timdiggerm

Bingowings said:

FVDnz said:

Bingowings said:

FVDnz said:

doubleofive said:

FVDnz said:

I just read something on the Wordpress page about Vader retaining his red lenses. I was actually wondering about that especially after seeing them on Vader’s helmet still intact on Rebels. Nice to hear that you’re going back to them, Ady. Your explanation makes perfect sense. 😃

Now another thing I’m wondering is the Rebel Hangar on Yavin IV. After watching fighters flying out of the Hangar on Rogue One, what’s the possibilities of seeing something similar happening on ANHR:SE? Mind you, though, the scene looks fine as it currently is anyhow.

I’m sure Ady would love to build a model of the Massassi Temple. Part of that is sarcasm, most of it is fear that he will. 😉

If he does, I shan’t be complaining lol. Heck, I recall the time when he’d mentioned something about having a scale model of Cloud City that somebody had built. Possibilities of filming multiple angles would certainly be endless! 😉

That’s no model…

Yeah, couldn’t find the exact word to actually describe what it was, maybe a maquette or something…

It’s a an actual city.

The whole dining room is one city

Sadly, I doubt Ady’s dining room has space for a bigature.

doubleofive said:

timdiggerm said:

doubleofive said:

timdiggerm said:

Agreed that this would be great, just as the battle droid was great. U-Wings parked in the Yavin hangar (though not flying out to combat, wrong type of mission for that) would be great too.

I like all of this. But, one could theorize that they only had two U-Wings and both went down at Scarif.

One could also theorize that all K2 droids were removed from Imperial Service immediately following review of footage from Jedha and Scarif demonstrating they can easily be reprogrammed and are thus a security risk.

I mean, one could

Or that we don’t see them in the 3 hallways we see in ANH.

Hah, now there’s a ridiculous, unlikely, improbable scenario.

doubleofive said:

timdiggerm said:

Agreed that this would be great, just as the battle droid was great. U-Wings parked in the Yavin hangar (though not flying out to combat, wrong type of mission for that) would be great too.

I like all of this. But, one could theorize that they only had two U-Wings and both went down at Scarif.

One could also theorize that all K2 droids were removed from Imperial Service immediately following review of footage from Jedha and Scarif demonstrating they can easily be reprogrammed and are thus a security risk.

I mean, one could

Agreed that this would be great, just as the battle droid was great. U-Wings parked in the Yavin hangar (though not flying out to combat, wrong type of mission for that) would be great too.

I was very surprised at how good the story in X-Wing: Alliance was. Even better, you can buy it from GOG or Steam, and then upgrade the graphics with the shockingly long-lived XWA Upgrade Project.

I see you’ve already got The Han Solo Adventures, so I will go ahead and recommend the The Lando Calrissian Adventures, as long as you don’t mind really weird things. My favorite part is when Lando is transformed into a giant inside a subterranean pyramid.

I apologize. This thread should not exist. Can threads be merged? Please do.

Also, being a Jedi is more than just the ability to lift things and fight with a lightsaber. There’s a lot of religious & philosophical teaching she hasn’t had.

This will be my first Star Wars film (other than Rogue One I guess) that I’ll be watching without reading spoilers.

Does this mean Luke will die after training Rey? Or is “The Last Jedi” a reference to Luke himself?

That might work, a swimming protocol droid notwithstanding. And surely the Chancellor’s special envoy to Naboo would have been briefed on the presence of a native population.

Octorox said:

Weird probably impossible idea, could C-3PO replace both TC-14 and JarJar in the Phantom Menace?

3PO belongs to the trade federation and greets Qui-Gon and Obi on the ship in the beginning (re colored and redubbed with an Anthony Daniels soundalike or Daniels’ voice clips from cartoons/radio dramas etc.)

Then he somehow accidentally stumbles onto one of the federation drop ships and winds up on the surface, saved by Qui-Gon instead of JarJar (would have to rotoscope out JarJar frame by frame and composite in new footage of an actor in 3PO costume). He accompanies them from then on, and his meet cute with R2 is moved earlier to the scene when Padme is cleaning R2 (3PO again replacing JarJar)

I like it, but how do you get them from the forest to Theed? Either you skip Otoh Gunga, in which case there’s no way of introducing the Gungans for the film’s finale, or you need to make up some way that a protocol droid goes with them to an underwater city they might not even know about.

Unless you’re discussing a version of the film in which Vader didn’t have a castle and saying reasons why, within the film “Rogue One”, they made that change, you are off topic.

I think we’re all pretty fortunate this entire board wasn’t moved to newsgroups a long time ago

Around here, people like to deny that the PT happened

Film a new, 15 year old actor to replace Jake Lloyd in TPM.

I feel like this thread is our own localized peek into the life of George R. R. Martin.

Remember when people were pissed that Diego Luna wasn’t playing Biggs, because he has a mustache?

Please Ignore This Comment.

Whereas this is a thread for piecing together what the “original” or unreleased cut(s) of Rogue One contained,

and whereas this discussion, starting with Alderaan’s comment, has turned into an argument about whether or not a certain type of film must contain certain elements, which is not the purpose of this thread,

and whereas I have now read the new Rules and Guidelines,

I declare that you guys are getting off topic, and ask that you take your argument to another thread, such as the main Rogue One discussion thread.

Back on topic, I’m intrigued by the two jedi statues, but worry that it’s just flipped shots?

Good point, and I’ve changed the wording slightly to match. Sounds like, given the lack of any major deleted scenes, that there wasn’t anything huge in there that we’re lacking, though - but I’m sure that version of the briefing was the surlier, “I rebel” Jyn.

John Gilroy said:

But we were only interested in the right way. We were interested in the right way and that’s what we went for.

Yes, thanks for that insight, John…

Great find, 005! I’ve made adjustments to the first two posts accordingly. That interview certainly puts some pieces together!

doubleofive said:

timdiggerm said:

doubleofive said:

Note the different design of the communications tower. Could be artistic license, might not be.

Matches the shot of the communications tower in the trailer

Does the comm tower look like that in the finished film?

Nope! In the finished film, they put the comm tower’s dish on top of the archives/command center and made it one building. This, as Ronster says, excised the entire sequence of Jyn & Callian running across the beach with the plans in hand, under fire from AT-ATs.

doubleofive said:

Note the different design of the communications tower. Could be artistic license, might not be.

Matches the shot of the communications tower in the trailer

sansuni said:

TV’s Frink said:

An additional month for every question you ask.

Really? How can it take a month longer just because I asked a question? Don’t you realize how ridiculous that sounds?

Yes. He is being sarcastic because he is very annoyed with people asking.