timdiggerm

Has anyone actually heard of people being confused by Ghost Shaw?

Yeah, he might be thinking of when they used the Trade Federation theme to introduce the clone troopers in AOTC. Terrible decision, I thought.

Any idea why we can't see all three ghosts at the pyre? Luke sees the first two ghosts, lights the pyre, Anakin appears, they have their private Jedi Funeral.

Admittedly, I had forgotten to even think about the PT. I'm pretty sure we got most of the OT deleted scenes.

brash_stryker said:

timdiggerm said:

brash_stryker said:

timdiggerm said:

Any plans to include the Deleted Scenes, as if this was a full-and-proper-official-release?

To be honest I could take or leave this. In order to download Revisted we're meant to own the Blu Ray set anyway, which would mean we already have a disk with the scenes on them. There's not much Ady can do to 'revisit' these scenes to differentiate his release from the official one as they are of such poor quality.

Right, obviously. It still feels like it'd be nice to have them all in one place - The "definitive" version of the film, the correct bonus features, etc.

I know how you feel. I'm a completist as well - to an obsessive degree. But the way I see it, the deleted scenes in the state in which they were released aren't fit to have the revisited name put to them. We didn't get even a tenth of the deleted scenes that are out there and that we KNOW exist (they'll "discover" a few more for the next re-release, mark my words) and the ones we did get weren't cleaned up or restored.

A tenth? I don't want to derail this thread again... but I'd love to see your list of deleted scenes, including what we got.

I'd really like to see the original cut of AOTC, in which Williams' score for the ending wasn't butchered.

brash_stryker said:

timdiggerm said:

Any plans to include the Deleted Scenes, as if this was a full-and-proper-official-release?

To be honest I could take or leave this. In order to download Revisted we're meant to own the Blu Ray set anyway, which would mean we already have a disk with the scenes on them. There's not much Ady can do to 'revisit' these scenes to differentiate his release from the official one as they are of such poor quality.

Right, obviously. It still feels like it'd be nice to have them all in one place - The "definitive" version of the film, the correct bonus features, etc.

Any plans to include the Deleted Scenes, as if this was a full-and-proper-official-release?

Paramecium302 said:

What I meant to say was, my first impression of the forum has been people complaining. Every thread has just been "George Lucas takes a dump on Star Wars fans" or "What pissed you off most about Blu-Ray release and any SE?"

Go check out the Preservations section

Luke: Jesse Eisenberg

Harmy said:

none said:

Should I feel wronged and disturbed as I saw 'West Side Story' before reading 'Romeo and Juliet'?

Yes.

This isn't a tenable position. Stories are retold, recycled, combined, etc, over and over and over. T.H. White's "The Once And Future King" was the first Arthurian story I ever read, and it's still the only. I haven't read the older versions of King Arthur...and that is okay, at least for now. I've never read the entire "The Odyssey", but I've seen "O Brother Where Art Thou". etc etc

Of all the changes/fixes Ady wants to make, Han's shirt is the most insane.

And yet he'll pull it off.

Although that's true, remember that there's nothing particularly evil looking about Vader's TIE versus other TIEs. Heck, the features that made it so unique ended up getting mostly incorporated into the Bomber in the very next film. Vader's TIE looked more powerful than the other TIEs (although it didn't actually demonstrate that), which fits with Vader's character. He is powerful.

What is the distinctive essence of Palpatine? How can that be reflected in a ship while still keeping the aesthetics of the Empire? As much as I understand why bat-wings (well, that is what that looks like) make sense, they don't fit with everything else the Empire builds.

And there's nothing wrong with naked.

Lando: Mos Def

or, add more black people elsewhere in the cast and make Lando middle-eastern or asian or something. Because obviously he has to be a token minority.....

What do you mean "evil"? This still has to be bound within the aesthetics of the Empire.

I don't find the emblem to be all that necessary, though I suppose it's fine if it looks good.The red stripe is excellent - Maybe have one on the wings too?

Bo, that was amazing.

And you didn't take out "Now THIS is podracing". Good job.

frumpsnake said:

would break absolutely everything from GPU-assisted playback to every standalone player for practically no benefit other than a minor increase in compression efficiency.

This seems like a bad idea to me.

corellian77 said:

The only minor effect that seemed like it could be improved is when the Falcon flies through the cloud on its way to Cloud City.  Its entrance and exit from the cloud didn't look entirely photorealistic to me.  There's a clear "edge"/point at which the ship ceases to be/becomes visible, whereas in a real cloud I think the ship would seem more to fade out/in from view... I hope I explained that clearly.  Anyone else think this too?

Yes, I noticed that too.

My only other criticism is the lack of Harmy-esque "decropping" of the Falcon cockpit shots. I doubt this will get fixed, though.

In which shots are the models moving incorrectly?

Rick McCallum said:

I hope that he does it, but I don’t have major arguments with him about it. I think that’s a decision he has to come to on his own as time comes by.

Wowzers.

Isn't part of the point of ROTJ that you're supposed to worry about Luke? If you don't, there's no tension in the Emperor's offer.

And don't forget that future events such as these concern us all, for the future is where we will spend the rest of our lives.

There are conventions?

Erikstormtrooper said:

Still, we could probably change our message from "You suck! Give us the originals!" to "Give us the originals. We love them!"

So in the meantime, what can we do on our own? Well, we have top men working on it.

TOP MEN.

Meanwhile, there's George-Bashing threads.