timdiggerm

It is pretty good. Not amazing, but much better than I expected.

I assume Palpatine created the EPA and gave Federal recognition to native tribes

LexX said:

Well, there’s the confirmation. Congrats to the OP, he was probably the first one to find it.

I almost wonder if OP was actually a researcher for Prop Store, running this by the fans discretely to judge if we’d accept this as true.

(for the record, I do think it’s true)

This sort of thing (for any movie) has long been the holy grail of fan editors. It has been pretty much impossible to achieve, though I’ve heard there have been good results with specialized music-removal machine-learning algorithms. But no, as far as I know, that does not exist (yet).

That being said, the movie is sufficiently visual and the music is so fundamental to the film that you might just try writing music to play under the film with no other sound.

The shoe itself is up for sale: https://propstoreauction.com/lot-details/index/catalog/359/lot/119014

I think he thinks that if he crowdsources re-creating individual scenes from the movie and then stitches them back together into a fan-made re-creation of the entire film, this will be legally free for anyone to view.

WookieeWarrior77 said:

I just thought of something. When Luke and friends are on the skiff, and he tells Han, “there’s nothing to see, I used to live here, you know” doesn’t Han know what Tatooine looks like? He’s hung out there before, in the first movie.
I’ve rationalized this to say that sure, he’s been to Mos Eisley, but hot the “middle-of-nowhere” parts like the endless sand dunes where Luke’s home was. (I don’t want there to be an issue with this line exchange because I love it)

Yeah I’m pretty sure your rationalization is the correct answer here

JadedSkywalker said:

A consistent canon is only possible through editing and retcons. Like in Tolkien for instance.

And even he left holes & mysteries undecided (origin of the Orcs, for example)

The real question is: why does anyone care about having a consistent canon?

Tobar said:

EddieDean said:

All gorgeous, though I question the need for the yellow oval flashes when blades clash. I assumed you’d be removing those, since that’s not how light works!

That’s how lightsabers work.

It’s true; light also famously doesn’t hum

I would like a lot more information

G&G-Fan said:

I find it kinda ironic that you cut the bongo sequence with the sea monsters because the cool creature stuff is the only reason I’d ever keep the journey to Otoh Gungah at all. Just my preference tho, obviously you can do what you want.

I feel like, without Otoh Gungah, Boss Nass & Co come out of nowhere in the 3rd act

Vladius said:

benroberts79 said:

I’m enjoying the show so far and personally enjoying the connection to Rebels, but I keep finding myself asking the question of where do these people go between now and the sequel trilogy?

I think it was mentioned earlier by someone else, but where’s Ashoka and Ezra in those movies. The takeaway from those was that Luke is the only one left and there is no other Jedi’s left and he’s the only hope.

Where as the Ashoka show implies that there is at least 3 other Jedi if you count Sabine. What becomes of them not to show up in the sequel trilogies.

Connecting all of this is what I’m most intrigued by and maybe we come to learn that through either this, The Mandolorian or the BoBF.

What’s very funny is that all of these problems also apply to these same characters being present during the original trilogy.

On the other hand, it’s not universe shrinkage

Ideas:

• Get them stuck in the other galaxy for awhile
• Kill them
• Kylo thought he killed them but they were in hiding
• They were elsewhere doing other stuff and never appeared onscreen (much like Ahsoka in ROTS)
• The World Between Worlds
• Some combination of the above

It’s pretty clear in ESB that Fett is working for Vader and trying to collect another bounty on Han

But yes his appearance in ANH:SE makes no sense

Overcoming years of (deserved) repressed guilt, a terrible upbringing, years of service to an abusive master, etc etc in order to save a loved one and thereby killing the Sith Lord who had masterminded a galactic war and subsequently held the galaxy under his power is undeniably great. You can’t measure Anakin without taking the end of ROTJ into consideration.

But anyway, discovering how to be one with the Force after death such that somehow you can manifest as an individual ghost is a pretty big deal so maybe it should be Qui-Gon.

Jedi122 said:

Crossvader said:

Return of the Jedi Revisited has been halted according to one of he’s recent updates, a New Hope revisited is he’s to be completed and released before he moves back onto Jedi.

There hasn’t been an update in five months. I wonder how he’s doing.

He’s posted on these forums over the summer, just no big update. I’m sure there’ll be an update when he’s ready

Chillye said:

timdiggerm said:

I mean it was a free, publicly available copy of a copyrighted work. That’s illegal.

Yeah, that’s a good answer. But it was on Internet Archive though. My guess is that maybe Puggo took it down or it violated Community Guidelines.

Or Disney finally told the IA to take it down. Or the IA is upping their enforcement in light of their recent lawsuit issues.

I mean it was a free, publicly available copy of a copyrighted work. That’s illegal.

It would benefit from somehow masking out the kids on the walkway, but other than that it’s really great

If I had the time, this is the project I would work on. Unfortunately, I don’t even have time 😦

yoshif8tures said:

Also the holograms on this show are more colour than blue. This seems like a big overlooked change

If you mean the communications holograms (since multi-colored holos have been around since the Rebel Briefing in ROTJ), this has at least been a thing since the ending of Solo

Hal 9000 said:

Mocata said:

The weird horny parts of SOTE are what audiences today are missing.

100%

Rey and Ben’s kiss was the best part of TROS because like FINALLY I’m like dust over here

I know many people hate it but I kind of agree.

Jedi122 said:

timdiggerm said:

exitzero said:

Great News! You no longer need to fix Luke’s “Force Kick”! It’s been retconned!

https://www.gamesradar.com/star-wars-mistake-luke-skywalker-kick-return-of-the-jedi/#:~:text=The implication being%2C then%2C that,that wasn’t a mistake.

That should save you 20 minutes.

Luckily those books aren’t even really canon

They are.

Oh shoot, he’s right

exitzero said:

Great News! You no longer need to fix Luke’s “Force Kick”! It’s been retconned!

https://www.gamesradar.com/star-wars-mistake-luke-skywalker-kick-return-of-the-jedi/#:~:text=The implication being%2C then%2C that,that wasn’t a mistake.

That should save you 20 minutes.

Luckily those books aren’t even really canon