ThisIsCreation

does anyone have an edit of the full movie with the deep fakes added?

I love the current edit of the movie the idea of you guys adding even more is exciting as hell.

I was on holidays in america (orlando) in 2009, i was 14 at the time, and up until that time i had not encountered the original cuts of the movies, but i was in pizza hut and they had a vhs player playing a new hope and i was dumbfounded seeing the unaltered version. I had grown up with the 97 & 2004 edits of the movies, in which i looked at as being the normal versions.

gotedits11 said:

Hi there, I have an edit called “Twin Peaks, A Chronological Cut” which is an edit of Fire Walk with Me, S1, S2 and Twin Peaks: The Return. This cuts out a lot of the fluff in season 2, some of the slower parts of the return and then the worst bits of season 1 and fire walk with me. Drop me a PM if you want the edit, and I can let you know which parts encompass season 2.

i appreciate you replying, but i’m kind of looking for is still having most of season 2 intact, just cut james and little bits, but thank you for reaching out.

wow, this sounds really cool.

Id love to check it out.

Movies Remastered said:

I didn’t have the effects & presets option ticked. This is a game-changer. 😃 What grain settings do you use?

Here’s a second pass

https://vimeo.com/496432736
pw: fanedit

Looking at it now, Maybe the trees should be roto’d but that’s a little out my league for now.

This is really cool, it’s a little too reddish on the castle, if you turned the saturation down by 15% around the castle it would be perfect.

The first 8 or so episodes of season 2 are better than season 1, but there is so much fluff half way through the season, is there any edits out there to cut this stuff out, such as james and his useless side story.

I wish i could edit them myself, there is so much potential.

The reason i like the ESB special edition is because it doesn’t ruin the pacing in my opinon.

The jabba scene in ANH ruins the reveal of the falcon, it removes the mystique of Jabba & it is redundant. We already learned everything we need to know from Greedo.

Don’t get me started on Jedi rocks from ROTJ, but i will say i prefer the celebration song from the Special edition of ROTJ.

• could it work?
• what part of the timeline would you base it?
• what would the story be?

I have always thought the idea of an inquisitor tracking down a jedi but they fall in love would be a pretty cool story.
I would place it between ESB & ROTJ.

bit off topic, but i love how we are huge fans of the lore & continuity, while the original trilogy just flung stuff at a wall to see what sticks, & each word we examine and try to put in it’s rightful place.

Watched this last night, the restructuring of the planet destruction taking place when Han died really takes the movie up a notch. I always liked this movie, but now i feel it works better than i could ever imagine.

currently downloading this, looking forward to seeing what’s different but most of all hoping to hear some palpatine in the mix.

I think now that we know who Rey really is, i would scatter a bunch of Palpatine references here & there.

i haven’t read what Hal9000 has added as far as palpatine is concerned but i think during the scene where Kylo is probing Rey’s mind, i think hearing Palpatine’s voice from ROTJ say ‘‘I can feel your anger’’ subtly, yet audible, just as Kylo looks afraid would work well.

My brother, who is/was a surface level star wars fan, recently watched this for the first time. I have seen it several times but he wants to go through the whole series with me. That actually explains me being here & trying to obtain the best versions of the movies.

This show really upped his love for Star Wars and the larger star wars world. He loved Plo-Koon, he had forgot Plo dies, seeing as the last time he saw revenge of the sith was in the cinema in 2005 when he was 9 & i was 10.
When he got to the Order 66 montage he was so pissed off to see Plo meet his maker.

It just shows, Clone wars was able to background character and make us love them.

i like most of the special edition edits, but people removing ian mcdiarmid from ESB & re-adding the old emperor just screws with the continuity

Hal 9000 said:

Poppasketti did for TLJ, and I borrowed some of what he did. For TFA:R Sir Ridley added a subtle Emperor’s Theme as we see the Vader helmet and I added Palptine speaking during Rey’s vision.

And even if jonh did want to add more force ghosts, I’d stick with the four we have. Feels right, and it’s the only Force ghosts we’ve seen in the saga.

Wow cool, i’m going to check them out.

I watched your TROS edit last night, i had seen a version of ben & the ghost scenes done before by someone but they weren’t up to the par with the versions in your version of TROS & i was afraid they wouldn’t fit, but the versions you had were beautiful. Every decision you made improves the movie so much.
I loved listening to the commentary track too.

Has anyone gone back and added foreshadowing for Palpatine in Episode 7 & 8 yet?

id love to give this a watch. concept wise i dig it. Making a new hope fit with the rest of the lore has always been something ive wanted to do.

JakeRyan17 said:

ThisIsCreation said:

I would like a version of the movie that keeps most of Hal9000’s changes.

My only extra edits would be this:

Keep leia’s lightsaber the same colour as it is in the movie originally.
I don’t want to see the force ghosts. I don’t want to see ghost ben solo.

Id pay someone to do it.

Why so against giving Leia’s colour the colour Carrie Fisher desired while also making it distinct from the other lightsaber being used in the scene (which helps show/emphasise that Ben uses his grandfather’s saber)?

I get not having all the ghosts in the climax… but taking Ben out of the final ghost scene was a big issue for me personally. It felt dismissive of his character arc and Rey’s as well for that matter.

Just curious to hear your reasoning.

actually the more i think about it the more im alright with the lightsaber, but i would like to ghosts removed, especially Ben’s. Simply because we don’t know what they might do in the future with him.

i would love this but without the force ghosts & only leia & luke at the end & Leia’s lightsaber staying its original colour… I would consider this the perfect cut then.

I would like a version of the movie that keeps most of Hal9000’s changes.

My only extra edits would be this:

Keep leia’s lightsaber the same colour as it is in the movie originally.
I don’t want to see the force ghosts. I don’t want to see ghost ben solo.

Id pay someone to do it.

edit: ive seen hal’s version now, ignore the above.

i would love to check this out. it sounds really interesting.

i would love this.

This thread feels like a time capsule.

Taking the last season of Mando into consideration, that is definitely not the razor crests.

jedi_bendu said:

It’s a shame this thread hasn’t got replies yet, it’s an interesting question. SE changes are mostly colour grading and added effects shots or things; perhaps fixing lighting problems is a whole other feat. Personally, I’m glad the speeder chase hasn’t been tampered with, because I much prefer movies being true products of their time, and I enjoy the action no matter how the effects have aged.

I totally agree. i am content with it being the way it was originally, it was just a question that has always been on my mind seeing as George likes to tamper with things.