. He really enjoyed each of them and I enjoyed having a new perspective on these films (I like all of them for their comedy style/aesthetic). Maybe it was unwise to show him Walk Hard before Bohemian Rhapsody or other formulaic musician biopics, but Walk Hard will give him a roadmap to tear those movies apart.

Phantom of the Paradise really is the best film version of the Phantom of the Opera/Faust story, if only because it feels more in-tune with the medium and very much sticks to its aesthetic. It doesn’t try to stick too closely to the source, but it gets similar ideas across. Young Frankenstein, outside of a few jokes, held up remarkably well. Wilder’s comedic stylings do transcend their time (e.g., the mood swings and the build-up to them).

SparkySywer said:

I kinda don’t see how it would improve the PT enough for it to be worth the effort

Make characterizations more consistent with TCW?

Neerb said:

BedeHistory731 said:

Replace all of the soundtrack with Spongebob music.

This is my favorite.

It’s beautiful!

Replace all of the soundtrack with Spongebob music.

I just wish Trevorrow incorporated the Sun Crusher into his script. Either that or the Galaxy Gun. 😉

fmalover said:

My only issue with TLJ is Rose’s overt idealism, as I dislike that sort of thing and also because it reeks of SJW.

🙄

G&G-Fan said:

sade1212 said:

The hard part really is just finding appropriate footage of Hayden to use. I’ve scanned through ROTS a few times (and the various deleted scenes) and never found anything at the right angle or which wouldn’t be a super obvious lift.

There’s the scene of him saying goodbye to Obi-Wan, or the balcony scene with Padme.

I mean this is a pretty great smile

Eh, it looks better later in the shot and a few shots later, with teeth showing. This nails it more:

Still, the lighting would make it very obvious that it’s not from the original. Some method of fixing it would be needed, but that’s simple.

Still, I’d say manipulation of more straight-on shots, interview footage from now, and/or deepfakery would do the trick.