timdiggerm

That assumes that the colors of the DVD are correct.

It appears there's already a user with that name.

I won't tell you why I found out...

Puggo is 100% correct.

Having just checked DJ's GOUT V3 against PuggoGrande...

Woah. I really like how the clouds look. But I have no idea why they're only in some versions.

And then the viewer has no idea how Ani got his scars.

So yeah, I'm pretty sure that Obi-Wan has to be shown to be partially lying.

Ender, nightstalk,

While that's the obvious answer, it means you can't show Ani's death. No lava fight, no explanation for how he ended up so scarred, no nothing.

Thank you. Someone had to do it.

I'd like to know why people (including Ady, at some point in time) think it's a good idea (or even possible) to give Obi a second apprentice in the PT. If Ani's his only apprentice, you can still make Ani=Vader a surprise. So... why?

I assume you mean for the fewth time in as many years.

No, silly Bingo, Obi and QuiGon were members of the Presbyterian Church

That 10 list made me realize that the AT-AT could show up during the Endor battle, but this is only solvable if Chewie's AT-ST can take it out, or if it gets destroyed in the overly massive explosion.

So... I thought I'd make my first attempt at editing. I'm using Windows Movie Maker on a laptop, so we're talking about a lot of mistakes and SD-res (because laptop is not the fastest), and there's no fixed effects or color correction. Also, I don't really know much about editing a multi-angle scene together. But hey, it's worth a try.

https://vimeo.com/49120755

Password is OT. You can skip the Emperor's scene if you want, and nothing is different once the fleet shows up (although I should have put in one of the alien pilots), I just wanted to give the viewer as much context as they desired. Sources used are the Blu-ray deleted scenes and DJ's GOUT V3, and I'm using http://starwarz.com/starkiller/2010/05/revenge-of-the-jedi-expanded-script/ as a guide.

Harmy said:

It's up to you guys if you want to reupload it but I'd like for the MKV to be taken down when the BD is out.

I'd prefer otherwise. For folks moving in all-digital realm, the MKV takes up less space and doesn't pretend to be physical.

Yeah, this sounds like an unusual feature that pretty much only benefits broken dvd players.

I think the idea is that if you want to fix the mkv, you should dl the tracks separately and remux it. This is not difficult, from what I hear.

TV's Frink said:

 

the voices have been dubbed with milder accents

 

That's ridiculous.

Although I agree, I also sympathize. I think I've heard the Glaswegian accent and...wow.

Very interested. The longer I think about it, more interested in ROTJ changes, even the score, I become.

x-1?

Unfortunately, Kamino also has some of the most memorable bits. So all-round it's a bit of a problem.

Some guy on reddit posted this gallery:

http://imgur.com/a/wh2gQ

with the title "Pictures from my boss's Star Wars collection"

Needless to say, fascinating stuff. Pretty sure that's a real original disintegrating Yoda head.

Pagz's solution to the QG/Yoda problem is perfect. I hadn't heard of that, but it's fantastic.

As for the first problem you list, it's only a problem if your goal is making sure the viewer doesn't know Ben is lying. If your goal is preserving the surprise at the end of ESB, then just having Ani die and Vader appear as a new henchment solves the problem entirely. My stance is that it's fine if the viewer knows Ben is lying but doesn't know how much he's lying - Ben is trying to manipulate Luke into wanting to take out the Emperor's new henchman while protecting himself. After all, it would ruin a lot of his take-down-the-Emperor plans if Luke knows Obi-Wan killed his father. And why would Luke listen to a guy who killed his father? Thus, the viewer thinks, the lie.

It isn't until the end of ESB that the lie makes even more sense.

Fascinatingly, I got it from myspleen and saw no such problem

<p>This could also be a good way to track and list all the differences (audio and visual) between the versions. Scene by scene articles with variations listed.</p>

100% agree.

I'd love to get these. I'm wondering if you've heard ABC's work?

CatBus said:

It has seen the end of CGI Jabba... and will soon see the end of Joh Yowza.

!

Joh Yowza said:

No no no!