timdiggerm

Prior Events, Flashbacks and the basic setup

• A flashback to Jyn’s time living with and being raised by Saw was filmed, during his shaved-head years. In this scene, shown in a trailer, he appears to be training her. This, however, means Jyn lived on Jedha.

• The film originally went from young Jyn being rescued by Saw to Jyn being taken before the Rebels to be sent to Jedha, with no introductory scene for Cassian and no rescue on Wobani in between.

The Rebellion

• The Rebels did not trust Jyn, keeping her in shackles during initial custody.

• The Rebellion know about the Death Star and its imminent weapons test before briefing Jyn. Her mission is to find out how to destroy it, not to get a defecting pilot to learn of its existence. Does this mean getting a defecting pilot from Saw on Jedha or, having already done that, is her mission to contact her father on Eadu?

• Cassian is described in promo materials as a Rebel Recruiter. Is he sent to Jedha to recruit Saw’s Partisans to the Alliance?

I thought it would be interesting to discuss the evidence available and rumors circulating about versions of Rogue One that we, the audience, have not seen. The “Rogue One * Spoilers *” Thread felt very cluttered, so I’ve made a separate thread. My goal is to use the first few replies to compile information put together in the discussion.

We can only assume C2-B5 featured heavily in some cut sequence. Possibly the stuff they filmed in the London Underground, which (given their lack of Imperial Disguises) must have been after they (with a still-okay Kaytoo) get the plans but before they leave the archives and head for the (originally separate) transmission tower.

ATMachine said:

you can see Guy Henry on set as Tarkin - in full costume, no less

I assume that they did Tarkin by filming Guy Henry, in full costume, acting as Tarkin, then replaced his head in post.

I thought the film was great. The third act, as finally released, appears to be a bit of ROTJ-fan-editor’s wishes, in as much as we got ships crashing into the shield, commandos doing stuff and good fighters & capital ship action.

Maybe it’s much cheaper for them to show Rogue One as a second-run film, which they figure people will still pay to see in January?

The shape ‘X’ can be referred to as an “Ecks” in universe without it being an Aurebesh letter. This does not explain A, B and Y-wings, unless they’re actually Osk, this-letter-didn’t-even-make-sense-in-the-first-place and Vev-wings respectively in Basic and are just translated to our letters for us.

Oh my gosh, Ronster will be here for ROTJ:R when suggestions are open!

doubleofive said:

Ezra has spent the last 3 years with a trained Jedi. Luke spends like 4 hours with Obi-Wan.

I didn’t make the connection that they’re the EXACT same age. Now I get the significance of him being born on Empire Day.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Empire_Day

Apparently, Ezra’s two days older

RU.08 said:

RooBee said:

Guys… what do you think of this?

They just announced it. I mean, come on… that poster… Mike’s talkings with Disney… Could it really be true? With an announcement of the release of the whole trilogy next year to celebrate ANH?

It says “A New Hope”, not “Star Wars”. If they were screening the original movie it would say “Star Wars”.

No, not in the modern world of franchise marketing. Calling the first film “Star Wars” is not a thing Disney would do.

Not counting the credits, of course

TV’s Frink said:

He’s planning secrets? I can’t wait to not find out!!

I’ve already not found out!

DuracellEnergizer said:

CHEWBAKAspelledwrong said:

DuracellEnergizer said:

Pfft. If you’re gonna try to sell her attractiveness on me, use the image of her in the leather BDSM garb.

TV’s Frink said:

And once again I’m reminded why there are no women on the internet.

If more women objectified men, we wouldn’t be having this problem.

Then we’d have two problems

starkiller666 said:

she is not rey’s mom

Oh I don’t really think so either, but thanks for the explanation

Exactly

and thus Rey’s mom??? Who knows.

It would be pretty cool if she turned out to actually be a secret double agent for Palpy, his personal Hand in covert affairs

And you thought Star Wars on VHS was over

An exciting conclusion?

Excitement?

In a prequel??

I was about to make a thread almost exactly like this

Maybe a rescore of the end of AOTC, to make the Republic Army less ominous could use that?

deepanddark20 said:

The director of Episode IX wants to shoot it using film and using real space footage:

http://www.theverge.com/2016/1/29/10867492/star-wars-episode-ix-shot-on-film

I guess I could see this working for re-entry atmospheric shots. But otherwise… not really practical.

TV’s Frink said:

There’s a spoiler in this thread title.

If you really don’t want to be spoiled, you shouldn’t find out about the delay until you show up to the theater in May.

I believe this is an appropriate time to say

ALLOL?

13las said:

Also, I noticed that the opening crawl seemed to jitter independently of the star field. Does anyone know if they did this on purpose? There’s no reason for that to happen if it was done digitally which I assume that it was. Right?

Yeah, I thought I saw that too. We’ll have to check the home release.

darth_ender said:

That is lame on a number of levels.

Could you explain those levels?

Can we add an option to hide all signature blocks?

Codeman said:

(sorry that this is in the fan edit section. I didn’t know where else to put it)

The Off-Topic Section?