- Post
- #305038
- Topic
- Info & Ideas: ESB and ROTJ Wishlist
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/305038/action/topic#305038
- Time
Originally posted by: DarthBo
The worst scene in the entire saga (yes, worse than jarjar) has to be that awful reunion scene on the rebel fleet in ROTJ. Please, shorten/cut that one. You know, the moment Luke shows up and decides to join Han and Leia... everyone starts smiling and hugging and laughing... *shivers* it's just like watching a bloody soap opera. It always felt out of place and very un-Star Wars to me.
I never got why they were so emotional anyway: they saw each other on Tatooine right? Luke went to visit Yoda after that, but as Yoda died not much after Luke arrived, it seems hard to believe Luke would stay there a few extra weeks before joining up with his friends again.
The worst scene in the entire saga (yes, worse than jarjar) has to be that awful reunion scene on the rebel fleet in ROTJ. Please, shorten/cut that one. You know, the moment Luke shows up and decides to join Han and Leia... everyone starts smiling and hugging and laughing... *shivers* it's just like watching a bloody soap opera. It always felt out of place and very un-Star Wars to me.
I never got why they were so emotional anyway: they saw each other on Tatooine right? Luke went to visit Yoda after that, but as Yoda died not much after Luke arrived, it seems hard to believe Luke would stay there a few extra weeks before joining up with his friends again.
What ever it is that you are smoking maybe you should consider stoping it cold turkey. NOTHING is worst than Jarjar. LOL
Second the scene you speak of needed to be shown with that way; the emotional reunion of good friends that have come through years of struggle to be where they are now. Not only are they about to emabark on the last great battle to try to finally defeat the empire but the scene also shows the connection Leia has with Luke who is now a little uneasy with her and she picks up on that although she doesn't know why yet....
I for one hope this scene is left just the way it is. And if it were possible my wish would be that EVERY JarJar scene be cut out and deleted from the prequels for all eternity.
